01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

RICS guidance

The RICS view on spray foam insulation

RICS has published two short statements on spray foam that owners, buyers and lenders all quote. This guide reads them closely and sets out what they do and do not say.

Horizon Roofing Hereford 9 min read

RICS is the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, the professional body for chartered surveyors, and its name carries weight in a house sale. A buyer's surveyor, a lender or a solicitor dealing with foam may well turn to what RICS has said, since chartered surveyors are its members and their reports feed into a sale.

The trouble is that the statements get paraphrased until they say more than they do. Some versions have RICS banning foam, or lenders refusing to lend. Neither is in the RICS text quoted here. What the text offers is a note that some lenders had grown uneasy, and a direct instruction for owners to put the question to their own mortgage provider.

This guide sets out the two statements, takes them apart a phrase at a time, and then explains what follows for an owner, in England and in Wales. It sits within our spray foam removal guides, and it deals with wording, not with whether your roof is sound. That needs a survey.

The two RICS statements owners are quoting

The first is a press release dated 3 March 2023, announcing a new RICS consumer guide on spray foam insulation. In it, RICS records that lenders in specific sectors had become concerned, with equity release mortgages named as one case, and that the effect was by then reaching lenders more broadly.

The second is the consumer guide itself. Its advice is to put a question to the mortgage provider: does the lender's own policy permit products of this kind to be fitted?

Between them the two statements make three separate points:

  • by March 2023 some lenders had become concerned
  • equity release mortgages were given as an example of the sectors involved
  • owners should ask their mortgage provider whether its policy allows foam

Those three points are what the two statements contain. Where you read a longer claim attributed to the body, it is worth asking where the longer wording comes from. The page on spray foam and equity release looks at the example more closely.

A press release and a consumer guide are advice and information. RICS is a professional body, not a lender and not a government department, so neither text is a law and neither sets a rule for any particular mortgage provider. Each lender writes its own policy, and those policies can differ from one another and change over time. A reply you receive today describes today's policy, which is a good reason to date and keep it.

Reading each phrase closely

Phrase by phrase, the press release is more modest than the headlines made of it. The table takes four of its phrases in turn.

Words in the RICS press release and what they mean
PhraseWhat it says
"there has been concern"A worry exists. It is not a rule or a ban
"specific sectors"Some parts of lending, not all of it
"such as equity release mortgages"One example, offered as an illustration
"wider impact on lenders"The concern had reached beyond the examples

Two readings are therefore wrong. One treats equity release as the whole picture, because "such as" introduces an example and says nothing about order or completeness. The other holds that every lender will refuse a home with foam, because the statement speaks of concern, not refusal, and sends the owner to the lender's own policy.

A third reading is also worth avoiding: that the concern is about foam as a material. The words place the concern among lenders. Why a given lender is concerned is not something the quoted words explain, so treat any reason you are offered as somebody else's reading, and ask the lender itself, in writing, what its policy turns on, so the answer you hold is its own.

Keep the quotation marks in mind when you repeat any of this. Exact words travel further than paraphrases, and a short exact quotation is easier for a solicitor or a lender to check. If a document you are shown quotes RICS at greater length than this page does, ask for the date and title of the source so that it can be read in full.

What the consumer guide asks owners to do

The instruction is to take the question to your mortgage provider. That sentence is addressed to an owner who has fitted foam, is thinking of it, or is buying a house that has it. It is the action the guide names, and it is worth following to the letter, with the question put in writing. Written questions get written answers, and a written answer is what a buyer's solicitor can place on file.

It follows that the useful questions are about the provider's policy, which is outside the surveyor's hands and ours. A practical sequence looks like this:

  1. Find out whether foam is in your roof and which type it is.
  2. Put the question to your mortgage provider, in writing: does its policy allow it?
  3. Keep the reply with the installer's papers and any survey photographs.
  4. If a buyer is involved, give the same papers to your solicitor.

Step one is not always simple. The Energy Saving Trust separates the two types by vapour: it counts closed-cell foam's resistance to vapour as a drawback, and treats open-cell foam as the type that lets more vapour through. If you cannot tell, ask whoever fitted it for the product name, which should tell you the type. Failing that, a surveyor can tell a good deal from the feel and look of the surface, and a photograph from the loft helps.

