Many roof jobs need no planning application. A repair, a re-cover and, in some places, a new roof window can all go ahead under permitted development, the set of rights that lets householders alter a home without applying. The difficulty is that two different Orders apply to our patch. Herefordshire, Worcestershire, Gloucestershire and Shropshire addresses follow the English one. Monmouthshire and Powys addresses, including the whole of the Bannau Brycheiniog National Park, follow the Welsh one.
The two Orders use the same class letters, B for roof enlargements and C for other roof alterations, but the conditions inside them differ in ways that matter on a real house. A roof light that is a routine job on one side of the border is a planning application on protected land on the other.
The sections below take England first, then Wales, then the protected land that switches rights off on each side, then listed buildings. Planning permission is a different test from Building Regulations approval, and a roof can need one, the other or both. Every service we offer is listed from the Horizon Roofing Hereford homepage.
Two Orders, one border
Householder rights in England come from the 2015 General Permitted Development Order. Wales still relies on the 1995 Order, with Part 1 substituted for Wales in 2013. Both sets of rights apply only to a dwellinghouse. In England the 2015 Order says a dwellinghouse does not include a building containing one or more flats, or a flat within such a building, so a flat owner has no householder rights to rely on.
Both Orders are national law. A council can withdraw named rights across an area through an Article 4 direction, which the last section explains. The table picks out differences that can change the answer for a roof.
| Topic | England | Wales |
|---|---|---|
| Changing the covering | Class C, no matching condition | Class C.2(a), must match the look so far as practicable |
| Roof light on protected land | Class C still applies | Not permitted, Class C.1(d) |
| Dormer on protected land | Not permitted, Class B.1(f) | Not permitted, Class B.1(g) |
| Window in a side slope | Obscure-glazed in every case | Depends on a 10.5 m test |
Read the table as a map, not a ruling. Each cell has its own conditions, set out below, and the council decides how they apply to your house.
If you are unsure, the quickest route is to send the planning team three things: pictures showing the roof's present state, a short description of the change, and your full address with its postcode. Those let the council say which Order applies and whether a designation covers the house, and a survey of your roof can supply the photographs.
England: Class C and a change of covering
Class C of the 2015 Order covers "Any other alteration to the roof of a dwellinghouse". It is the class that takes in re-roofing, so a change of covering on an English house is normally permitted development. Unlike the Welsh version, England's Class C has no condition about matching materials, which is why slate to tile is a Building Regulations conversation in England and not a planning one.
The class still has limits, and an alteration is not permitted if any of these apply:
- it would protrude more than 0.15 metres beyond the plane of the slope of the original roof
- it would take the highest part of the alteration above the highest part of the original roof
- it includes installing, altering or replacing a chimney, flue or soil and vent pipe
- it includes installing, altering or replacing solar photovoltaics or solar thermal equipment
A further condition covers side slopes. Every window set in a side-facing slope must be obscure-glazed. It must also be non-opening, except that opening parts more than 1.7 metres above the floor of the room are allowed. The height relaxes only the non-opening limb, never the obscure glazing.
Class C has no exclusion for conservation areas, National Parks or National Landscapes, which is why a re-cover or a roof window can still be permitted development there. Our roof window planning guide covers the detail for roof windows and rooflights.
England: Class B, dormers and article 2(3) land
Class B is the enlargement of a dwellinghouse consisting of an addition or alteration to its roof, and a dormer is the usual example. The limits are volume, position and land. The volume cap is 40 cubic metres on a terrace and 50 cubic metres on any other house. A dormer cannot extend beyond a slope that forms the principal elevation and fronts a highway. Which slope counts as the principal elevation is a question to put to the council.
The land condition is the one that catches people. Class B.1(f) removes the right where the dwellinghouse is on article 2(3) land. The Order's definition covers an area designated as a conservation area, an area of outstanding natural beauty, a National Park and a World Heritage Site.
