A slate roof weighs little on each fixing, yet every slate depends on a single small piece of metal. If that metal corrodes, loosens or was the wrong sort for the pitch, the slate slides, and one slipped slate soon becomes a line of them. The way a slate is held to its batten is therefore as much a part of the roof as the slate itself.
There are two methods. Nailing is the long-established method, and a nailed slate has holes punched through it. Hook fixings are the newer alternative: a metal hook fixed to the batten catches the slate at its lower edge, and the slate needs no holes. Cupa, a slate maker, sets a firm pitch limit on hooks, and that limit decides which roofs can use them.
The sections below cover each method, the pitch figures, what the standard asks for, how fixings fail and what changes when a roof is re-slated. For the wider subject see our slate roofing page.
Two ways to hold a slate down
A slate is not glued or screwed to anything. It is overlapped by the slates above, and held at one point so it cannot slide. With a nailed slate, that point is a hole near the head, with a nail driven through it into the batten. The slates in the courses above cover the nail head, so the roof's face shows no metal at all.
With a hooked slate, nothing passes through the slate. A hook is fixed to the batten, curls up in front of the slate's lower edge and holds the tail down. Because the slate is gripped at its foot, it cannot lift in the wind or slide out of its course.
| Method | Where the slate is held | Pitch note |
|---|---|---|
| Nailed | Through holes near the head | Cupa's 20 degree figure, with its conditions |
| Hooked | At the tail, with no holes | Not below 25 degrees, says Cupa |
Neither method is better in itself. Each belongs to a range of pitches and to a kind of slate, so the fixing is named in the specification before a single slate is ordered. The same slate can be nailed on one house and hooked on another, and what separates the two is the slope and the data sheet, never a preference of ours. Hooks leave the slate face clean, but they lean entirely on the grip at the foot of the slate, and that is why their limits are strict.
Nailed slates and what the nails go through
A nail has to do three things for the life of the roof. It must stay in the batten, resist rust and keep hold of a slate that is being tugged by wind. Where any of the three fails, the slate drops a little at a time, first sagging in its course and then sliding out.
Nail failure has its own name. A roof suffering from nail sickness has fixings that have rusted through or worked loose, so the slates beneath them are in good order and are simply no longer fastened. You see the slates slip one by one, sometimes in the same area of the slope. Our guide to nail sickness on a slate roof shows how to tell it from random damage.
When we examine a nailed slope, we look at:
- the nail heads, for rust staining on the slate face below them
- slates that sit out of line or slightly proud of their course
- the holes, for cracking round the nail where the slate has split
- the battens, for rot that lets a nail pull out
- patches where slates have been replaced with a different fixing
The metal of the nail is part of the specification. A nail of the right metal costs little beside the cost of lifting a slope twice, so the quote names what goes in. A single slipped slate in an otherwise firm roof can be refixed. Where the nails across a slope are failing, patching treats the symptom, and we explain why re-slating is the better buy, with photographs of the nails we pulled out.
Hook fixings and the 25 degree line
Cupa is direct about hooks: it rules them out below 25 degrees. The reason, as we read it, lies in how a hooked slate sits. On a low slope the slate rests with its tail close to the batten, and the grip of the hook is the only thing resisting wind lift. As the pitch rises, gravity helps keep the slate down. Below 25 degrees, the hook is asked to do too much.
That figure is separate from the minimum pitch for natural slate itself. Cupa also reports what BS 5534:2014+A2:2018 indicates for the lowest pitch of natural slate: 20 degrees for moderate exposure with a 500 mm slate and a 115 mm overlap. Every one of those conditions matters, and a shorter slate or a smaller overlap needs its own data sheet.
Put the two together and the position is plain:
| Pitch | Fixing |
|---|---|
| Below 20 degrees | Outside Cupa's slate figure; check the data sheet |
| 20 to below 25 degrees | Nails; hooks are ruled out |
| 25 degrees and above | Nails or hooks |
At 25 degrees and above, the pick between nails and hooks rests on the slate, the exposure and the specification. A roofer who offers hooks on a shallow slope is offering something the slate maker advises against. A roof between 20 and 25 degrees can still be slated, so long as the slates are nailed. Our short answer on hooks on a low pitch goes through the figures further.
What BS 5534 asks, and what it does not
BS 5534:2014+A2:2018 is the edition of the slating and tiling standard now in force, and manufacturers write their instructions to it. It is a recognised method and not a statute, and the difference matters when someone says a particular fix is compulsory. Marley, a tile maker, says plainly that installing to BS 5534 "isn't required by law". What the standard does is set out a method that building control and manufacturers recognise, and a sound roof follows it.
One change in it matters at the edges of a slate roof. Marley reads the 2015 amendments as taking away mortar's standing as the single fixing for a roof covering. Bedding mortar alone is therefore not enough at a ridge or verge on a new job, and a mechanical fixing is expected beside it. Dry-fix systems are covered by a separate standard, BS 8612. Where a slate roof carries a dry ridge, a dry verge or both, the fittings are chosen to suit the slate, and our ridge work follows whichever applies to the roof we are working on.
For slates in the field of the roof, the standard works with the fixing rules above: the slate maker's data sheet gives the nail size and the pitch conditions, and the roofer follows it. We keep one method across a slope, because a hooked slate beside a nailed one behaves differently in wind and makes later repairs harder to read.
Telling when fixings are failing
Failing fixings give notice. Slates that slip once and are refixed, then slip again within a season, point to nails that no longer hold. A gap that opens in the same course on several slopes suggests the fixings were wrong from the start. Slates that rattle in a gale are sitting loose. And a roof that sheds more broken pieces after each blow is asking for a survey.
A tingle is a repair many slate roofs already carry. It is a lead or copper clip, with one end nailed to the batten and the other turned up over the tail of the slate, and it holds a slate where the original nail has gone. One tingle among sound slates is a fair repair. A row of them across one slope points to nails that have given up across the slope, and to battens that deserve a closer look.
On cost, Checkatrade (June 2026, ex VAT) gives natural slate repairs at £150 to £220 per m², for repair areas up to a maximum of 3 m². That is a per-m² rate for small repairs, and it is not a basis for pricing a slope. MyJobQuote's 2026 figure for an average roof repair is around £650. Your own figure is one written total, given after we have been on the roof.
- Refixing a few slipped slates: fixings checked, slates re-hung
- A run of tingles: a sign to look at the nails across the whole slope
- Failed fixings across a slope: a case for re-slating, as set out in re-slating a roof
Changing the fixing when a roof is re-slated
Re-slating is the moment fixings can be changed, and a different fixing is only one part of the job. The slates are stripped, sorted and relaid on new nails or hooks as the specification allows, and the battens and underlay get a check while the roof is open. The need for approval follows the proportion of the roof being re-covered, and the two countries apply different tests:
- In England, the Planning Portal sets two tests together. Under "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope'" and "Less than 50 per cent of the roof", no building application is normally needed.
- Also in England, a covering that adds weight "by 15 per cent or more" needs approval, the Planning Portal says.
- In Wales, the Welsh Government says of re-roofing: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval."
Swapping natural slate for a heavier covering is a weight question in either country, and a structural check follows. A like-for-like re-slate on nails or hooks does not change the weight in the way a different covering would. Even so, we put the question to the building control service that covers the address before work starts, and do not assume. A re-slate is also the chance to replace every nail at once, so that no old fixing is left to fail beside a new slate.
The stripping and relaying itself is described step by step in the re-slating guide linked above.
