01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Roof materials

Roof types across Herefordshire and the border, from stone tiles to slate

Leave Hereford in any direction and the roofs change: grey-brown stone, fired clay, slate from north Wales. This guide says what each covering is, where it comes from and its lifespan.

Horizon Roofing Hereford 9 min read

A roof in this part of England and Wales may not be the one the house started with. Stone tiles have been swapped for slate, clay for concrete, and an old timber frame can wear whatever covering the last owner could get. Knowing what you have is the first step to repairing it properly, and the second is knowing what the rules on your side of the border say about changing it.

This guide describes each covering and where it comes from without ranking one above another, because the repair always turns on the covering on your own roof.

It starts with the stone tiles particular to the county, then moves through clay, concrete and slate, then the timber-framed houses the region is known for. The last section covers matching a repair to the roof in front of you. For the services behind each material, start from the Horizon Roofing Hereford home page.

Stone tiles from the Golden Valley

The old stone roofs of this county are covered in sandstone tilestones: thin slabs of local sandstone, split and hung much as clay tiles are. The county's stone atlas, published in 2012 under the Strategic Stone Study and edited by the British Geological Survey, traces most tilestone to sandstones of the St Maughans Formation. Some quarries still extract it, and the atlas gives current permissions in the Golden Valley, out at the western edge of the county.

The atlas also records other sources and places:

  • Downton Castle Sandstone, used historically as a freestone and as a tilestone
  • the brownstones, quarried for tilestones as well as building blocks
  • Longtown, where old cottages still sit under flagstone roofs
  • Kington, where the flagstones on old cottages come from the younger Raglan Mudstone Formation

The Ewyas Lacy Study Group, a local history society, adds that stone tiles have been the traditional roof there for centuries because the sandstone was close to hand.

Grey through to brown is how SPAB describes the stone slates of this region, with some purple ones in Herefordshire; the full name of that body is the Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings. It calls stone and slate roofs in Wales and the Marches predominantly double-lapped, meaning each course overlaps the one two below it so a slab always covers the joint beneath. Many stone roofs, SPAB notes, have been recovered since in a different stone, in slate, or in a reconstituted look-alike. Our guide to stone roof tiles in Herefordshire goes into repair.

Clay: tiles from the Herefordshire brickworks

The geology that gave the county its stone also gave it clay. According to the atlas, clay from the Raglan mudstones supplied the county's long-running brick, tile and pipe industries, and about 250 brickworks appear in the county's Sites and Monuments Record. Those tile works gave the county a fired covering to set beside its stone.

Clay tiles are fired, so colour and texture come from the clay and the kiln, not from a coating. That matters in a repair: a replacement tile of a different red shows as a patch on the slope for years afterwards. Weathering softens the difference slowly, so sorting salvaged tiles by colour before they go back is worth the time.

On lifespan, Marley reports that the Building Research Establishment (BRE) fixed a minimum life expectancy for clay roof tiles at 60 years. That figure is for clay only and does not carry across to other coverings. HomeBuilding gives clay tiles "60-80 years" as an approximate range. Both are typical ranges, not promises.

Minimum pitch depends on the tile. Marley's table lists these for its clay products, which are product names and not places:

  • Canterbury at 40°
  • Ashdowne at 35°
  • Hawkins and Acme Single Camber at 30°
  • Lincoln pantile at 15°

Check the data sheet for the tile actually on your roof, because a pitch that suits one clay tile can leak under another. Our guide to clay plain tiles in Herefordshire covers matching, nibs, fixing and repair in more detail, and explains why reclaimed tiles can be worth keeping.

Concrete tiles and their pitch limits

Concrete tiles are moulded from cement and sand and come in plain, interlocking and double-roman profiles. They are made to a standard shape, so matching replacements are easier to find than for stone or old clay, and that is their strength on a repair. The same profile that makes them easy to buy makes a mixed roof obvious, so a patch of a different make shows from the road.

Lifespan sources disagree, so both are named. Marley puts the expected life of its roof tiles at around 60 years and adds, "This is not a guarantee or warranty of its longevity." HomeBuilding gives plain concrete tiles and double romans as "40-50 years". A gap that wide is a reason to judge the individual roof, not a table.

Minimum pitch again depends on the product. Marley's table gives these figures for some of its concrete tiles:

Minimum pitch for some Marley concrete tiles
TileMinimum pitch
Plain35°
Edgemere17.5°
Double Roman (smooth)22.5°
Mendip (smooth)15°
Ludlow Plus22.5°

Ludlow Plus is a product name and says nothing about roofs in the town of Ludlow.

Weight is where concrete can cause trouble when it replaces something lighter. Both the English and the Welsh Approved Document A regard added roof loading of more than 15% as significant, which is why the structure gets checked first. Our guide to concrete interlocking tiles sets out the details of fixing and underlay.