In Herefordshire, that has two practical consequences. First, there are 64 conservation areas in the county, according to Herefordshire Council, and they include Hereford's historic centre, so a dormer in a conservation area needs an application. Second, there are two National Landscapes in the county, Wye Valley and Malvern Hills, and Herefordshire Council explains that in law they remain areas of outstanding natural beauty.
The National Landscape teams do not decide the application. Decisions on planning applications rest with each individual Local Planning Authority, the Malvern Hills National Landscape points out, and not with the National Landscape Team or Partnership. For a house near either designation, check with the council first.
Wales: the 1995 Order and its stricter Class C
The Welsh Class C also covers "Any other alteration to the roof of a dwellinghouse", with a first set of limits close to England's. The work may not stand out more than 15 centimetres from the plane of the original slope, and it may not rise above the highest point of the original roof.
Four differences follow.
- Condition C.2(a) asks that exterior materials "so far as practicable match" the existing ones in appearance. The Welsh Government's summary says you do not normally need to apply to re-roof, and that the materials should match as far as possible.
- Class C.1(d) bars a roof light where the house stands on article 1(5) land. The Welsh Government's guidance defines that as National Parks, AONBs and conservation areas. A World Heritage Site is treated the same way.
- Class C.1(c) excludes installing, altering or replacing a chimney, and removing one from a house on article 1(5) land.
- Condition C.2(b) applies the obscure-glazing rule only where a window would fall within 10.5 metres of the boundary opposite the side elevation. Inside that zone the window must be obscure-glazed. It must also be non-opening, except where the opening part sits 1.7 metres or more above the floor.
The Welsh Class B keeps the 40 and 50 cubic metre limits and adds a few of its own, including a 20 centimetre setback from the eaves and a 10.5 metre test from a highway beside a side slope. It excludes article 1(5) land at B.1(g). The Welsh Government's planning permission for roofs page gives the plain-English summary.
Protected land compared: article 2(3) and article 1(5)
Both Orders switch rights off on protected land, but they draw the line in different places and the effect on a roof is not the same. The table sets the two side by side.
| Job | England, article 2(3) land | Wales, article 1(5) land |
|---|---|---|
| Dormer | Removed | Removed |
| New roof light | Not removed | Removed |
| Re-cover | Not removed | Not removed, must match |
| Chimney | Altering barred on any land | Removal barred |
A conservation area is protected land in both countries, and so are National Parks. The Wye Valley National Landscape crosses the border, with its team based in Monmouth, so two houses a few miles apart can be on different sides of the line and be governed by different Orders. Check the address, not the view. A designation map on a council's website is a starting point, but the planning team has the final word on whether your house lies inside the boundary.
A World Heritage Site is on both lists. Where a house sits close to a boundary, ask the council which designation applies. We work out which side of the border a house is on before we advise, because that settles which Order and which Building Regulations route apply to the job.
The designation also decides who you ask. Inside the Bannau Brycheiniog National Park, planning applications go to the National Park Authority, and building control stays with the council. Our guide to roof work inside the National Park takes those Welsh rules one job at a time.
Listed buildings, conservation areas and Article 4 directions
A listed house keeps its permitted development rights under Classes B and C in both countries, because neither class excludes listed buildings. Listed building consent is needed on top. In England the test is section 7 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990, which asks whether the works would affect the building's character. Wales changed over to the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 on 4 November 2024, and section 88 says works must be authorised, which section 89 does by way of listed building consent. Section 88(2)(a) catches works that alter or extend a listed building so as to touch its special character, and a new covering, a rebuilt stack or a roof window might each do so.
An Article 4 direction can take rights away from a defined area. GOV.UK guidance defines it as a direction that allows either the local planning authority or the Secretary of State to withdraw named permitted development rights, and the Welsh Government adds that conservation areas are where these directions turn up most. Herefordshire Council's site carries no Article 4 list, so ask the council whether a direction covers your street.
Where a conservation area removes a right, planning permission is what is needed, and the council can say which roof jobs it affects.
If the address is in Monmouthshire, ring the Duty Planning Officer on 01633 644831 to ask whether planning permission is needed. Our guide to roofing rules on the border adds the Building Regulations side.
