Callout 1 of 3
Clay, slate and the St Michael's Square direction
Gloucester City Council keeps a list of Article 4 directions, and two entries bear on roofs. Among the works the St Michael's Square direction brings under planning control are these four: enlargement, improvement or other alteration to the house, including changing windows and doors; any alteration to the roof, including roof lights, dormer windows and the substitution of clay tiles and natural slates with concrete or other materials; a porch outside any external door; and the installation, alteration or removal of a chimney. The Southgate Street Conservation Area direction, confirmed in January 2014, applies to named properties and includes the first three of those.
In plain terms, a house caught by either direction cannot swap clay for concrete as a free choice, because the substitution is a planning question for Gloucester City Council. Even where no direction applies, the covering matters. Marley, citing the BRE, gives clay tiles a minimum life expectancy of 60 years, and the BRE figure is for clay only. HomeBuilding puts Welsh slate at "100+ years", and SPAB says a well-slated roof is "likely to be more than 100 years". Reclaimed Welsh slate is lower, at "50-80 years" in HomeBuilding. Concrete tiles carry two published figures: Marley says "around 60 years", while HomeBuilding says "40-50 years", and both are named so you can weigh them.
Those lifespans are why a sound clay or slate roof is worth keeping. We strip, sort and refix the good units and replace only the broken ones, with matching new or reclaimed pieces. SPAB's advice is that "Claims of unavailability or long delivery times should always be checked with the quarries", and we make that check before any different material is suggested. The covering is photographed slope by slope, and where a direction applies the pictures go to the council with the proposal. Where a slope is part original and part replacement, the join is photographed too, so the mixed area can be traced. The survey records which units are original and which came later, so that a proposal can match the old covering instead of guessing at it.
To find out whether your house is caught, use the council's own list of directions and ask Gloucester City Council directly, quoting the address. A roof that is not caught still gets the same survey. Our slate roofing page covers sorting, refixing and matching, and the written price states the covering that is proposed.
Checked on a Gloucester slope
- Slipped, cracked or missing tiles and slates
- Nail fixings and slate hooks
- Battens and underlay from the loft
- Gaps at the lowest course above the gutter
- The covering's material set against any direction
A direction can turn a change of covering into a question for the council, so we ask it first.















