A roof repair and a full re-roof can look the same from the pavement, but the paperwork behind them turns on the border line running past the property. Herefordshire, Worcestershire, Gloucestershire and Shropshire follow the Building Regulations for England. Monmouthshire, Powys and the Bannau Brycheiniog National Park follow the Building Regulations for Wales, which the Welsh Government writes for itself.
Two questions get mixed up. Planning permission asks whether the work changes how a building looks or is used. Building Regulations ask whether the work is structurally sound, properly insulated and safe in a fire. Re-covering a pitched roof can be a Building Regulations matter first, and our planning permission guide covers the other half.
Each rule below names its country within the sentence itself, which lets you go straight to the side of the border you live on. None of it replaces a call to the council's building control team, who decide how a rule applies to your roof. For the rest of what we do, start from the Horizon Roofing Hereford home page.
Which side of the border is the house on?
Building regulations are devolved. The Building Regulations 2010 apply in both nations, but Wales amends them and publishes its own approved documents, each marked "For use in Wales". An approved document is the government's practical guidance on how to meet a rule, written for builders, designers and building control officers alike, so the guidance that applies is set by the address of the house and not by where the roofer works from.
For the roads around Hereford the split is simple:
- In England: Herefordshire, Worcestershire, Gloucestershire including the Forest of Dean, and the Shropshire edge around Ludlow.
- In Wales: Monmouthshire, Powys and everything inside the Bannau Brycheiniog National Park.
One definition runs through both sets of rules. The Building Regulations 2010, regulation 2, says a thermal element "means a wall, floor or roof (but does not include windows, doors, roof windows or roof-lights)". That matters since a roof counts as a thermal element, which brings it inside the definition: once you re-cover a large enough part of it, the insulation can be pulled into the job, in England and in Wales alike, whichever covering goes on.
Two houses a mile apart, one in England and one in Wales, can therefore face different tests for the same slates. That is why we confirm the address and its nation before we write a quote, and why the sections below keep the two sets of rules apart.
The English test for re-roofing
Where a house in England is being re-roofed, the Planning Portal supplies the test. It says no application is normally required when "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope'" is affected, and "Less than 50 per cent of the roof is affected." Both limbs must hold at once, and neither makes up for the other. Envelope means the complete outer shell of the building: every wall, the floor and the roof with its openings, so one slope of a large house can sit well under the first limb while still being a big share of the roof itself. That second limb is the one to watch.
Keep the qualifiers. The Portal says "normally", and the council's building control team can tell you if your job falls outside the normal case. Herefordshire Council runs its own building control service, so for a Herefordshire address that is the first call, and the officer can say whether your particular slope and covering count as an application.
Flat roofs have a twist. Under Approved Document L in England, the examples of renovation it lists include a flat roof having its waterproof membrane replaced, so a new covering on a flat extension can raise the insulation question even when the roof is small. A pitched roof is judged the same way once the covering is stripped back to the rafters.
Before you ring, have these to hand:
- photographs of the existing covering, taken at the eaves and inside the loft
- the approximate area of each roof slope you plan to renew
- the new covering you have in mind, and whether it is heavier
- whether the loft is insulated at ceiling level or between the rafters
The Welsh test for re-roofing
Wales starts from a different place. The Welsh Government says of re-roofing: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval." The starting presumption in Wales is approval, with exceptions, where England starts from no application, with limits. For a householder with a Welsh address, the safe habit is to ring the council's building control team before the scaffold goes up rather than after the old covering is off.
The Welsh Government's roof page then draws a smaller line. In Wales, repairing or re-covering a small share of the area of a pitched or flat roof is not normally something that needs an application, and the Welsh Government page gives the exact share; building control will confirm it for your roof. Approval is needed in Wales if you carry out structural alterations, if the new covering's fire performance will be significantly different, or if the area you replace or repair is larger, in which case upgrading the roof insulation would normally be required.
Changing material draws a specific warning. In Wales, a switch to a different material from the original, slate to tiles being the example the Welsh Government gives, is likely to need approval. The check covers structural stability where the replacement is significantly heavier or lighter, and it covers fire safety and energy efficiency as well.
