In brief
Check the installer's invoice and data sheet first, since they should name the product. If they do not, shine a torch at it from the hatch: open-cell foam tends to be soft and spongy, closed-cell foam firmer and denser. Do not cut into it. The two behave differently with moisture, so the Energy Saving Trust treats them separately, and a roof survey confirms which you have.
Start with the paperwork
The quickest way to know which foam you have is to read the papers handed over at the end of the job. A product name, a batch number or a data sheet can settle it in a minute, and the installer can tell you the same by phone or email.
Look through the folder for:
- the quote and the invoice, which can name the product and the thickness applied
- a product data sheet or certificate, which should say open-cell or closed-cell
- the date and the name of the installer, so you can ask them directly
- a surveyor's report from a sale, if the house changed hands after the work
If you bought the house with the foam already in place, the seller's solicitor may hold the papers, and the buyer's report may have recorded the type. Nothing in the roof needs to be disturbed to find any of this out. A date matters as much as a name, so match the papers to the work actually done in your loft.
When the paperwork is silent, the next step is to look, and the section below explains how to do that without harm. If you want the background on the two kinds, our page on open-cell or closed-cell spray foam sets them side by side.
What you can see from the loft hatch
Foam is easiest to judge from where you can see a clean patch of it, such as through the hatch or at the eaves. Use a torch, stand on a proper board and never put weight on the ceiling between joists.
| What you notice | Points to |
|---|---|
| Soft, light, sponge-like when pressed | Open-cell |
| Firm, dense, resists a press | Closed-cell |
| Rough, fibrous or crumbly surface | Open-cell |
| Smooth, tight surface | Closed-cell |
These are tendencies, not a test, and a roof can hold more than one kind where it was done in stages. Foam that has aged, been painted over or been sprayed thickly can look different from its data sheet.
Do not cut a sample out, and do not pull at it to see what is behind. The foam may be bonded to the timbers and the underlay, and a torn piece can leave damage you then have to explain to a lender. Take photographs instead. Photographs of the foam, the timbers either side and any labels are what a survey starts from.
Why the type matters
The two foams handle moisture differently, which is why the Energy Saving Trust keeps them apart. Closed-cell is the one it marks down for lack of vapour permeability, while open-cell comes out better on that count.
On timber, the Trust points out that foam laid straight against the roof closes off part of the rafters. For the rot that can follow, it says the risk "should be much lower" if the foam is open-cell. That hedge is the Trust's own. It does not say open-cell foam is safe in every roof, and neither do we.
Neither foam is a fault in itself. The type tells a surveyor which questions to ask first, and what the photographs need to show, so it changes what a survey looks for:
- with closed-cell foam, whether moisture is being held in the timbers behind it
- with open-cell foam, whether the foam itself has taken up water
- with either, whether the foam has taken hold of the underlay or the covering
It also changes the conversation with your lender, who may ask what is in the roof before it asks anything else. See whether your lender will accept spray foam for how to put that question.
What a survey confirms, and the rules either side
A survey does the part you cannot do from the hatch. We look at the foam from the loft side, photograph it with the timbers around it, and tell you which kind it is and how firmly it holds. Our spray foam removal pages explain what happens next if anything needs to come out.
Should the answer include re-covering, the approval test differs between the two countries:
- England, as the Planning Portal puts it: normally no application where less than 25 per cent of the total building envelope, and less than 50 per cent of the roof, is affected.
- Wales, as the Welsh Government puts it: in most situations, re-roofing work will need Building Regulations approval.
Foam alone is not re-roofing, so most identification and removal work sits outside those tests. We ask the council's building control team where it is unclear. A recorded type also helps a buyer's surveyor or a lender, because it replaces guesswork with dated photographs. The price follows in writing, as a single sum, once the survey is done.
