Callout 1 of 3
Stone slates and later slates on one Garway roof
Two entries in the Royal Commission's 1931 Herefordshire inventory show how varied a Garway roof can be. Of Church House Farm it wrote "The roof is of stone slates and some modern slates." Of Black House it wrote "The walls are of rubble and the roof is of stone slates." So one roof carried two coverings and another carried one. Modern in 1931 is a century old today, and the join between two coverings is where fixings and laps differ, so the survey maps each slope and names what is on it before a price is considered.
The slate half of such a roof has its own limits. Cupa, the slate supplier, quotes BS 5534:2014+A2:2018 for a 20-degree floor on natural slate, a figure tied to moderate exposure, a 500mm slate and a 115mm overlap. Cupa also says hooks should not be used below 25 degrees. A shallower slope needs a different answer. HomeBuilding's lifespans are "100+ years" for Welsh slate, "75-100 years" for Spanish and "50-80 years" for reclaimed Welsh. SPAB, in its note for Wales and the Marches, says the life of a well-slated roof is "likely to be more than 100 years". These are ranges, not promises, and the state of the nails matters more than the date.
On the stone half, sorting comes before replacing. Sound stones are kept, cracked ones are set aside, and any replacement is chosen to match in size and colour. Herefordshire's stone roofs use local sandstone tilestones, and the building stone atlas gives the St Maughans sandstones as the main source. Where reclaimed slate is used to fill gaps among older slates, we check that its thickness and colour sit with the rest. A slipped slate calls for a repair, nothing more, and the survey tells you which you have. Our slate roofing page goes further into slate repairs and re-slating. Stone slates need careful footing, so boards spread our weight across the slope while the courses are checked, and slates that are lifted go back in the order they came out.
The ridge and the hips are the other places where one covering can meet another. Mortar bedding alone is no longer relied on: Marley says the 2015 amendments to BS 5534 made it clear that mortar "could no longer be relied upon as the only means of securing the roof covering", so a ridge that is rebedded is also fixed mechanically. We photograph each ridge joint from above, because that view is the one you cannot get from the ground.
What the survey records on a mixed slope
- Covering
- Stone slate, slate or both, slope by slope
- Join
- Where one covering meets another
- Fixings
- Nails or clips, sound or corroded
- Pitch
- Measured, then set against the maker's minimum
- Photographs
- Every fault, for your own copy
One roof, two coverings: each slope is identified before any repair is chosen.















