Ask five owners what is stuck under their roof and you may get five answers: foam, insulation, the spray stuff, the white sponge. Underneath the names there are only two kinds that matter to a roofer, and the Energy Saving Trust, which gives independent energy advice, sets them out plainly: closed-cell and open-cell.
The distinction is not a matter of brand. It decides how the foam copes with moisture vapour, how closely a surveyor wants to look at the timber behind it, how it is taken off the rafters and what the work costs. It also decides how much a published statement can tell you about your own loft, and that is less than the headlines suggest.
Where we quote the Trust, the wording is exact, including the words that soften a claim, such as "should" and "much lower", because those words are the point. The sections below cover each kind, how to tell which you have, what changes at removal and what a lender may say. The full job is described on our spray foam removal page, and the loft side of the story sits in what spray foam does to roof timbers.
Two kinds of foam, and what separates them
Both kinds start as a liquid mixed on site and sprayed between or over the rafters, where it expands and sets. The names describe the structure of the set foam. In closed-cell foam the tiny bubbles are sealed off from one another, which makes a dense, firm material. In open-cell foam the bubbles are connected, which makes a lighter, softer one that feels like a sponge.
That structure is what matters for moisture. Sealed bubbles do not let vapour through. Connected bubbles let more of it pass. The Energy Saving Trust puts the two points this way. Of closed-cell foam it says the "main drawback" is that it is "not vapour permeable". Of open-cell foam it says that it is "the more vapour permeable". Notice the comparative: more vapour permeable, not freely permeable, and not the same thing as a roofing membrane designed to breathe.
Neither description says one foam is good and the other bad. Each says how the foam deals with vapour. What that means for a roof depends on the covering above it, the underlay beneath the covering, the ventilation of the loft and the way the house is used day to day, including how much steam it makes.
That is why a statement about foam in general is a starting point and never a verdict. The roof in front of us has its own history, its own tiles or stone, and its own ventilation, and the survey reads all of that before anything is said about what should happen next.
Closed-cell foam and its stated drawback
The Trust is direct about closed-cell foam, and it is worth reading what it says and what it leaves unsaid. The drawback it names is vapour: the foam does not let it through. The advice stops there. It does not say that a roof lined with closed-cell foam will rot, and a surveyor cannot say so either without seeing the timber.
What the drawback does is shift the question. Moisture in the air of a house, from cooking, washing and breathing, moves upwards into the loft. On a conventional cold roof it can leave through ventilation openings. Where foam fills the space and cannot pass vapour, the roof timber behind it is a place where moisture could collect, and where nobody can see it.
The same foam has a practical effect at removal. Set closed-cell foam is firm and rigid, so it is cut into sections and lifted, and that is slower work than clearing a soft foam. The cost figures further down reflect it.
If you have closed-cell foam, the questions for a survey are:
- is the timber behind it dry, and how can that be shown?
- is the foam bonded to the underlay, the tiles or both?
- can the roof be ventilated and re-insulated without disturbing the covering?
- has any water entered from above, through a slipped tile or a gap at a flashing?
Each answer changes the plan, which is why none is assumed.
Open-cell foam and the Trust's careful hedge
For open-cell foam the Trust is more reassuring, but it chooses its words with care. On timber, it says that foam sprayed to a roof's underside will partially seal the timber, and then adds: "But this risk should be much lower with an open-cell foam." Two softeners sit in that sentence, and they stay there when we repeat it. The risk "should" be reduced, and it is "much lower", which still leaves a risk. For a homeowner that matters most when the roof is old, because an ageing covering may let water in from above, and open-cell foam does not stop water from reaching the timber.
That is how we use it. We never write that open-cell foam is safe, and we never quote the Trust without its hedge. A roof with open-cell foam gets the same survey as one with closed-cell foam, because the foam covers the timber in both cases, and covered timber cannot be judged by looking at its surface.
