Under the tiles or slates of a pitched roof there can be a sheet called the underlay, laid over the rafters and held down by the battens. Older houses may carry traditional bitumen felt. Newer work, or a re-roof done in recent decades, may carry a breathable membrane, a sheet made to let moisture vapour pass out of the loft. Some stone and timber-framed houses on the border have neither, and show the back of the covering directly.
Spray foam is applied from the loft side, as a liquid that expands against whatever it meets. When that is felt or a membrane, the foam and the sheet become one layer. That matters for two reasons. The sheet may no longer do the job it was chosen for, and taking the foam off may take the sheet with it.
The sections below explain the types of underlay, what the foam changes, how we find out what you have, and what removal and re-laying involve for a house in either nation. For the whole job, begin at our spray foam removal page.
Felt, membrane or nothing: what sits under your slopes
Underlay comes in three forms on the houses we survey around Hereford. Bitumen felt is the traditional black sheet. A breathable membrane is a modern sheet that passes moisture vapour. Some stone and older tiled roofs have no sheet at all, so from the loft you look straight up at the back of the covering, with torching in places, a lime mortar bedding pushed in between the battens.
Vapour behaviour matters most. Marley, a tile maker, separates two types. Marley's high resistance (HR) type passes no moisture vapour whatever, so the loft beneath it needs ventilation openings at the eaves. Low resistance (LR) underlay is air-permeable, and Marley says it can rely on ventilation through normal eaves construction only when a well-sealed ceiling and its certification conditions are met.
Because the two behave so differently, the first question on any foam-lined roof is which one lies beneath the foam. A sheet chosen to breathe, with a layer of foam now bonded to its underside, works under different conditions from the ones it was made for.
You may find more than one of these in a single house, because extensions and repairs were done in different decades:
- bitumen felt over the older main roof
- a breathable membrane over a later extension or a re-roofed slope
- bare battens under stone tilestones, where the stone is the only barrier
Each combination needs its own handling once the foam comes off.
What foam changes once it is bonded to the sheet
The Energy Saving Trust describes two main kinds of spray foam, closed-cell and open-cell. Closed-cell foam, it says, has a "main drawback": it is "not vapour permeable". Open-cell foam is "the more vapour permeable" of the two. For timber, the Trust warns that foam sprayed directly against the underside of a roof will partially seal it. The Trust adds that with open-cell foam the risk "should be much lower".
Read those lines with the underlay in mind. A breathable membrane lets vapour out of the loft only if there is somewhere for the vapour to go. Closed-cell foam against its underside is a layer the vapour cannot pass, and open-cell foam is a layer it can pass more easily. Neither statement says anything about how your own roof is performing. That depends on the thickness of the foam, the condition of the sheet, the ceiling below and how the house is lived in, with its cooking, washing and drying of clothes.
With felt, the question is different. Felt is there to shed water towards the gutter. Once foam covers it, the felt cannot be inspected from the loft, and a split in it stays hidden until water shows at a ceiling.
What we can say from the hatch is therefore limited. The foam hides the sheet, and the sheet's condition is the very thing we most want to see. That is why the survey comes before the quote.
Working out what the foam is stuck to
You can learn a fair amount without touching the foam. We begin at the hatch with a strong lamp and look at the places where the foam stops, because those edges show what lies beneath.
- the eaves, where the foam may end short of the wall plate and leave the underlay visible
- around the loft hatch and any pipe or flue, where the foam was cut back
- a ragged or torn edge where foam has pulled a sheet away from a rafter
- any printed lettering on a membrane, which names the maker and the type
- the colour and texture of the sheet: black and rough suggests felt, grey or white and smooth suggests a membrane
Outside, a closer look at the tile edges at the eaves and the verge, and at the ridge, can tell us whether a sheet runs under the covering or only battens do. Each of these is photographed and shown to you.
Please do not cut or scrape the foam to have a look. Cutting a sheet that is bonded to foam leaves a hole in the one layer between the loft and the weather, and rain can reach it before a repair is planned. Take photographs from the hatch instead, with a phone torch held to one side, because side light shows the surface texture. If you have spotted a stain on a ceiling, our guide to spray foam and condensation explains what a damp loft can mean.
Bring any paperwork from the original installer, such as an invoice or data sheet. It may name the foam and the sheet it was sprayed onto, and that shortens the survey.
What happens to felt or membrane when foam lifts
When we take foam off, we work from the loft side, cutting and lifting it away from the rafters and then from the underlay. How the sheet comes away depends on how well it was fixed and how hard the foam bonded to it. We plan for three outcomes and tell you which one we expect before the work begins.
- The foam comes away and the sheet stays sound. It is checked, small tears are repaired and the roof is closed up again.
- The foam lifts but the sheet tears, or comes away in patches. Those areas need new underlay between the battens, or a full new sheet across the slope.
- The sheet and the foam come off together. The slope is then without underlay and needs a new one before the roof is made good.
Closed-cell foam, being rigid, is generally taken off in sections, and open-cell, being soft, is cut back. Either way, the first minutes of lifting reveal how the sheet is behaving, and the plan can change at that point. Every tear and every batten we find is photographed, and you receive the pictures. A phone photograph of any felt you can see at the eaves before work begins gives us a reference to compare with what lies under the foam, so keep it handy.
Replacing an underlay on a pitched roof normally means lifting the covering above it, at least in part. Our guide to new underlay after foam removal covers the choice of sheet, and the next section covers the rules.
When a new underlay means lifting the covering
Re-laying underlay under tiles or slates can turn a loft job into roof work, and approvals are not the same across the border. We check with building control before we start, either the council or a registered building control approver, because re-roofing falls under the Building Regulations.
- In England, the Planning Portal gives two tests for an English roof: under 25 per cent of the building envelope, and under 50 per cent of the roof itself. A job that passes both is not normally sent to building control as an application.
- In England, a replacement covering weighing 15 per cent or more over what it replaces is, on the Planning Portal's reading, a case for approval.
- In Wales, the Welsh Government starts from the position that approval is needed "In most situations".
- In Wales, the Welsh Government's roof page says repairs or re-covering of "less than 25 per cent of the area of a pitch or flat roof" will not normally need an application.
Which route applies to your roof depends on how much of it is lifted, so the area is measured at the survey before we say anything about approvals.
Underlay may not be the only thing that changes once the tiles are up. Battens that have rotted behind the foam are replaced, and the covering is relaid. Sound tiles, slates or stone tilestones go back where they came from, so the roofline keeps its look. Where one breaks in the lift, we match it as closely as stock allows.
Ventilation once the sheet is sorted
A new underlay is only half the answer. The other half is how the loft will breathe. For a cold roof, where insulation sits at ceiling level, Marley gives this for HR underlay: "25mm along the length of the eaves for pitches of 15° or less; 10mm along the length of the eaves for pitches of more than 15°." For an air-permeable sheet, with the ceiling beneath it well sealed, Marley says the usual 3mm gap in ordinary eaves construction is enough, as long as its certification requirements are met.
| Underlay | Vapour behaviour | Eaves opening |
|---|---|---|
| High resistance | Not vapour-permeable | 25mm at 15° or less; 10mm above 15° |
| Air-permeable | Air passes through the sheet | 3mm, if the ceiling is well sealed |
These are Marley's figures for its own products and conditions, so we read the data sheet of the sheet we fit rather than rely on a number from memory. Ventilation is a technical matter for the underlay maker and applies alike in England and in Wales. The insulation that goes back is another matter, because each nation sets its own Part L figures for a renovated roof, and our guide to re-insulating after foam removal sets them out.
If foam was fitted because the loft was cold or the tiles were slipping, that cause still needs dealing with, and the new layers are chosen to do it.
