Drive north-west out of Hereford towards Weobley, Pembridge or Eardisland and the skyline changes. Black timber framing, white infill panels and a heavy stack standing against the gable become the pattern of the landscape. The stack is a very different structure from the frame beside it. It is masonry, built up course by course, and it carries its own weight down through the roof to the ground.
That stone is local. Herefordshire Council hosts a building stone atlas, first published in September 2012, which says the large external stacks of these buildings are "commonly of local sandstone". Where a stack rises through a stone-tiled roof, the repair to one meets the repair to the other at the flashing.
This guide covers why the stacks are stone, how to read their condition from the ground, where the stone meets the roof, how replacement stone is matched, and the English rules that apply to listed and protected houses. Everything else we do to stacks starts from our chimney repairs page.
Why these stacks are built of stone
In the atlas's account, the black-and-white house, the timber-framed type, is Herefordshire's most striking regional style in the countryside, strongest in the county's north-west, where visitors can follow a Black and White Village Trail. The villages it picks out are Weobley, Yarpole, Dilwyn, Almeley, Pembridge and Eardisland. Weobley lies 10.4 road miles out of Hereford, Eardisland 14.6 and Pembridge 15.7, so they sit well inside the area we cover. The atlas also notes that the bottom beam of such a frame, the sole-plate, rests, in its word usually, on a sandstone or siltstone plinth.
The chimney is not part of the timber frame, and it was built of a different material. The atlas traces the county's sandstones and siltstones, and names local sandstone as the common stone of the stacks. Our answer on why old Herefordshire stacks are built of stone goes further into that.
Three things follow for a repair:
- the stack is heavy, stands free above the roof and is exposed on every face
- its joints and its stone age at different rates, so each needs its own look
- the frame, the plinth and the stack were built as one house, and a repair that ignores that looks out of place from the road
We start any survey by working out which stone the stack is built of and which of the county's stones it resembles, then match the repair to the house as it was built. A repair in the wrong stone is visible for as long as the stack stands.
Reading a stone stack from the ground
A good deal can be learned with binoculars on a dry day, before anyone goes up. The aim is to separate faults in the joints from faults in the stone itself, because they call for different repairs.
| What you see | What we check |
|---|---|
| Dark, empty joints | How far back the mortar has gone, and whether the stones behind are firm |
| Faces peeling in thin layers | Whether the stone is laid on its natural bed or turned on edge |
| Green or black staining | Whether water is running down the stack from the flaunching or flashing |
| A lean or a step in the line | Whether the movement is old and settled or still going |
| Plants in the joints | Where the roots have opened the stone and what lies behind |
Stone that peels is not always weak stone. Sandstone and siltstone form in layers, and a block set with those layers upright may flake where a block laid flat in the way it formed would not. That is why the way each block sits matters as much as the block itself.
From inside the house we look at the chimney breast below the stack, since a damp patch there can have its source on the stack above. A stack that has started to lean is a larger question, and our guide to rebuilding a chimney above the roof covers the choices.
Where the stone meets the roof
Water gets into a stone stack mainly at its junctions. The lead flashing, a folded strip of sheet lead that seals the foot of the stack against the slope, is chased into the courses of the stack and laid over the roof covering. Between the tile or stone courses go the soakers, which are small lead pieces folded to shape. On top, the flaunching, a mortar collar, holds the pots and sheds water outward.
Royston Lead's table of cast-lead sheet lists the codes by use, and the letters printed there tell us what each code is for:
| Code | Thickness | Listed uses |
|---|---|---|
| Code 3 | 1.32 mm | Recommended for lead soakers only |
| Code 4 | 1.80 mm | Soakers, flashings, pitched valley gutters, dormers |
| Code 5 | 2.24 mm | Flashings, pitched valley gutters, parapet and box gutters, dormers |
Some of the older houses are roofed in stone tiles as well, the sandstone tilestones that the atlas links to the St Maughans sandstones, the principal source of the county's roofing stone. SPAB's technical note on roofing in slate and stone says such roofs "are predominantly double-lapped", so each course overlaps the one below by a wide margin, and a flashing has to be cut and dressed to that thickness.
