Short answer
Partly. In the Energy Saving Trust's description, open-cell is the more vapour permeable foam and closed-cell is not vapour permeable. With open-cell foam the rot risk "should be much lower", the Trust says, but more permeable does not mean a roof can breathe freely. The layers outside the foam, such as the underlay, matter just as much, so we look at the whole build-up.
Two meanings of the word breathable
People use breathable for two different things, and the confusion causes most of the worry. One is vapour permeability: whether water vapour, the invisible moisture in warm indoor air, can pass through a material. The other is air permeability: whether the air itself moves through. A material can be one and not the other.
Roofing underlays show the difference. Marley describes a high-resistance underlay as not vapour permeable, and it needs ventilation at the eaves, while low-resistance or air-permeable underlays can rely on much less, provided the manufacturer's conditions are met. So "breathable" on a data sheet is a claim about one layer, tested in isolation. Foam is a layer in the same sense, and its label deserves the same care.
A roof is a stack of layers. Each one lets vapour pass more or less freely, and the slowest layer governs how quickly damp can leave. For foam, the useful question is therefore not whether it breathes in the abstract. It is whether the whole build-up lets the timber dry. Our guide to open-cell and closed-cell foam explains how to tell the two foams apart in your own loft.
What the Energy Saving Trust actually says
The Energy Saving Trust is a source some owners meet, and its wording is careful. The table keeps to what it says, including the hedges, and the paragraph below it shows why they matter when you read a quote or a surveyor's note on your own roof.
| Type | Vapour | Timber risk |
|---|---|---|
| Closed-cell | Not vapour permeable | Foam against the roof partially seals the timber |
| Open-cell | The more vapour permeable | The risk "should be much lower" |
Notice the hedges. The Trust says the more vapour permeable, which is a comparison, and it says should be much lower, not nil. Neither phrase tells you a particular roof is safe. A leak above the foam, an underlay that blocks vapour, a roof with little airflow at the eaves, or timber that was damp when it was sprayed can each override a favourable foam type.
That is why we treat the type as a starting point. It narrows what we expect to find, and the roof itself is then checked against that expectation, one layer at a time, from the covering inwards.
When open-cell foam meets felt and other layers
Foam sprayed onto an old bitumen felt or onto a modern membrane changes the picture. If the layer it covers is itself not vapour permeable, the foam's permeability cannot do much, because the vapour reaches a barrier a short way beyond it. We take this up in our guide to foam sprayed onto felt or a membrane.
On the timber side, open-cell foam against a rafter still touches the wood. If that wood was damp when the foam went on, or if water later gets in from above, open-cell foam can hold moisture in contact with it. What the lower risk means is that vapour has a route out in the normal course of things.
What we check, in the order we meet it:
- the covering outside, for slipped tiles and worn flashings
- the underlay type, where we can see it
- the eaves, for airflow and staining
- the rafter ends and battens, probed for softness
No data sheet can answer those four for your house, so the looking comes before the advising.
Lenders, rules and what happens next
Open-cell foam does not exempt a house from the lending question. RICS reported in March 2023 that equity release mortgages were one place where concern had arisen, and its consumer guide asks owners to put the question of spray foam to their mortgage provider. The advice is about spray foam products in general, whichever cell structure a house has, so the sensible first step is a call to the lender and a note of what type is fitted.
If the foam stays, a record of the type and a recent look at the timber are worth having. If it comes out, the new insulation target depends on the country. For England, Approved Document L 2021 Table 4.3 names 0.16 for a renovated roof past its 0.35 threshold, and in Wales Table 11.1 names 0.16 too, allowing 0.35 as the worst acceptable result when 0.16 is not feasible. Our answer on the insulation level after foam removal covers both.
Checkatrade, in July 2026, puts open-cell removal at £50 to £75 per m², compared with around £80 to £100 per m² for closed-cell. Our spray foam removal page shows how the survey leads to one written total, and what that total covers before any work begins.
