Spray foam was fitted to keep heat in. Take it away and the roof is bare: rafters and battens with nothing between the rooms and the weather except the covering. Leaving it that way is not an option for a lived-in house, so every foam removal job ends with a new insulation layer and a plan for how the loft will breathe.
What that layer must achieve is set by Part L of the Building Regulations, the part dealing with fuel and power, and Part L is not the same in the two nations. England follows Approved Document L, volume 1, 2021 edition. Wales follows its own Approved Document L, volume 1, 2022 edition. Each has a table for a roof that is renovated rather than built new, and the figures and triggers differ.
This guide sets out both tables in plain terms, then turns to ventilation, which decides whether the new layer stays dry. Nothing here replaces a decision by building control, either the council or a registered building control approver, who tells you how the tables apply to your house. For the whole job, see our spray foam removal page.
What goes back once the foam is off
A pitched roof can be insulated in two broad ways, and the choice sets everything that follows. With a cold roof, the insulation lies along the ceiling line and the void above it stays cold and ventilated. With insulation in the slope, it fills the depth between the rafters or lies over them, and the loft joins the heated part of the house.
Welsh Table 11.1 recognises insulation along the ceiling or between the rafters, and also covers flat roofs and roofs with insulation built into the construction. Which suits a house depends on how the loft is used. A loft kept for storage suits a cold roof. A loft that is a bedroom, or may become one, needs its insulation in the slope.
Building law has a name for the roof as a part of the building: a thermal element. Regulation 2 of the Building Regulations 2010 defines the term to cover the structure of a roof, wall or floor, and keeps the glazed and door openings in them apart. It is the roof structure that is rated, while windows set into it carry figures of their own.
When we survey a foam-lined roof we note the choices open to you:
- how deep the rafters are, which limits what can go between them
- whether the slope has an underlay, and of what kind
- whether the loft is used, or planned to be
- what the ceiling below is made of and how well it is sealed
Our answer on foam or mineral wool between rafters looks at the material question.
England: Table 4.3 and the fifteen-year relaxation
For a house in Herefordshire, Worcestershire, Gloucestershire or Shropshire, Approved Document L 2021 applies, and it took effect for England on 15 June 2022. Its Table 4.3 deals with existing elements that are renovated or kept, and loft conversions fall under it. For a roof, the table sets a threshold of 0.35 and an improved value of 0.16, in W/(m²·K), the unit for heat loss, in which a smaller figure is a better roof.
So a kept roof that is worse than 0.35 is raised to 0.16 when it is renovated. Paragraph 4.13 then gives England a way out. Where 0.16 is impractical, or the energy saved would need more than 15 years to repay the outlay, the roof gets the best figure that does repay itself inside 15 years. The paragraph adds that an element improved this way should in general not be worse than 0.7.
Table 4.2 is a separate table, for new fabric added to an existing dwelling. Its roof figure is 0.15. For glazing in the slope it gives roof windows 1.4 or WER Band B, and rooflights 2.2. Which table a foam removal job falls under is for building control to say, and we put the question to them before the work, not after.
One practical point follows from all this. Because the foam hid the roof, nobody can say today which of these tables a given house will meet until the timbers and the covering have been seen, which is why the survey and the opening-up come before any insulation order is placed.
Wales: Table 11.1 and the half-of-the-element trigger
For a house in Monmouthshire, Powys or the Bannau Brycheiniog National Park, the Welsh Approved Document L applies, and it took effect for Wales on 23 November 2022. Its Table 11.1 deals with retained fabric. For a pitched roof insulated along the ceiling or between the rafters, and for a flat roof or one with insulation built in, column (a) reads 0.16 and column (b) reads 0.35.
The two columns do different jobs. Column (a) is the target for retained fabric. Column (b) is the limit, the worst figure that Wales accepts. Paragraph 11.14 sets the trigger: once the renovated area passes half of the surface of that thermal element, the entire element is brought up to standard, and a major renovation touching a quarter of the building envelope has the same effect.
Paragraphs 11.20 and 11.21 supply the Welsh way out. Where 0.16 cannot be justified, the best achievable standard applies, with column (b) as the usual floor. Repaying the outlay from energy savings within 15 years is the economic test.
A completely new roof element on a Welsh house falls under Table 4.1 instead, at 0.13, which is tighter than England's 0.15. A roof you are keeping, whether it is re-covered or re-insulated, falls under Table 11.1. The Welsh Government's re-roofing page says re-covering work should include improving the roof's thermal insulation. So on a Welsh job we raise the insulation question at the same time as the covering question, and the two are priced together in one written total, with the survey photographs showing building control what was found.
The two nations side by side
The renovation figures look alike at first and work differently in practice. This table sets them next to one another, with the document each comes from.
| Point | England | Wales |
|---|---|---|
| Table | AD L 2021, Table 4.3 | Welsh AD L, Table 11.1 |
| Target figure | Improved value 0.16 | Column (a) 0.16 |
| Other figure | Threshold 0.35 | Limiting value 0.35 |
| What 0.35 means | Starting point for upgrading | Worst acceptable result |
| When the target is impractical | Best figure that repays in 15 years; in general no worse than 0.7 | Best feasible figure; in general no worse than column (b) |
The difference in the 0.35 row is the one to remember. In England it is the figure that sets the work off, and in Wales it is the floor below which a roof must not fall. A house on either side can end up at 0.16, and the route to it is not the same.
Glazing in the slope is held to the same figures on both sides of the border. If a window is swapped during the same visit, it goes in the same plan as the insulation, and the written price covers the lot as a single total. Taken together, the figures give building control one picture of the work, and they give you one set of papers to keep. A Welsh owner and an English owner can therefore end with a similar-looking roof and a different file behind it, which is worth knowing before a sale.
Ventilation: whether the new layer stays dry
Insulation put back without a plan for ventilation can fail where the foam did. Marley, a tile maker, gives openings for a cold roof, working to BS 5250, the code of practice for managing moisture in buildings. Marley's figure for HR underlay is a continuous opening along the eaves of 25mm at pitches of 15° or less, and 10mm at pitches above 15°.
High resistance underlay passes no vapour, so the loft depends on those openings. A low resistance, air-permeable underlay behaves differently. Marley says that beneath a tight ceiling the 3mm of ordinary eaves construction can do the job, so long as the product's certification terms are followed.
These are one maker's figures for its own products. The sheet we fit has its own data sheet, and we follow it. What stays the same is the principle:
- air must be able to enter at the eaves and leave higher up
- insulation must not be pushed hard into the eaves, blocking the gap
- the ceiling below must be sealed around hatches, pipes and light fittings
- a roof insulated in the slope is ventilated by its own detailing, never left to chance
Our answer on loft ventilation after foam removal takes the same subject in short form. Between them, the underlay, the eaves openings and the sealed ceiling decide whether warm damp air leaves the house or settles in the roof.
How much goes back, and when the rules change
No thickness is given here because none can be stated without a roof in front of us. The thickness depends on the material chosen and its data sheet, on the depth of the rafters, and on which of the figures above applies. The insulation maker's data sheet turns a U-value target into a thickness, and that sheet goes with the quote. Our answer on insulation level after foam removal covers the idea further.
Both nations are due new editions. England's AD L 2026 begins on 24 March 2027 for work other than higher-risk building work. It renumbers the tables, so new elements move to Table 3.2 and existing elements to Table 3.3, and the payback rule becomes paragraph 3.14. In Wales, the successor to the 2022 edition begins on 4 March 2027. Until those dates, the 2021 English and 2022 Welsh editions apply to the work described here.
Which edition a particular job falls under is a question for building control on your side of the border, and we put it to them before work starts. The answer goes into the paperwork you keep, along with the product data sheets and our photographs.
Once the new layer and the ventilation are in, nothing is left behind in the loft or on the drive when we go. You are left with a loft that can be inspected, which the foam had made impossible, and with papers that show a buyer or a surveyor exactly what was done.