Two further points matter about open-cell foam:
- it is soft, so it can be cut back and peeled, which is generally quicker than lifting rigid sections
- it can hold moisture if the roof above it leaks, so a slipped tile or a split in the underlay matters more than the foam type suggests
Our answers page on whether open-cell foam is breathable deals with the word "breathable", which roofing uses for something narrower than the Trust's "vapour permeable". A foam can pass some vapour without being a breathable membrane, and the difference decides what the loft needs afterwards.
Telling them apart in your own loft
You can learn which kind you have without damaging anything. Look at the foam from the hatch and use a gentle fingertip on an out-of-the-way patch, or ask us to do it at the survey. Do not cut into it to find out; the cut can open the sheet or the batten behind.
| Sign | Points to open-cell | Points to closed-cell |
|---|---|---|
| Feel | Soft, gives under a fingertip | Firm, rigid, resists a press |
| Texture | Spongy, with a ragged cut edge | Smooth, tight, with a clean cut edge |
| Weight of an offcut | Light | Heavier for its size |
A cut edge at the hatch frame or beside a pipe is the best place to look, as it shows the inside of the foam. Take a photograph of it with a ruler beside it and send it with your enquiry. If the loft floor is boarded, say so, because boards hide the foam at the eaves, where the end edge of the foam can tell most about what lies beneath. A clear picture can settle it, though some foams sit between the descriptions and the survey then decides.
The paperwork can help as much as the foam. Look for the installer's invoice or a data sheet, which may name the product and say whether it was open-cell or closed-cell. Our short answer on which spray foam you have sets out the same checks in question-and-answer form.
What the difference changes at removal
The kind of foam sets how the job is planned, what it takes and what it costs. Third-party guides give typical UK ranges, and they are not our prices. Checkatrade's July 2026 guide puts open-cell removal at £50 to £75 per m², with closed-cell dearer at around £80 to £100 per m². MyJobQuote gives an average of £40 per m² for spray foam removal without splitting it by type. Each per-m² number is for comparing the kinds with one another and is never a total for a roof.
| Point | Open-cell | Closed-cell |
|---|---|---|
| Lifting | Cut back, peeled and scraped | Cut into sections and lifted off |
| Third-party cost range | £50 to £75 per m² (Checkatrade) | Around £80 to £100 per m² (Checkatrade) |
| Main survey question | Has the foam held water from above? | Is the timber behind it dry? |
In either nation the foam comes off in the same way. The two nations part company over the insulation that goes back, because England and Wales each have their own Part L figures for a renovated roof, covered in the later guides in this set.
Afterwards you get a single written figure for the whole job. It reflects the foam type along with the area sprayed, the thickness and the access, and the quote should say plainly whether VAT and scaffold are in it. Neither third-party range covers what the foam was hiding, such as battens or underlay that need replacing, which only show once the foam is lifted.
Which kind a lender or a buyer worries about
When a house is sold or remortgaged, the lender's view counts for more than ours. Neither RICS statement on lending separates open-cell from closed-cell foam, so the general caution about foam under roofs applies to both kinds.
RICS, the surveyors' professional body, reported in March 2023 that unease had reached parts of the mortgage market, and named equity release mortgages as one example. Its consumer guide gives owners a single instruction: put the question to the mortgage provider, since a lender's policy decides whether such products are allowed. Equity release is an example in that report and not the point where the unease began.
That leaves a sensible order of steps:
- Find out what you have, using the signs in this guide and the survey.
- Ask your lender or conveyancer what their policy says for your product.
- Decide whether to leave the foam, remove it or have it assessed first.
Leaving it is a choice some owners reasonably make, and we tell you so when a survey shows dry timber and a sound roof. Where timber is damp or the covering above has failed, removal is the better route, and the photographs from your own roof show why. A buyer's surveyor may ask the same questions from the other side, so the same evidence helps at a sale. A seller weighing removal before listing has three things to balance: what the survey shows about the timber, what the buyer's lender will accept, and how much time is left before exchange.
