Short answer
No. There is no rule that foam has to come out of every roof. Whether it stays depends on the type, on the state of the timber, underlay and covering behind it, on whether the roof leaks, and on what your mortgage provider or a buyer will accept. We survey first, and we tell you plainly when leaving it where it is makes better sense than stripping it.
The questions that settle it
Foam is not one product, and a roof lined with it is not one case. Before anyone talks about stripping, a handful of questions need an answer, and most of them can only be settled by looking.
- Which type is it? The Energy Saving Trust describes two main kinds, one closed-cell and the other open-cell, and the pair behave differently around timber.
- Where was it sprayed: between the rafters only, or over battens, the underlay and the backs of the tiles?
- Is the covering sound, or are there slipped tiles, worn flashings or an old valley above it?
- Is the timber dry and firm wherever it can be tested?
- What do your lender and any buyer expect?
- Is a re-roof planned soon, so the foam would have to be dealt with anyway?
If you are not sure which foam you have, our guide to which spray foam you have helps you tell by looking and pressing. A rigid, unyielding surface suggests closed-cell, and a soft, spongy one suggests open-cell. Either way, a photograph taken from the loft hatch is a useful first step, and a note of when the foam was fitted and by whom, if you know, saves time at the survey.
When leaving the foam alone is reasonable
If the foam is open-cell, the covering above it is sound and the timber tests dry, there may be no case for removal at all. On the question of rot, the Energy Saving Trust takes the view that open-cell foam carries a danger that "should be much lower", though lower never means none. That is a reason to inspect and keep watch, not a reason to strip.
A roof that has been checked from outside and found weathertight, with a loft that shows no staining, damp smell or soft timber, can sensibly carry on as it is. We would still note the foam type, take photographs for your records and suggest the roof is looked at again if the covering is ever disturbed. Any repair done through foam is harder than one done on a bare roof, and our answer on whether foam stops tiles being repaired explains why.
Stripping a roof that does not need it costs money. MyJobQuote's average of £40 per m² means that removal is no small spend, so a decision to go ahead should rest on a named reason, and finding one is what the survey is for.
When taking it out is the better answer
Removal comes into view when something specific points to it. A leak that has run behind the foam, soft timber found at an eaves or a stack, or a covering that is due for replacement all give a reason. So does a lender that will not lend against the house, or a buyer's surveyor who refuses to sign it off.
On lending, RICS noted in March 2023 that equity release lending was one place where unease had surfaced, and its consumer guide tells owners to ask their mortgage provider where it stands. The answer can differ from one lender to the next. That should not be taken to mean that every lender declines.
Sometimes the sensible step sits between the two. Opening one bay to look at the timber costs less than a whole slope, and what it shows decides the next move. If the wood is sound, the section is closed up again. If it is not, you will have the evidence and photographs in hand before any larger decision is made.
What changes if the foam does come out
Taking foam out leaves the roof short of insulation, and England and Wales set different standards for putting it back. In England, Approved Document L 2021 Table 4.3 names 0.35 as the threshold and 0.16 as the improved U-value for an existing roof that is being renovated. In Wales, the Welsh Approved Document L Table 11.1 also gives 0.16, with 0.35 as the worst acceptable figure where 0.16 is not feasible. Our answer on the insulation level after foam removal goes through both in more detail.
Re-covering rules differ too. The England test on the Planning Portal asks two things: whether less than 25 per cent of the total building envelope is affected, and whether less than 50 per cent of the roof is. Both must hold for an application to be normally unnecessary. In Wales, re-roofing needs Building Regulations approval in most situations, according to the Welsh Government, so ask the council's building control team early.
None of this applies until a decision has been made. Our spray foam removal service begins with the survey that makes the decision possible, and the written price that follows is one total.
