01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Foam and lenders

Spray foam in your roof: why surveyors and lenders raise it

Foam applied under the roof covering can cover the very timbers a surveyor wants to see. Here is why it comes up at a sale or a remortgage, and what the published guidance says.

Horizon Roofing Hereford 9 min read

Spray foam was sold for years as a quick way to insulate a loft, and some homes now have it stuck to the underside of the roof. The trouble tends to arrive later, when someone sells, buys or remortgages and a surveyor looks into the roof space.

What the surveyor sees there matters. A roof lined in foam cannot be inspected the way a bare rafter and batten roof can, and the next question is what is happening to the timber behind the foam. A lender asks that question through its valuer, and the answer shapes what the lender says next.

This post sets out what RICS said in March 2023, what the Energy Saving Trust says about the open-cell and closed-cell kinds, why timber is the worry, and what an owner can do about it. It also covers the insulation rules that apply once foam comes out, which differ between England and Wales.

What a surveyor sees in a foam-lined roof

On an ordinary pitched roof a surveyor can look from the loft at the rafters, the battens, the underlay and the back of the tiles. That view shows daylight, damp patches, rot and rusted nails. Foam sprayed onto the roof's underside covers nearly all of it, so the surveyor sees a pale, bumpy surface and cannot see the timber. Where the layer is thick, even the shape of the rafters is lost.

The report then has to record that part of the roof could not be inspected. A buyer who reads that line has a reason to ask more questions, and a lender who sees it has a reason to ask its own through the valuer.

What a surveyor looks for first in such a roof:

  • Foam stuck to the underside of the tiles or slates, which makes later repairs awkward
  • Foam laid over the underlay, battens and rafters, so that nothing behind it can be checked
  • Whether the foam went on as a thin coat or as a deep layer
  • Signs of damp or staining that show at the edges, near the eaves or round the chimney
  • On an old roof with no underlay, foam running straight onto the reverse face of the tiles or slates

A roofer inspects one from the loft and from outside, and the check has limits that we explain before we start. A loft hatch and a torch are the minimum. We photograph what we find, so you hold the same pictures a buyer or a lender would ask to see.

What RICS said in March 2023

The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors put out a consumer guide on spray foam insulation, introduced by a press release dated 3 March 2023. In it, RICS recorded unease in parts of mortgage lending, with equity release named as one such area, and told owners to raise the matter with their mortgage provider.

The release says the unease had spread beyond its first sector and was by then having a "wider impact" on lenders. Equity release appears there as an example, and the release does not name it as the place where the concern began.

The consumer guide gives owners one plain instruction, which is to confirm with the mortgage provider that the lender's own policy permits spray foam products at all. That is advice to anyone thinking of foam, and to anyone who has it already.

Two limits matter when you read it:

  • The release reports concern and tells you to ask, and it sets out no rule that binds every lender
  • Each lender keeps its own policy, which can change over time, so what one accepts another may query

For more on what RICS has published, see our guide to what RICS says about spray foam. If you are asking the lender yourself, put the question in writing, say which type of foam it is if you know, and file the answer with your papers so that a buyer's solicitor can see it later.

Open-cell and closed-cell foam

Not all spray foam is alike, and the difference bears on the timber behind it. The Energy Saving Trust, on a page last updated on 26 October 2026, describes spray foam as coming in two main kinds, closed-cell and open-cell.

The two kinds of spray foam, as the Energy Saving Trust describes them
TypeWhat the Energy Saving Trust says
Closed-cellIts main drawback is that it is "not vapour permeable"
Open-cellPasses more vapour; the Trust calls it the "more vapour permeable" of the pair

Vapour permeable means moisture in the air can pass through the material. A foam that does not let it through keeps moisture on the room side, and a foam that does lets some of it move on. Which one is on your roof matters to anyone judging the timbers, and the room below will not tell you.

Telling them apart takes a look at the surface from the loft, and our guide to open or closed cell spray foam shows what to look for. A product that has been pressed with a thumbnail behaves differently in the two cases, though a survey should not rely on that alone.

Ask the firm that fitted it for the data sheet. A sheet that names the product settles the question and gives a surveyor something to read, which does more for a sale than an argument about the foam.

