01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Stone tiles

Herefordshire stone roof tiles: tilestones, sources and repair

The older stone roofs of Herefordshire carry tilestones cut from local sandstone, split and dressed for the job. This guide covers where they come from, how they are laid and how they are mended.

Horizon Roofing Hereford 9 min read

Where did the tilestones on Herefordshire's traditional stone roofs come from? The building stone atlas answers with the St Maughans sandstones, around the Golden Valley. A tilestone is a slab of that local sandstone, split thin and dressed to hang on a roof. Stone slate and flagstone are other names for the same family of coverings, and the atlas puts the word slate in inverted commas when it describes them.

The covering shapes the look of the older villages and farmsteads, and it shapes the repair as well. A stone roof is heavy, its tiles are not made to a catalogue, and a replacement has to be found rather than ordered. Anything that can be reused is kept, which is why the survey and the sorting matter more here than the rebuilding.

The sections below cover the sources, the places named in the atlas, the colour and the lay, repair, where stone can still be had, and the consent that listed and Welsh-side roofs bring. For the wider subject, see our slate roofing page.

What a tilestone is, and where it was quarried

The atlas is a Strategic Stone Study published in September 2012 and hosted by Herefordshire Council. It traces the roofing stone to the St Maughans Formation, with a possible contribution from sandstone bands in the Raglan Mudstone. Quarries are still active in the St Maughans stone, and the permissions held for working it cluster in the Golden Valley, out at the county's western margin.

Other stones were used as well. Downton Castle Sandstone was quarried historically both as freestone and as tilestone, and the brownstones supplied tilestones along with dimension stone. A freestone is a stone that can be cut in any direction without splitting, and dimension stone is stone cut to size for walling and other building. A tilestone is the opposite case, a stone chosen because it splits into thin, flat slabs along its natural beds.

For the reader with a roof in front of them, the useful point is that the stone is local, and so is the pattern of what was available:

  • the St Maughans sandstones, centred on the Golden Valley
  • Downton Castle Sandstone, used as freestone and as tilestone
  • flagstones from the Raglan Mudstone, in the places the next section names
  • the brownstones, cut for tilestones and for dimension stone

None of this tells you what your own roof is made from. The stone on a particular house has to be identified by looking at it, and the survey photographs record the colour, the thickness and the way each stone has weathered.

Longtown, Kington and the Black and White villages

The atlas names places where the stone roof is still plain to see. The older cottages of Longtown are still roofed with flagstones, it says, and Kington's older cottages are roofed with flagstones from the younger Raglan Mudstone Formation. A flagstone is a flat sandstone slab, here put to use as a roof covering rather than as paving.

The Black and White Village Trail runs through the timber-framed north-west of the county, and the atlas counts Eardisland, Pembridge and Weobley among its villages, with Almeley, Dilwyn and Yarpole. Stone shows up in those houses in other ways. The timber frames stand on plinths of sandstone or siltstone, and the big outside chimneys are, the atlas says, commonly built of local sandstone. Those stacks stand on the roof line, so a stone stack and a stone roof can meet at a flashing.

Places in the atlas, and the stone it names
PlaceWhat the atlas says
LongtownOlder cottages roofed with flagstones
KingtonOlder cottages roofed with Raglan Mudstone flagstones
Black and White villagesStacks commonly of local sandstone

Our guide to the flagstone roofs of Longtown looks at that village in more detail. The roof itself is the only evidence that counts for any one house, so the survey starts with the stone and the way it is laid, not with a village name. Each stone differs a little from its neighbours, which is why a replacement is chosen against the course it will sit in and not ordered by the pallet.

Where a stone stack meets a stone roof, the repair is best made in the same stone at the flashing and at the chimney foot, so the whole elevation stays consistent.

Colour, lay and the double lap

SPAB's advice on slate and stone roofing in the Marches takes in Herefordshire, Worcestershire, Shropshire, west Gloucestershire and Wales. It says Welsh slate and stone roofs "are predominantly double-lapped", which means the courses overlap down the slope, with each stone sheltered by those above it, as on a slate roof. The overlap is explained in our guide to slate pitch and headlap.

On colour, SPAB describes the region's stone slates as grey to brown, with purple types turning up in Herefordshire. A purple stone is therefore a local variety, and it is worth recognising on a roof before anyone proposes replacing it with something plainer. Our short answer on purple stone slates in Herefordshire deals with that.

