Callout 1 of 6
Open-cell or closed-cell foam under your slopes
Spray foam insulation starts as a liquid sprayed between the rafters, the sloping timbers that carry the roof, where it expands and sets against the underside of the tiles, slates, felt or membrane. It was sold to some owners as a way to warm a loft and to others as a cure for slipped tiles, because the set foam glues the covering to the battens, the thin timbers the tiles hang on. From the loft hatch of a stone cottage near the Wye or a brick semi in Leominster it can look tidy. What matters is which kind of foam it is and what it now covers.
The Energy Saving Trust says "There are two main types of spray foam insulation, closed-cell and open-cell." Closed-cell foam is dense and hard once it sets, and the Energy Saving Trust says its "main drawback is that it's not vapour permeable", so moisture in the loft air cannot pass through it. Open-cell foam is softer and lighter, and the same guidance calls it "the more vapour permeable" of the two. Neither type lets anyone see the timber behind it, and that is the point a surveyor will raise. The Energy Saving Trust's spray foam guidance describes both.
You can get a fair idea from the loft. Closed-cell foam feels rigid and is hard to dent with a thumbnail. Open-cell foam gives under a finger and can be torn by hand. Neither test is proof, so at the survey we cut a small sample from a corner, look at the texture through the cut and note how far the foam runs: just between the rafters, or over their faces too, down into the eaves and up towards the ridge. We also ask for any paperwork the installer left, because a product name and a fitting date help everyone who reads the file later, a buyer's surveyor included.
Where the foam was sprayed matters as much as the type. Foam on bare tiles or slates has nothing between it and the covering, so taking it off can disturb the tiles from inside. Foam sprayed onto felt or a breathable membrane, the sheet laid under the battens to catch wind-driven rain, can bond to that sheet and tear it as it comes away. Our guide to open-cell and closed-cell spray foam sets out the differences in more depth. Spray foam insulation removal in Hereford, and for local homes out across Herefordshire into Worcestershire, Gloucestershire, south Shropshire and the Welsh border counties, begins with this look at the foam, because what we find shapes the method, the time on site and the cost.
Telling the two foams apart
- Closed-cell
- Hard and rigid, hard to dent, not vapour permeable
- Open-cell
- Soft and spongy, tears by hand, the more vapour permeable
- Sprayed onto
- Bare tiles or slates, felt, or a breathable membrane
- Coverage
- Between the rafters only, or over their faces as well
- Paperwork
- Product name and fitting date, if the installer left any
Foam that holds a slipped tile in place has not repaired it. It has only hidden it.









