Callout 1 of 3
Patch or re-cover: reading a Highnam slope
Every roof job turns on one decision: does a patch do, or does the covering come off? The slopes answer it. Slipped, cracked and missing pieces are counted from the ground, then again at close range from a ladder. Up in the loft, the underlay and the battens, the rails of wood under the tiles, are checked for rot, stains and daylight. Highnam parish had 2,142 usual residents at the 2021 Census, and we start with the roof in front of us, not with a guess about its age.
Lifespans are ranges and never promises. Marley puts roof tiles at around 60 years of expected life and adds that this is no promise of longevity, while HomeBuilding gives plain concrete tiles "40-50 years". The BRE's minimum life expectancy of 60 years is for clay tiles only, and HomeBuilding gives Welsh slate "100+ years". An age inside a range does not make a roof sound or failing. The nails, the battens and the underlay do that.
Weight is the other test of a new covering. The Planning Portal sets approval at an increase of 15 per cent or more in the roof covering's weight, while AD A, in paragraph 4.4, reads a rise of more than 15% as a significant change in loading, so a heavier tile brings a structural check before a batten is nailed. In England, the Planning Portal draws its line for a re-roof at less than 25 per cent of the building envelope and less than 50 per cent of the roof; inside both, an application is normally not needed.
Underlay decides how a re-covered roof breathes. Marley's ventilation guidance for a cold roof with HR (high resistance) underlay calls for 25mm along the eaves at pitches of 15° or less and 10mm above 15°, and HR underlay is not vapour-permeable. Air-permeable (LR) underlay laid over a well-sealed ceiling needs only the 3mm that normal eaves construction gives, on condition that its UKAS third-party certification is in order. We check which kind is under your tiles before deciding what the new layer must be.
A patch is the better buy while the timbers and underlay are sound and the faults are confined to a few tiles or one pitch. Where failure runs across entire slopes, roof replacement describes what stripping, relaying and re-battening involve. Either way you see photographs of the faults first, with the loft timbers shown beside the tiles above them, and a recommendation that says which case your roof is.
What moves the size of a Highnam re-roof
- Roof size
- More pitches and a longer ridge mean more work
- Covering chosen
- Tile or slate, and how closely it must match
- Access
- Scaffold height and any licence for the road
- Hidden condition
- Battens, underlay and timbers found under the old covering
One written total price, never itemised.
A roof's age tells you less than its battens, its nails and the underlay beneath.