For selling rather than staying, see selling a house with spray foam, which covers the sale timetable.

Who reads the RICS wording, and for what

The same two statements are read by five different people, and each takes something different from them.

How each reader uses the RICS wording
ReaderWhat they do with it
OwnerAsks their mortgage provider about foam
BuyerAsks the seller for the foam papers
SurveyorNotes the foam and what could not be seen
SolicitorCollects the lender's reply for the file
RooferShows the roof, the foam type and a removal price

A surveyor's job is to report on what can be seen, and to say plainly what could not be. In a loft with foam against the roof covering, much of what a surveyor would normally see is covered over, so the report records the foam, its type if that can be told, and the limit on inspecting the timbers.

When a surveyor flags foam, the flag on its own does not say the roof is damaged. It says the report found something to follow up, and the next step is to learn what the foam is and what sits behind it. Our guide on what to do when a buyer's surveyor flags spray foam covers the next steps for a sale.

For a seller, the useful response is evidence: photographs, the foam type, the installer's papers and an inspection of the covering from outside. For a buyer, the useful response is the same list, asked for early. A buyer who requests the papers before an offer knows what is being bought, and a buyer who waits until the survey may be asking in a hurry.

What the statements do not say

It helps to list what is absent from the two passages quoted above, because the gaps are where the retellings go wrong.

  • No ban on spray foam appears in it.
  • No lender is named as refusing or accepting foam.
  • No percentage of lenders, homes or sales is given.
  • No deadline is set for owners, lenders or buyers to act.
  • No test for the roof itself is described, such as a moisture level or an age of foam.
  • No fix is prescribed, and removal is not mentioned as a requirement.

Anyone who quotes a figure for how many lenders turn foam away, or who says removal is compulsory, is going beyond the text, and it is fair to ask them where the figure comes from. The fair summary is narrower: in 2023 RICS recorded concern, gave one example, and told owners to ask.

That narrowness is useful, and it is also honest about what is known. It means you cannot answer the question for your house by reading about other people's. Your mortgage provider has a policy, a buyer's lender has another, and the answer in each case comes from the provider, in writing, for your address.

It also means a roofer cannot settle it. We can show what the roof looks like, which foam it carries and what taking it out would involve, and you receive a single written figure once the survey is done. Whether a particular lender accepts the result is for that lender to say.

Acting on it in England and in Wales

The RICS wording applies in both countries, because it concerns lending and surveying, not the Building Regulations. The rules that apply once you act on it do differ, and the table gives the headline for each.

If the foam comes out and the roof is re-covered or re-insulated
CountryRe-coveringInsulation target
EnglandPlanning Portal: less than 25 per cent of building envelope, less than 50 per cent of roofAD L 2021 Table 4.3: 0.16, from a 0.35 threshold
WalesWelsh Government: approval in most situationsTable 11.1: 0.16, not worse than 0.35

Both countries are due new editions of Approved Document L: AD L 2026 in England from 24 March 2027, and a new Welsh edition from 4 March 2027. Until then the current editions apply, and a job priced now follows them.

Staying under both percentages is what normally keeps an English re-cover outside the application route. In Wales, the Welsh Government's re-roofing guidance is the starting point, and a switch to a different covering, which it illustrates with slate replaced by tiles, can bring structural, fire and energy requirements with it.

The same house can therefore sit under quite different tests depending on which side of the line its postcode falls. These are the points where a conversation with your lender and a conversation with building control meet. Before any work starts we confirm with the council's building control team, or a registered building control approver, which country's rules apply to your address.

The RICS view: your questions

Has RICS banned spray foam in roofs?

No. The two RICS statements are a March 2023 press release noting concern among some lenders, and a consumer guide telling owners to take the question to their mortgage provider. Neither bans foam, and neither names a lender that refuses it, so the answer for your house is the provider's.

Is equity release the only sector RICS mentioned?

In the March 2023 release, yes: RICS names equity release mortgages as its one example among sectors it describes only as specific. The words "such as" give an illustration, not an order of events or a full list, so read the example as one case and ask your own provider.

Who do I ask about my own house?

RICS points owners to their mortgage provider and its lender policy. A roofer can supply a survey, photographs and a written total price for removal if that is the route you choose, but only your provider can say what its policy allows for your address. Keep the answer with your papers.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing