Callout 1 of 3
Stone walls with tiles or slates above them
The Royal Commission's 1931 inventory of Herefordshire grouped monuments 8 to 20 in the parish, which it spelled Llangarren, and said of them: "The walls are of stone and the roofs are covered with tiles or slates." That one line leaves the question open, and a survey has to settle it for the roof we are standing on. Tile and slate are repaired differently, hung differently and fail in different ways, so naming the covering comes before naming the fault.
Telling the two apart is quick. A slate is a thin flat slab, held either by nails punched through its upper end or by a hook at its tail, while a tile is thicker, sometimes curved, and hangs from a nib on its upper edge. On the slope we look for pieces that have slid, snapped or lifted, and for bare battens, the timber laths the covering is fixed to. Marley's published table of minimum pitches runs from 12.5 degrees for one of its Mendip concrete tiles to 40 degrees for its Canterbury clay tile, which is why we read the product data before agreeing a repair or a change of covering.
Age is a range, never a promise. For clay tiles, Marley reports that the BRE determined a minimum life expectancy of 60 years, a figure that belongs to clay alone. HomeBuilding gives clay tiles 60 to 80 years and plain concrete tiles 40 to 50. A roof that has lasted less or more than its range tells us something about the fixings and the battens, and we photograph whatever the loft side of the covering shows.
Stone adds its own checks. Where the roof sits on a stone wall, we look at the wall head, the top few courses beneath the eaves, for loose pointing and for stones that have shifted, because a covering cannot stay tight on a wall that is moving. A gutter that has sagged away from the stone also leaves a damp track down the face, and we trace it back to the bracket or the joint that failed before we price anything.
If a whole slope has to go, England's Planning Portal sets two tests for a re-roof, and both must be met: less than 25 per cent of the building envelope, and less than 50 per cent of the roof. Meet them and nothing normally has to be applied for. A covering heavier by 15 per cent or more needs Building Regulations approval, and the rafters are checked before anything is ordered. Our pitched roofing page sets out the choices for tile and slate.
Checked on a Llangarron slope
- Whether the covering is tile or slate
- Slid, snapped or lifted pieces
- Bare or rotten battens
- Product pitch against the roof pitch
Naming the covering comes before naming the fault.