SPAB places the Herefordshire sources from the Olchon Valley across to the Golden Valley, and a further source north of Hay-on-Wye. Tilestones are laid in courses, and natural stone is not uniform, so a roof can look uneven from the ground when it is in fact in good order.

That unevenness is part of the character, and it is also what a like-for-like repair has to respect. A roof re-covered in evenly cut stone or in slate reads as a different building, even where the new covering is sound. The honest test of a repair is whether, from the lane, you can tell where it was done. We photograph the roof from the same spot before and after, so you can judge that for yourself.

Repairing a stone tile roof

Stone-tile work starts with a survey, and the first question is what can stay. A stone that is sound and still hanging securely is left where it is, a stone that has slipped is rehung, and a stone that has split or lost its face is replaced with a matching one. The sound stones taken off for a repair are kept for the same roof.

The things we look at, with photographs:

  • stones that are slipped, split or missing a face
  • the fixings behind them, and whether the battens or timbers are sound
  • the mortar at hips, ridges and verges
  • the flashings, and the stack where a stone stack meets the roof
  • earlier repairs in other stone, slate or artificial stone

Because stone is heavy, the roof timbers are looked at as closely as the covering. A sagging ridge or a bowed rafter shows that the structure has moved, and rehanging stones on moved timber means lifting a larger area than the visible fault.

SPAB says of stone roofs: "Unfortunately, many are changed to different stones or even to slates or fake stone slates." A change of material alters the look of the building and the way the roof sheds water, so we would rather show you which stones can be kept than propose a covering the house was never built with.

A written price follows the survey of a stone roof, as one total, and it names the stone used for any replacements. For the repair method in detail, see repairing a stone tile roof.

Where matching stone can still be found

Working quarries do exist, as the first section notes, and SPAB's advice on supply is plain: "Claims of unavailability or long delivery times should always be checked with the quarries." If anyone says matching stone cannot be had, the quarry is the place to confirm it.

The Ewyas Lacy Study Group, a local history group, writes that stone tiles have been a traditional roofing material in Ewyas Lacy for centuries, owing to the geology of local sandstone deposits that are relatively easily accessible in the area. Its line fits what the atlas records for the Golden Valley.

Reclaimed stone is another route: tiles from a stripped roof or a demolished building can be sorted and reused, and the same skills apply as with slate. The question to ask a supplier is where the stone came from and what it looks like in daylight, because colour and thickness vary from one source to another.

What to ask a supplier or a quarry:

  • which stone it is, and from which formation or working
  • the thickness and the range of sizes on offer
  • whether the colour can be matched by eye against a stone from your roof
  • how long the order would take, in writing

Our short answer on whether you can still get Herefordshire stone tiles covers the supply side. Reclaimed stone is checked for the same faults as any old covering: cracks, flaking faces and edges worn thin.

Consent and approval: England and Wales

A listed house with a stone roof brings a consent step into any repair that changes its character, and the law differs by country:

  • England: under section 7 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990, works that affect a listed building's character need listed building consent.
  • Wales: under sections 88 and 89 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023, works to a listed building must be authorised by listed building consent.

Replacing stone with slate or another covering is the sort of change those consents turn on, and an unlisted house is still a matter for the council. We check with the council whether a conservation area or an Article 4 direction applies before any change of material. Herefordshire has 64 conservation areas.

Re-covering also meets the Building Regulations. For England, the Planning Portal puts the weight test at an increase "by 15 per cent or more", which brings Building Regulations approval. Welsh Government guidance on a different covering uses the case of slate replaced by tiles, where it expects Building Regulations approval to be likely. Stone is heavy, so swapping it for a lighter covering is as much a structural question as a visual one.

We put the plan to building control for the address before the work is priced, and the quote says which consents the job needs. Inside the Bannau Brycheiniog National Park, check with the National Park Authority about planning as well, since the council does not decide that question there.

Stone roofs: your questions

Which Herefordshire stone is the main source of roofing tilestones?

The atlas gives the St Maughans Formation sandstones, centred on the Golden Valley area, as the principal source of Herefordshire stone roofing slate. Some quarries still work them for building and roofing stone, and the permissions held for that sit at the county's extreme western end.

Can a stone tile roof be repaired with the original stones?

Sound stones that come off during a repair are kept for the same roof and rehung, with matching stone for any that have split or lost their face. The survey photographs show which stones can stay, and the written price names the stone used for replacements.

Does a listed stone roof need consent for a repair?

Listing brings consent into any repair that changes the building's character. In England that is section 7 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990, and in Wales sections 88 and 89 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023. Check with the council before any stone is lifted.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing