01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Matching in Wales

Re-slating in Wales: matching the look of the old roof

A re-slated Welsh roof has to look like the one it replaces, as far as practicable. This guide explains that condition, how the old roof is read, and the Welsh rules that sit beside it.

Horizon Roofing Hereford 9 min read

A slate roof carries the look of a house more than most coverings do. The colour of the slates, the size of each one and the way the courses run all show from the road. In Wales, that look is also written into the planning rules for a householder: when a roof is re-covered under permitted development, the new covering has to match the old one in appearance.

The condition sits in Class C.2(a) of the 1995 Order, which still governs householder development in Wales. It is short, and it is easy to misread in both directions. Some owners assume any slate will do, and others assume a change of covering always needs planning permission. Neither is right.

This guide sets out what the condition says, what counts as appearance, how an old roof is read before new slate is chosen, and where roof lights, chimneys, the National Park and listed status change the position. It ends with the Building Regulations side, which is a separate question. It belongs with our slate roofing guides.

What Class C.2(a) says

Class C of the Welsh order, in the householder part, covers "Any other alteration to the roof of a dwellinghouse", and re-covering is an alteration to the roof. Its conditions in paragraph C.2(a) require that "the appearance of the materials used in each element of any exterior work must so far as practicable match the appearance of the materials used in the equivalent element of the existing dwellinghouse".

The Welsh Government's plain-language page on roofs puts it more simply. It says: "You do not normally need to apply for planning permission to re-roof your house or to insert roof lights or skylights." It adds that the appearance of the materials "must, as far as possible, match the appearance of those used on your existing roof".

Three points follow from the wording:

  • The test is appearance. It does not ask for the same material, and it does not forbid a different one.
  • The words are "so far as practicable", which allows for a close match where an exact one cannot be had.
  • It applies to each element of the work, so the slates, the ridge and the verge are each judged against their equivalents.

How close is close enough is a judgement for the planning authority. Where a case is not clear, the council, or the National Park Authority inside the Park, is asked before the order for the slate is placed.

Reading the old roof before choosing new slate

A match begins with a careful look at what is already there, and it ends with a sample laid against the old slates. Nothing is ordered on the strength of a catalogue picture.

The roof is seen from the road and from the roof, and the old slates are measured and photographed. The features that make up the appearance can be listed:

What the old roof tells us
FeatureWhat is noted
ColourRange from slate to slate, and any weathering
SizeLength and width of the slates on each slope
SurfaceSmooth, rippled or rough, and the edge profile
LayingCourses, headlap and any change in size up the slope
DetailsRidge, verge and eaves finishes

SPAB records that Welsh slate and stone coverings are "predominantly double-lapped". That describes how the courses are laid, and it is part of the look a new roof should keep. A roof laid in a different pattern can look quite unlike the one beside it, even with slate of a similar colour.

The old slates are not always a fixed list of sizes. Some older roofs carry slates of mixed sizes, and a replacement run that is perfectly regular reads as new. Matching therefore starts with the old slates themselves, whenever they are sound enough to go back, and the new slate fills only what is missing. Our guide to re-slating a roof describes how the old slates are sorted for reuse.

Welsh, Spanish, reclaimed and fibre cement slate

Four kinds of slate come up in a Welsh re-slating job. Each can give a close match on some roofs and a poor one on others, so the decision is made roof by roof.

  1. New Welsh slate. SPAB ties the name Welsh slate, as used now, to quarries around Nantlle and Bethesda. On a roof that was slated in Welsh slate it is the obvious starting point.
  2. Spanish slate. A natural slate with its own tone and surface, which has to be checked against the old slates.
  3. Reclaimed Welsh slate. Slates lifted from another roof, which carry their own weathering and can sit well against old slates.
  4. Fibre cement slate. A manufactured slate of even colour and size, which looks flatter than split natural slate.

HomeBuilding's published lifespans are "100+ years" for Welsh slate, "75-100 years" for Spanish and "50-80 years" for reclaimed Welsh slate. Its supply-only prices are £185 per m² for Welsh slate and £72 per m² for Spanish. Both figures cover materials alone and are never turned into a total.

For an owner in Wales, the point is that price and lifespan pull in one direction and appearance may pull in another. If the existing roof is Welsh slate and the planning rule asks for a match, a cheaper slate that is visibly different is not a safe saving. Our guide to natural or man-made slate compares them in more detail.

Roof lights, chimneys and the National Park

The matching condition is only one part of the Welsh order. A re-slate can come with other changes, and some of them lose their permitted development rights in particular places.

Class C in Wales excludes, among other things, "the installation, alteration or replacement of a chimney". It also bars a roof light, where the alteration "would consist of or include the insertion of a roof light into a roof slope and the dwellinghouse is on article 1(5) land or within a World Heritage Site". The Welsh Government's technical guidance describes article 1(5) land as land in Wales "within a National Park, an area of outstanding natural beauty and an area designated as a conservation area". Within the Bannau Brycheiniog National Park, in a conservation area or on the Welsh side of the Wye Valley, a new roof light therefore needs planning permission.

Roof lights lose their permitted development right in these places:

  • the Bannau Brycheiniog National Park
  • any conservation area
  • an area of outstanding natural beauty, such as the Welsh side of the Wye Valley
  • a World Heritage Site

Inside the Park, planning questions go to the National Park Authority, and we put them there and not to the county council. Building control stays with the council. The council's building control service, or a registered building control approver, handles that side.

The conditions for roof windows and roof lights are laid out in our roof window planning guide.

A listed house is separate again. The Welsh class has no exclusion for listed buildings, yet listed building consent is still needed where the work changes the building's character, as the section below explains.

Listed houses and conservation areas in Wales

Listed building law in Wales changed on 4 November 2024, when the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 came into force. Section 88(1) says: "A person must not carry out works to which this section applies, or cause such works to be carried out, unless the works are authorised under section 89." Section 89 is the authorisation by listed building consent, and the works caught include alterations that touch what makes the building special.

A new covering can be such a work. If a house is listed, the slates, the ridge, the lead and the fixings can all be part of what makes it special, so the match is not only a matter of colour. The consent route comes first, and permitted development comes second.

Part 4 of the same Act is the source of conservation areas in Wales, and in one a roof light loses its permitted development right, as described above. The Welsh Government adds that an Article 4 direction can take permitted development rights away, mostly in conservation areas. We do not state what any direction covers. We ask the council to confirm whether one applies to the address.

The plain rule for every owner in a listed house or a conservation area is to ask the council first and order the slate second. Our lead details on a slate roof guide covers the metalwork that sits within that picture.

The Welsh Building Regulations behind a re-slate

Building Regulations are a separate question from planning. The Welsh Government says of re-roofing: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval." For a change of material it says: "If the existing roof covering is to be replaced with a different material to its original for example, slate to tiles, then approval under the Building Regulations is likely to be needed". The reason it gives is stability, since a new covering that weighs a good deal more or less than the old one changes the load, with fire safety and energy use also in play.

Three more Welsh points matter on a re-slate:

  • Weight. Approved Document A for Wales says: "A significant change in roof loading is when the loading upon the roof is increased by more than 15%."
  • Insulation. The Welsh Government says "the work to re-cover a roof should also include for improving the thermal insulation properties of the roof". Under Approved Document L for Wales, Table 11.1 asks for 0.16 W/m²K in a renovated roof, and not worse than 0.35 where 0.16 is not feasible. Paragraph 11.14 extends the work to the entire element once more than 50% of its surface is renovated, and under paragraphs 11.20 and 11.21 a payback within 15 years is the economic test.
  • Timing. A new Approved Document L for Wales takes effect on 4 March 2027.

Welsh building control changed on 1 July 2026, when new building regulations came into force, with reform of the process for higher-risk building work. The Welsh Ministers regulate local authority building control, and the Building Safety Regulator oversees registered building control approvers on their behalf. Before a re-slate starts we ask the council's building control service or a registered approver which route applies to the address.

Matching a Welsh slate roof: your questions

Do I need planning permission to re-slate in Wales?

Not normally. According to the Welsh Government, re-roofing does not normally call for a planning application, provided the new materials resemble the ones already on the house as closely as is practicable. A listed house, a conservation area or an Article 4 direction changes that, so the council is asked first.

Can I use a different slate if it looks the same?

The condition tests appearance, and "so far as practicable" allows a close match. Whether a different slate is close enough is for the planning authority to judge. Laying a sample against the old slates in daylight, and asking the council before ordering, is the safe way to find out.

Why does the National Park Authority matter for a roof in Bannau Brycheiniog?

Planning questions about a roof inside the National Park go to the Park Authority, which acts as the planning authority for that land, and not to the county council. Permitted development does not extend to a new roof light on that land. Building control stays with the council or a registered building control approver.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing