In brief
Not in every case, but it is likely where foam was sprayed straight onto the underlay or its battens. Once the foam is cleared we look at the underlay course by course. Torn, brittle or foam-coated sections are replaced, and clean, sound sections can stay. The new membrane is chosen with the roof's ventilation in mind, because HR underlay (high resistance) does not pass vapour.
What foam does to the underlay behind it
Underlay is the sheet stretched across the rafters below the roof covering and held by battens, the cross-timbers that carry the tiles or slates. It is the second line of defence: it catches water that gets past the tiles and sheds it toward the gutter.
Spray foam goes on from inside the loft, onto the underside of the roof. It swells as it cures, and wherever it touches the underlay, a batten or a rafter it grips. Pulling it free is slow, careful work by hand, and a membrane that has been glued to timber for years does not always come away whole. Our main guide to spray foam insulation removal covers the wider job.
That is why the underlay is never judged until the foam is gone. Once it is exposed, we check and photograph:
- tears or splits, particularly where one sheet overlaps another
- foam still stuck to the face of the membrane
- brittle or crumbling patches that cracked when moved
- old nail holes and torn edges at the battens
- the detail around the chimney, valleys and any roof window
You see the pictures before any decision is made, so the choice rests on the photographs, not a guess.
Keeping it or replacing it
The decision is made section by section, not for the whole roof at once. A clean underlay in good condition on one slope can be kept while the slope beside it, where the foam was thicker, is renewed.
| What we find | What happens |
|---|---|
| Whole, clean, flexible | Stays in place |
| Small tear at a lap | That course gets a new sheet, lapped correctly |
| Foam bonded to the face | Replaced, because the residue is a weak spot |
| Brittle or crumbling | Replaced across the whole slope |
Where the covering is lifted to reach foam on the outer side, the underlay lies open to view anyway, so renewing it at that point adds no second visit. Where the covering stays on, we work from the loft side, and we tell you which sections cannot be judged until the foam is off.
Foam on a membrane is a separate question from foam on the tiles themselves. Our page on foam sprayed onto felt or membrane goes into that case.
Choosing the new underlay with ventilation in mind
Underlay is not one product, and the choice affects whether the roof can breathe. In Marley's terms HR underlay is not a vapour-permeable product, so it needs ventilation at the eaves. Marley's eaves figures for a cold roof, with the insulation along the ceiling, are 25mm for pitches of 15° or less and 10mm above 15°.
Air-permeable types are treated differently. Over a well-sealed ceiling, Marley's figure is a 3mm gap through normal eaves construction, so long as the certification conditions it names are fully met. Those conditions matter, and nobody should pick a roll by its label.
The Energy Saving Trust gives a second reason to plan this before any insulation goes back. It lists vapour permeability as the weak point of closed-cell foam, with open-cell the more permeable of the two. Of rot, it says the risk "should be much lower" where open-cell foam is used. Whatever replaces the old foam, the underlay, the insulation and the ventilation path are chosen together.
Our guides on re-insulating after foam removal and spray foam and condensation cover the other half of that choice.
Approval, England and Wales
Putting a membrane back beneath an existing covering is repair. Re-covering a larger area is where the Building Regulations come in, and the rules diverge between England and Wales.
- England, Planning Portal: normally no application, provided less than 25 per cent of the total building envelope and less than 50 per cent of the roof is affected.
- A heavier covering matters too: the Planning Portal asks for approval at 15 per cent or more extra weight.
- Wales, per the Welsh Government: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval."
The Welsh Government's roof guidance also expects re-covering to improve insulation, because it treats a roof as a thermal element. That bites when the covering itself is being replaced, not when one course of underlay is. Neither side's test is built around a small patch of membrane, so the first question is always what share of the roof is being opened up, and we answer it from the survey photographs.
Where a job sits close to a threshold, we ask the council's building control team before starting, or a registered building control approver. Our written price after the survey is a single total that states if scaffold and VAT sit inside it.