Where a stack stands in a stone-tiled roof, we cut the flashing into the joints rather than surface-fixing it, and we match the dressing to the roof around it. MyJobQuote (page updated 22 September 2026) gives around £200 for a chimney lead flashing patch and around £570 for a full replacement. Stone-tile work itself is priced after a survey.
Matching replacement stone
Where a stone has failed and must be replaced, the colour and the grain matter as much as the strength. The atlas names the stones that Herefordshire has used for building and roofing, and the names are a useful starting point for a survey:
- St Maughans Formation sandstones, named by the atlas as the chief source of Herefordshire's stone roofing, worked today at only a few quarries, though the atlas sets its permissions to work stone in the county's far west
- Downton Castle Sandstone, which "has been used historically both as a freestone and as a tilestone"
- brownstones, "quarried for both tilestones and dimension stone"
- flagstones from the Raglan Mudstone Formation, which roof older cottages in Kington, while Longtown's older cottages are "still roofed with flagstones"
SPAB notes that stone slates in the region range from grey to brown, "but there are some purple types in Herefordshire". A new stone that is the wrong shade will show from the lane for a long time, which is one reason we photograph the existing stack close up before we order anything.
SPAB also warns that "Claims of unavailability or long delivery times should always be checked with the quarries." We take that seriously: when a stone is reported unobtainable, we put the question to the quarry before we offer you a substitute. Where no match exists, we show you the alternatives and say what each would change.
Reclaimed stone from the house itself is the closest match there is, and a stack that is carefully taken down and rebuilt can be put back in its own stone.
Listed houses, conservation areas and consent in England
A black-and-white house may be listed, and the English rules are these:
- Under section 7 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990, works that "affect its character as a building of special architectural or historic interest" need listed building consent, unless they are authorised.
- Listed houses keep the permitted development Classes B and C, though consent is also required, so ask Herefordshire Council before work to a listed stack starts.
- Herefordshire Council says there are 64 conservation areas in the county, and your address may sit in one. Check whether an Article 4 direction applies with the council.
- Paragraph C.1(d)(i) of Class C rules out any roof alteration that installs, alters or replaces a chimney, so a rebuilt stack is not simply permitted development.
The Wye Valley and the Malvern Hills are National Landscapes, a recent working name that now stands in for the Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty. A National Landscape is a designation. Planning applications are decided by the local planning authorities, not by the National Landscape team.
Repair in matching stone, with matching mortar, is one thing and rebuilding is another. Our guide to repointing a chimney stack covers the first and the rebuilding guide covers the second. When in doubt, ring the council before the scaffold goes up. Take photographs of the stack from the lane and from the garden, and keep any letter from the council about the house, as both help the conversation. On a listed house, the council makes the consent decision, whatever we advise.
Access, neighbours and a written price
A stack on a gable beside a lane or a village street may need its scaffold to stand over the highway. Section 169 of the Highways Act 1980 makes that a licensed scaffold, so we arrange the licence with our scaffolder. The English councils around Hereford charge differently:
- Herefordshire Council: £167 covers a maximum of 1 month, extensions are £123 per month, and 10 days' notice is the minimum
- Worcestershire County Council: £85 per week, £65 for later weeks
- Gloucestershire County Council: £145 for a minimum of 28 days, then £36 per extra 7 days, at least twelve calendar days' notice
- Shropshire Council: £200, at least ten working days' notice
The units differ from one fee to the next, so none can be set against another. Scaffold is priced into the written total.
Where a house shares a stack with its neighbour, work to that stack can fall under the Party Wall etc. Act 1996, where it is the owner who serves notice, at least two months ahead of a cut into a party wall. Neighbours who object, or fail to answer in 14 days, bring in a surveyor. Questions of that kind belong with a party wall surveyor rather than building control.
Following the survey you get a single written total price, which names the stone and the mortar so you can see what is being matched. Birds nest in some stacks and bats can use the gaps in old stone, so we check before we disturb either.