Welsh slate on the border

Slate arrives from further away than the stone. According to SPAB, "Welsh slate" today means slate from the Nantlle to Bethesda belt in north-west Wales, where the Bethesda and Blaenau Ffestiniog operations carry on. Slate is thin, dense and splits cleanly, which suits steeper roofs and gives a neat, slim edge at the verge. A slate hangs on nails or hooks, and on an old roof it can be the fixing rather than the slate that gives way after the nails rust through.

Lifespans vary with origin, and HomeBuilding's table shows the spread:

  • Welsh slate: "100+ years"
  • Spanish natural slate: "75-100 years"
  • reclaimed Welsh slate: "50-80 years"

On the Welsh side, SPAB's note on Wales and the Marches expects a well-slated roof to pass 100 years, with the word "likely" attached. That remark is about slate. It does not stretch to stone, whose life depends on the stone chosen and how well it was laid.

Pitch is the next question. Cupa reads BS 5534:2014+A2:2018 as giving natural slate a floor of 20 degrees where the exposure is moderate, for a 500 mm slate lapped by 115 mm. Treat 20 degrees as a figure with conditions, never a universal floor. Cupa also keeps hook fixings off any pitch below 25 degrees, and our guide to nails or hooks for slates explains why.

Our guides to re-slating a roof and reclaimed Welsh slate cover the work step by step. When a supplier tells you a slate is unobtainable or weeks away, SPAB suggests putting that question to the quarries themselves.

Black-and-white houses and what sits on them

The building style most closely tied to north-west Herefordshire is timber framing, the black-and-white house. The atlas calls it the most striking regional style, and a tourist route, the Black and White Village Trail, has grown up around it. Weobley, Pembridge and Eardisland are among the villages it names, alongside Yarpole, Dilwyn and Almeley.

The frame stands on a base. The atlas notes that a sole-plate, which is the lowest horizontal timber, is usually set on sandstone or siltstone footings, and that big external chimney stacks are also often local sandstone. A stone stack on a timber house is a job of its own, because the lime mortar, flaunching and flashings all have to suit the stone.

The roof covering is a separate question. A black-and-white house may carry stone tiles, clay or slate, and its present covering may not be the one it was first built with. A timber frame also moves slightly with the seasons, so the roof edge and the chimney junctions open and close in a way a rigid masonry house does not.

Checks you can make from the ground:

  • the line of the ridge, where a dip means timbers have shifted
  • the verge, the roof's edge at the gable end
  • cracks around the base of the chimney stack
  • any sag at the eaves above the plinth

Photograph anything that worries you and send it with the address, so the survey can start with what you have already seen. Our guide to stone stacks on black-and-white houses covers the chimney side in full.

Matching a repair, and the rules on each side

Matching is the reason to know your roof type. A repair that suits the way the roof was built lasts longer and looks right, and in some places it is also what the rules ask for. In England, swapping the covering is normally permitted development; going heavier brings in the Building Regulations, with the Planning Portal drawing the line at an increase of 15 per cent or more in the weight the roof structure has to take.

In Wales, the Welsh Government's guidance is that a re-roof needs Building Regulations approval in most situations. Its example of a change that probably needs approval is slate replaced by tiles, where structure, fire safety and energy efficiency are all checked. Welsh permitted development also asks that new materials match the existing appearance so far as practicable. The planning conditions sit in our roof window planning guide.

Listed buildings add a layer. A listed house needs listed building consent as well, under the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 in England and under the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 in Wales.

Before you commission work, ask for these in writing:

  • what the existing covering is, named plainly
  • whether the new covering matches it in appearance, weight and fixing
  • which country's rules govern the address
  • whether reclaimed or new material is proposed, and from where

Our guide to planning permission for roof work in Herefordshire covers the approvals side in full, and roof work approvals in England and Wales sets the two sets of tests side by side.

Questions on local roof types

Where does Herefordshire stone roofing come from?

Per the county atlas of building stone, the St Maughans Formation sandstones are the main source of tilestone; they are still cut at a small number of quarries, and numerous active permissions lie in the Golden Valley area. Downton Castle Sandstone and the brownstones have been used too, and older cottages in Longtown and Kington carry flagstone roofs.

How long does a clay or slate roof last?

Marley reports that the BRE set a minimum life expectancy of 60 years for clay roof tiles. HomeBuilding gives Welsh slate as 100+ years and reclaimed Welsh slate as 50-80 years. Treat the figures as ranges rather than promises; the condition of the fixings and battens can settle the true cost.

Can I replace slate with concrete tiles on a border house?

Concrete is heavier. In England, the Planning Portal sets approval at a weight rise of 15 per cent or more. In Wales, the Welsh Government counts a switch from slate to tiles as a likely approval case. A listed house needs listed building consent too, so speak to the council first.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing