Callout 1 of 3
Naming the covering before re-covering it
Before anything else, the covering gets a name. Ashford Carbonell has houses, outbuildings and a church of different ages, and the covering on any one of them may be tile, slate, stone or a replacement laid in recent decades. Each is photographed close up and named in the report, so a repair can be matched to what is truly there and a patch of the wrong colour does not stand out for years. Near the village's conservation areas, a change of material is a question to put to Shropshire Council before it is priced.
Lifespans come hedged. HomeBuilding lists Welsh slate at "100+ years" and plain concrete tiles at "40-50 years". Marley expects roof tiles to last around 60 years and treats that as a forecast, not a promise, while the BRE's 60-year minimum belongs to clay tiles alone. SPAB's note, which covers Wales and the Marches and names Shropshire among its counties, says slate and stone roofs there are "predominantly double-lapped", so a patch is cut in to follow the laps already on the roof. If one slope has failed and the rest has not, repairing that slope is the better buy, and the report marks which slopes are sound; a new covering is offered once the old one is spent throughout.
England's rules on re-covering sit in the Building Regulations. The Planning Portal says no application is normally needed when "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope'" is affected and "Less than 50 per cent of the roof is affected". The envelope is the whole shell of the house, which is why two tests are given. A new covering that "increases the weight of the roof covering by 15 per cent or more" needs approval, and AD A paragraph 4.4 describes a significant change as "more than 15%". Insulation comes up at the same visit: AD L 2021 Table 4.3 sets a threshold of 0.35 and an improved figure of 0.16 for a renovated roof, until AD L 2026 Table 3.3 applies from 24 March 2027. Our roof replacement page covers full re-coverings.
The England re-cover tests in brief
- Building envelope
- Less than 25 per cent affected, in the Planning Portal's test
- Roof itself
- Less than 50 per cent affected, in the same test
- Weight added
- 15 per cent or more needs approval, says the Planning Portal
- Insulation
- AD L Table 4.3: threshold 0.35, improved 0.16
Name the covering first, and the repair can be matched to it.















