Short answer
Neither suits every roof. Foam is sprayed in place, bonds to the timber and is awkward to inspect or take out later. Mineral wool is cut to fit between the rafters, can be lifted out to look at the wood, and leaves the rafter faces open. The Energy Saving Trust treats closed-cell foam as the type that stops vapour passing and open-cell as the type that lets more through. The right choice turns on the roof's condition, its underlay, its ventilation, the rafter depth and your lender.
How each one sits between the timbers
Picture one rafter bay, the gap between two neighbouring rafters running from eaves to ridge. Foam is sprayed into it as a liquid, expands and fills every corner, then sets. Mineral wool arrives as a batt or roll, is cut to the width of the bay and pushed in, where it stays by its own fit.
That one difference shapes how the roof lives afterwards, and the comparison below shows where it bites.
| Point | Spray foam | Mineral wool |
|---|---|---|
| Fitted by | Spraying, then curing | Cutting and pushing in |
| Bond to timber | Sticks to rafters and battens | None; held by its fit |
| Looking at the wood | Needs the foam cut back | Lift the batt and look |
| Taking it out | Cut, peeled or lifted in pieces | Pulled out and bagged |
A batt that is cut a little short leaves a gap that foam would have filled, so the fit of wool matters as much as its thickness. It is a trade of convenience against certainty, and neither side wins every time.
What each does to the timber around it
On the foam side, the Energy Saving Trust is plain. It marks closed-cell foam down for one reason, that it is not vapour permeable, and it describes open-cell as the more permeable choice. Where foam goes directly against the roof timbers, the Trust adds, they are partly sealed in and can rot if water collects, but with open-cell foam that risk "should be much lower". Wool has no such sealing effect, because it is not stuck to anything.
Mineral wool does not bond to the wood, so the rafter faces are left exposed to the air in the bay. That makes the timber easier to inspect and easier to keep an eye on over the years. It does not make a leaking roof sound, and a wet batt loses much of its use, so the covering above still has to be right.
Either choice depends on air moving in the roof space where the design needs it. Our answer on loft ventilation after foam removal explains why the eaves matter when a roof is re-insulated, whichever material you choose.
Repairs, lenders and selling
Think ahead to the next repair. A slipped tile above wool can be reached by lifting the batt, while the same repair above foam may need foam cut away first, a point we cover in our answer on whether foam stops tiles being repaired. That is not a reason to rule foam out, only a cost to count.
The lender point is specific to foam, since the RICS statements quoted here are about spray foam. Its March 2023 release named equity release mortgages as one place where lenders had shown concern, and its guide for consumers advises asking a mortgage provider about policy before foam goes in. A house insulated with wool does not raise that question in the same way.
A buyer's surveyor can lift a batt and photograph the timber, which keeps a sale simpler. Foam that has to come out later is a different matter: Checkatrade (July 2026) lists removal of open-cell foam at £50 to £75 per m², then closed-cell at around £80 to £100 per m², VAT extra. A roofer's one written total reflects the area you are working with.
Building Regulations on each side of the border
Under the Building Regulations 2010, roofs count as thermal elements, so re-insulating one can fall under Part L whichever material you choose, in England or in Wales. England's Approved Document L 2021, Table 4.3, sets 0.16 for a renovated roof that is worse than 0.35. The Welsh Approved Document L, Table 11.1, also gives 0.16, with 0.35 as the worst acceptable figure where 0.16 cannot be reached.
Those are U-values. A U-value records how much heat passes through a surface, and a lower figure is better. It applies to the finished roof, not to one product. Foam and wool can each reach the figure, though the thickness needed differs with the rafter depth, which is why a survey measures the roof before anything is chosen. A deep rafter leaves room for more insulation between the timbers, while a shallow one may need a layer added below or above, and that affects the look of the room as well as the cost.
Our answer on the insulation level after foam removal sets out the figures more fully, and our spray foam removal page shows where this choice sits in the whole job. Ask the council's building control team, or a registered building control approver, whether your work needs an application.