On flat roofs in Wales, some repairs need no application. Replace a flat roof that has its insulation built in, though, and the Welsh Government says the thermal element may have to be upgraded. Our guide to re-roofing a house in Wales follows a job from the survey to the last tile.
Heavier coverings and the 15 per cent line
Weight is the one test that is close to the same on both sides. In England, the Planning Portal says approval is needed if "You use a new covering material which increases the weight of the roof covering by 15 per cent or more." Approved Document A, which deals with structure, puts it as "A significant change in roof loading is when the loading upon the roof is increased by more than 15%." The two wordings differ by a hair, so quote one and name it: the Portal says 15 per cent or more, Approved Document A says more than 15%.
In Wales, the Welsh version of Approved Document A carries the same sentence at paragraph 4.4. It is a Building Regulations matter, never a planning one, and the point of it is a structural check on the timbers that carry the roof.
That check looks at:
- the rafters, the sloping timbers under the battens
- the purlins, which are horizontal beams carrying the rafters partway up the slope
- the wall plate, a timber laid in mortar along the head of the wall
- any signs of past movement, such as a sagging ridge
Any change to a covering of a different weight is exactly the kind of change the check exists for. Our guide to choosing a new roof covering sets out what each covering asks of the timbers beneath it.
Two further special cases in England: the Planning Portal says "Building regulations approval will always apply when removing chimney breasts", and for a conservatory it says "A new roof must comply with building regulations", so ask your building control body before you order one.
Part L: the insulation figures for each nation
Part L is the part of the Building Regulations that deals with saving fuel and power. It sets U-values, which measure how much heat passes through a roof or window: the lower the figure, the better the insulation. These are the figures that apply to the work on this page, in W/m²K.
| Element | England (AD L 2021) | Wales (AD L 2022) |
|---|---|---|
| New roof on an existing home | 0.15 (Table 4.2) | 0.13 (Table 4.1) |
| Roof window | 1.4 or WER Band B | 1.4 or WER Band B |
| Rooflight | 2.2 | 2.2 |
| Renovated roof, including a loft conversion | 0.35 threshold, improved to 0.16 (Table 4.3) | 0.16, and not worse than 0.35 where 0.16 is not feasible (Table 11.1) |
A rooflight is held to 2.2; a roof window follows the window figure instead. In England, paragraph 4.13 relaxes the renovation figure where the upgrade would not pay back within 15 years, and the renovated element should generally come out no worse than 0.7.
In Wales, the whole element is improved where the area renovated is greater than 50% of the element (paragraph 11.14), with a payback test of 15 years in paragraphs 11.20 and 11.21.
Both nations have a new edition coming: in England, Approved Document L 2026 takes effect on 24 March 2027, and in Wales the new Approved Document L takes effect on 4 March 2027. Until those dates, the tables above apply.
Who does the building control
Building control is done either by the council or by a registered building control approver, a private business that has registered with the Building Safety Regulator. Across England and Wales, every private business that wants to do building control work under the Building Act 1984 must apply to register with that Regulator.
The two nations differ in how they are overseen:
- In England, the registration regulations came into force on 6 April 2024. Building control by private firms was already around before that date; it is the registration scheme that is new.
- In Wales, the Regulator acts on behalf of the Welsh Ministers and regulates registered building inspectors and approvers, but it does not regulate local authority building control. Local authorities, according to the Welsh Government, answer to the Welsh Ministers.
- In Wales, new building regulations came into force on 1 July 2026, replacing the deposit of plans for non-higher-risk work with applications for building control, and building control approval lapses automatically after three years.
For a Herefordshire address in England, Herefordshire Council Building Control can be reached on 01432 261938 or at bce@herefordshire.gov.uk. For Monmouthshire and Powys addresses in Wales, ask the council's building control service or a registered building control approver.
Within the Bannau Brycheiniog National Park, the Park Authority's role is confined to planning. Building control stays with the council, so a roof inside the Park still goes to the council for Building Regulations, and to the National Park Authority for any planning question. Party wall questions, covered in our guide to roof checks when buying a house, go to a party wall surveyor, not to building control.