Why timber is the worry

The concern about foam on a pitched roof is about the rafters and battens behind it. Timber stays sound when it can dry. Foam applied on the rafter side of a roof changes how the roof breathes, and a roof that cannot dry may hold moisture against the wood for years without anyone seeing it.

The Energy Saving Trust says that "Spraying foam directly to the underside of the roof will partially seal the timber". It then adds that "this risk should be much lower with an open-cell foam". Both statements are hedged. The risk is not described as nil, and the Trust does not say every closed-cell roof is in trouble.

That hedge is the right way to read it. It means:

  • The concern is real enough for the Trust to name it
  • The risk differs between open-cell and closed-cell foam
  • Nobody can tell from the room whether a given roof has a problem
  • The only way to know is to look at the timber itself

If a survey has raised a concern, a roofer can lift a small area of foam or the covering at an edge and photograph the wood beneath. That one look can tell a buyer or a lender more than a vague worry does, because it replaces a guess with a picture, and a picture of dry, sound wood can close the matter. A picture of damp or darkened timber is just as useful, because it tells you early, while the repair is still a small one.

What an owner can do

A flagged roof is a problem to be solved in order, and the cheap steps come first.

  1. Identify the foam: the cell type, the installer, the year and any paperwork you hold.
  2. Ask your own lender, or the buyer's lender, what its policy on spray foam is, which follows the RICS advice to check with your mortgage provider.
  3. Ask for a roof inspection that includes a look at the timber, with photographs of what is found.
  4. Decide, once the facts are in, whether to leave the foam, to have an area opened for a look, or to have it removed.

Removing foam is not always the answer. If a buyer's surveyor has already flagged the roof, our guide to what to do when a buyer's surveyor flags spray foam is the place to start, and it explains how a seller can respond.

If the foam was sold to you on a promise that turned out wrong, the Citizens Advice consumer helpline on 0808 223 1133 gives advice on your rights. The Welsh-speaking adviser is on 0808 223 1144. The same service covers England and Wales.

Where you ask us to look, we go into the loft, photograph the foam and the edges, and show you what is there. The written total for any removal follows the survey, and if the foam can stay, that is what the report says.

Keep every reply from a lender and every survey photograph in one folder. A buyer's solicitor will ask for them, and a seller who has them ready saves days.

If the foam comes out: costs and the rules after

Third-party guides give a sense of scale, though not our prices. MyJobQuote, on a page dated 17 September 2026, gives spray foam removal as £40 per m², and around £3,200 for a three-bed detached property. Checkatrade, in July 2026, also gives around £3,200 for removing roof foam from a three-bedroom detached house, with £50 to £75 per m² quoted for open-cell and around £80 to £100 per m² for closed-cell foam. A per-square-metre figure describes a unit of area, never the total for your roof.

Once the foam is out, new insulation is needed, and the approved documents set different figures in the two nations:

  • In England, Approved Document L (Table 4.3) gives a roof a renovation threshold of 0.35 and an improved value of 0.16, with a relaxation in paragraph 4.13 where payback is longer than 15 years.
  • In Wales, Table 11.1 asks for 0.16 and accepts nothing worse than 0.35 where 0.16 cannot be reached, and the whole element is brought up once over half of it is renovated.
  • On ventilation, Marley asks 25mm along the eaves for pitches of 15 degrees or less, and 10mm above that, where the underlay is high resistance.

Our guide to spray foam removal describes how the work is done, from the first survey to the clear-up, and the written total covers the whole job. If you are selling, ask for the report and photographs in a form a solicitor can pass on.

Questions on foam, surveys and mortgages

Does spray foam affect a mortgage application?

It can, because lenders set their own policies. RICS reported unease in parts of mortgage lending in March 2023 and told owners to ask their provider. The answer has to come from the lender, ideally before you apply, and a reply in writing is worth keeping.

Is open-cell foam kinder to the roof timbers?

The Energy Saving Trust says open-cell foam, which passes more vapour than closed-cell, should carry a much smaller rot risk from sealing the timber. That is a lower risk and not no risk, so a roof with either type can still be looked at before anyone decides.

Can the foam be checked without removing it all?

A small area can be opened at an edge, or the covering lifted in one place, to photograph the timber behind. That gives a surveyor or lender a picture in place of a worry. Whether the rest should come out is a decision to take once the photograph shows the state of the wood.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing