In brief
Mostly, yes, where the foam is gripping timber and not the covering. Where it has bonded to the underside of the covering, some pieces may crack as it is freed. We lift the covering carefully, clear the foam from the back of each piece, and relay the sound ones. Any that break are replaced with a match for size, thickness and colour, and you are shown which.
What the foam is actually touching
The answer depends on where the foam went. Spray foam is applied from inside the loft, so its first contact is with the rafters, the underlay and the battens. Whether it reaches the covering itself depends on how the roof was built and how much was applied.
Before a price is given, we look at three things from the loft side and, where it is safe, from the outside:
- foam sitting on the rafters only, with the underlay and battens clear
- foam bonded to the underlay and the battens, which is the usual case to deal with
- foam that has pushed through gaps and reached the underside of the covering
The first two do not touch the covering at all, and the foam can be taken off with the roof left as it stands. The third is where tiles are at risk, because the foam has hold of the piece you see from the street.
Each case is photographed, and you see the pictures before any work is agreed. Our guide to how spray foam is removed follows the whole process from the loft out.
How the covering is lifted and saved
Where foam has reached the covering, the tiles come off in order, course by course, and the foam is cleared from the back of each one before it is stacked. Pieces that are sound go back; pieces that crack are put to one side to be replaced. Taking a tile off cleanly is a skill in itself, because old fixings can be corroded and a tile can snap at the nail hole.
| Covering | Where it breaks |
|---|---|
| Concrete tile | Edges and the surface coat |
| Clay tile | Nibs and corners |
| Natural slate | Head, at the nail holes |
| Stone tilestone | Edges, and in layers |
Natural slate replacements are matched on length, width, thickness and colour, and Welsh, Spanish and reclaimed slates all look different. For Herefordshire stone tilestones, SPAB's advice is that a claim of unavailability or of long delivery "should always be checked with the quarries", so a quarry is asked before any other stone is suggested.
High-powered jet washing is not the answer for any leftover residue on the face. Marley says it is not recommended because it can damage the surface of slate or tile.
What breakages cost, in third-party figures
A tile that breaks is a small cost and not a reason to avoid removal. Which?, surveying Trusted Traders in November 2025, gives £75 to £400, excluding VAT, for fixing a handful of standard tiles, one to six, that have broken or gone missing.
Checkatrade's June 2026 repair guide gives rates per m², excluding VAT, on a patch of up to 3 m²:
- concrete tiles, £90 to £120 per m²
- clay tiles, £110 to £160 per m²
- natural slate, £150 to £220 per m²
Those are the guide's own rates for a repair patch, so we never scale them up to a figure for a whole roof. A foam job that damages a handful of tiles is priced as removal plus a few replacements, not as a new roof.
The price arrives in writing after the survey as a single total, with scaffold and VAT stated. If the covering looks too brittle to lift without losing many pieces, you hear it before work begins, with the photographs that back it up. In that case a conversation about roof repairs after foam removal comes first, and re-covering is the fallback.
Relaying the covering, England and Wales
Tiles put back are fixed as the roof needs. Marley points out that BS 5534 carries no force of law, though after the 2015 amendments mortar has not been treated as sufficient alone for securing a covering. On slate, Cupa rules out hook fixings on pitches under 25 degrees.
Relaying the same covering over the same roof is repair work. Replacing it with something different is a different matter, and England and Wales part ways.
- For England, the Planning Portal ties approval to a replacement that is 15 per cent or more heavier in total roof covering weight.
- In Wales, the Welsh Government says approval is likely when slate is replaced by tiles, because structure, fire safety and energy use all come into it.
Neither test is met by relaying your own tiles. If you are weighing a different material because the old one will not survive lifting, that choice is covered in our spray foam removal guides, and we check with the council's building control team, or a registered building control approver, before any change of covering.
