A roof window is the easiest way to bring light into a loft, and the planning question behind it is answered one way in England and another in Wales. England's rules come from the General Permitted Development Order 2015. Wales still uses the 1995 Order, with its own wording, and it bars roof lights on protected land that England does not.
Our other pages point here whenever planning comes up, so the conditions are quoted in full and in the Orders' own words. Quotations are in speech marks and are exact. After them come Building Regulations, energy figures and escape windows, then listed houses, conservation areas and Article 4 directions.
Whichever side you are on, two points hold. Permitted development is a planning right, not an approval of the work, and Building Regulations are a separate matter. And if the house is a flat, none of the householder rights below applies.
The short answer on each side of the border
Fitted into an existing slope, a roof window counts as an alteration to a house's roof, so it comes under Class C in Part 1 of the relevant Order. Class C permits it, subject to conditions. The table sets out where England and Wales part company.
| Question | England | Wales |
|---|---|---|
| Class C covers a roof window | Yes, within its conditions | Yes, within its conditions |
| Barred in a conservation area, National Park or National Landscape | No | Yes, on article 1(5) land |
| Side-slope window glazing | Obscure-glazed in every case | Obscure-glazed within the 10.5 metre test |
| New materials must match | No such condition | So far as practicable |
The practical split is this. In England, a roof window needs permission in a conservation area, a National Park or a National Landscape no more than it does elsewhere, provided the conditions are met. In Wales, a new roof light on that kind of land is not permitted development at all, so it needs planning permission.
Dormers are a different matter. They fall under Class B, which sets volume limits of "40 cubic metres in the case of a terrace house" and "50 cubic metres in any other case" in both Orders. Class B is not available on article 2(3) land in England, nor on article 1(5) land in Wales, which is why a dormer in a conservation area almost always means an application.
England: Class C and its conditions, word for word
In England the source is Schedule 2, Part 1 of the General Permitted Development Order 2015. Class C reads: "Any other alteration to the roof of a dwellinghouse." Class C permission is lost if any of the following applies:
- C.1(b): "the alteration would protrude more than 0.15 metres beyond the plane of the slope of the original roof when measured from the perpendicular with the external surface of the original roof"
- C.1(c): "it would result in the highest part of the alteration being higher than the highest part of the original roof"
- C.1(d): "it would consist of or include" either "the installation, alteration or replacement of a chimney, flue or soil and vent pipe", or "the installation, alteration or replacement of solar photovoltaics or solar thermal equipment"
Condition C.2 then governs side slopes. Development is permitted by Class C "subject to the condition that any window located on a roof slope forming a side elevation of the dwellinghouse must be" two things: "obscure-glazed; and" "non-opening unless the parts of the window which can be opened are more than 1.7 metres above the floor of the room in which the window is installed."
In England, then, obscure glazing applies to every side-slope window. The 1.7 metre height relaxes only the non-opening part. Land under article 2(3), which includes conservation areas, National Parks, National Landscapes and World Heritage Sites, removes Class B dormers, but Class C has no article 2(3) exclusion.
Wales: size, height and materials under Class C
Wales still works from the 1995 Order, Schedule 2, Part 1, as amended in Wales. Class C is worded the same way: "Any other alteration to the roof of a dwellinghouse." The conditions that follow are not the English ones.
- C.1(a): development is not permitted if "the alteration would protrude more than 15 centimetres beyond the plane of the slope of the original roof"
- C.1(b): or if "it would result in the highest part of the alteration being higher than the highest part of the original roof"
- C.2(a): the condition on materials, that "the appearance of the materials used in each element of any exterior work must so far as practicable match the appearance of the materials used in the equivalent element of the existing dwellinghouse"
The materials condition has no English counterpart, and it matters for a re-roof as well as a roof window. The Welsh Government's plain-English summary says planning permission is not normally needed to insert roof lights or skylights, and that the materials used should match those on the existing roof as far as possible.
Chimneys come into it too. Welsh condition C.1(c) excludes, among other things, "the installation, alteration or replacement of a chimney" and "(vii)the removal of a chimney from a dwellinghouse on article 1(5) land or within a World Heritage Site". So taking a chimney off a roof can need permission in Wales where it would not elsewhere.
That summary is the friendly version. For anything near a limit, the Order's own wording governs, and the council can say how it reads on a particular roof.
Wales: roof lights on protected land and side windows
Two Welsh conditions have no English twin. The first is C.1(d), which bars roof lights on protected land: development is not permitted if "the alteration would consist of or include the insertion of a roof light into a roof slope and the dwellinghouse is on article 1(5) land or within a World Heritage Site." Welsh Government guidance defines article 1(5) land as "land in Wales within a National Park, an area of outstanding natural beauty and an area designated as a conservation area." It says plainly that on such land, roof lights are not permitted.
In practice that covers the entire Bannau Brycheiniog National Park, and the section of the Wye Valley National Landscape that lies in Wales. For an address there, check with the National Park Authority or the council, because planning permission is needed.
The second is C.2(b), the side-window test. In Wales, if any element of a window inserted on a roof slope "would, if projected downwards in a vertical line to ground level, be within 10.5 metres of any boundary of the curtilage of the dwellinghouse opposite the relevant side elevation, the window must be":
- "obscure-glazed;"
- "non-opening unless any part of the window which can be opened is, when measured at any point along the lowest edge of that part, at least 1.7 metres above the internal floor or stair of the dwellinghouse directly below that point; and"
- "permanently maintained in compliance with paragraphs C.2(b)(i) and (ii)."
Building Regulations, energy figures and escape windows
Permitted development settles the planning question only. Building Regulations ask their own.
- In Wales, the Welsh Government says: "Approval under the Building Regulations will generally be needed for the installation of a new rooflight".
- In England, a new roof window must meet Approved Document L 2021, Table 4.2, at 1.4 (or WER Band B), and a rooflight against 2.2. Ask Herefordshire Council Building Control, on 01432 261938, whether your window needs an application.
- In Wales, Table 4.1 of the Welsh Approved Document L gives 2.2 for rooflights and, for roof windows, 1.4 or WER Band B, just as England does.
The figure 2.2 belongs to rooflights only. Roof windows follow the window figure instead. Next editions of the document are due: in England AD L 2026 takes effect on 24 March 2027, and in Wales the new edition on 4 March 2027.
A loft room can need an escape window as well. In England, Approved Document B paragraph 2.10 covers storeys up to 4.5 m above the ground: the openable area of an escape window has to be at least 0.33 m², with a minimum height and width of 450 mm, and its openable part must start no higher than 1100 mm above the floor. In Wales, paragraph 3.8 of its Approved Document B sets the same sizes. Above 4.5 m in England, paragraph 2.5 expects a protected stairway or else an alternative escape route, and Welsh paragraph 3.6 gives that same pair of choices.
Listed houses, conservation areas, Article 4 and who to ask
A listed house is not stripped of its Class B and Class C rights, but it also needs listed building consent. In England, section 7 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 asks for consent for works that "affect its character as a building of special architectural or historic interest". In Wales, sections 88 and 89 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 do the same job, and they have been in force since 4 November 2024.
An Article 4 direction can switch permitted development off in a defined area. In England, GOV.UK says it "enables the Secretary of State or the local planning authority to withdraw specified permitted development rights across a defined area". In Wales, the Welsh Government says such directions "are most common in conservation areas". We cannot say what any direction covers, so ask the council if one reaches your street.
Flats are different again. In England, the 2015 Order does not count a flat as a dwellinghouse, so no householder right applies, and the freeholder and the council must be asked. A lease may reserve the roof to the freeholder, which is a second reason to ask before you order a window.
For a house in Herefordshire, ask Herefordshire Council's planning team. In Monmouthshire, the Duty Planning Officer on 01633 644831 takes "queries on whether you need planning permission". Our guides on side-slope roof windows and obscure glass, roof lights in Welsh conservation areas and parks and escape windows cover each in more detail. The wider picture is on our Velux and skylights page.
