The choice between natural and man-made slate can be made when two quotes arrive and the figures sit a long way apart. Price is only one of four things that separate the coverings. The others are how much they weigh on the rafters, how they look from the road, how long they can be expected to last, and which rules a change of covering sets off. This guide takes each in turn.
Natural slate is cleaved from rock. Man-made slate is made in a factory, and the best-known type is fibre cement. Both are laid in overlapping courses and fixed with nails or hooks, so a new roof of either can look alike from the far side of the street. Close up, and later in the life of the roof, they behave differently.
We can lay either, and we say which one suits the house in front of us. The sections run from the material itself to cost and approval. For the wider subject, see our slate roofing page.
What each covering is made of
Natural slate begins as a block of rock that splits along flat planes, and each slate is trimmed from one of those splits. No two have quite the same thickness, tone or edge. SPAB, the building conservation charity, ties the label Welsh slate today to quarrying around Nantlle and Bethesda in the north-west. Spanish slate is the usual imported alternative, and reclaimed Welsh slate is a third route: slates lifted from an old roof, sorted, and sold on. Reclaimed slate is the most variable of the three, because each slate carries the wear of its first roof.
A fibre cement slate is a manufactured sheet of cement reinforced with fibres, pressed to a set size and thickness. Every slate in a pack matches the rest, which suits a plain modern roof and makes laying quick. HomeBuilding's lifespan table lists fibre cement (Eternit) tiles at "30-40 years".
A word on age. Older fibre cement slates may contain asbestos, and HSE says: "If the building was built or refurbished before 2000, assume that there is asbestos in it." HSE's guidance on asbestos cement roofs calls them fragile in every case, so nobody should step on one. On an older roof of this kind we treat the covering as suspect until it is shown otherwise, and the route for taking it off is agreed with you before anything is touched. Decisions about what to lay in its place only come after that.
Weight and what the rafters carry
Slates differ in weight from one product to the next. Natural slate varies by thickness and by origin, and fibre cement is made to a set thickness. Neither can be given a single figure, so the weight on a quote should come from the data sheet of the actual slate, never from memory or a rule of thumb.
Weight matters for two reasons. The rafters and walls have to carry it, and the Building Regulations take notice when it changes. Both countries use the same number in Approved Document A, where paragraph 4.4 says: "A significant change in roof loading is when the loading upon the roof is increased by more than 15%." What each side adds on top is different:
- In England, approval comes into play, the Planning Portal says, once a covering adds weight "by 15 per cent or more".
- In Wales, the Welsh Government gives "slate to tiles" as its example of a change of material, where approval is "likely to be needed" if the replacement is "significantly heavier or lighter".
Swapping natural slate for a lighter fibre cement slate therefore counts as a change of weight, and it is checked in the same way as a move to a heavier tile. We ask building control which test applies before ordering, and we bring the maker's weights to that conversation. If the rafters are marginal, a structural check follows and the covering may change. Where the new slate weighs the same as the old, the loading is unchanged, and the question moves on to fixings and battens.
How they look from the road
A roof is seen from the road far more than from the roof, and slate shows its type at that distance. Natural slate has a slightly uneven surface, so light breaks across it and the courses shimmer a little in different weather. Its edges are not perfectly straight, and its tone ranges within a batch from darker to lighter. Reclaimed slate adds a weathered face that new slate takes time to match.
Fibre cement is flatter and more even. Its colour is the same across the roof, and the courses run in dead-straight lines. On a new extension that can be what the owner wants. On a Victorian terrace beside a row of natural slate roofs, it stands out as a patch.
SPAB's note on the roofs of Wales and the Marches adds a warning on the other side. Of stone slates it says: "Unfortunately, many are changed to different stones or even to slates or fake stone slates." A roof that loses its original covering loses part of the building's character, and the change is hard to reverse.
Neither look is better in the abstract. The right one belongs to the house and to the roofs on either side of it. When two roofs share a wall or a ridge, we compare samples side by side in daylight and photograph them from the pavement, so you can judge the match before the order is placed. Our guide to re-slating a roof describes how a whole slope is sorted and relaid.
Lifespan: what the published ranges say
Lifespans for roofing are typical ranges and never promises. The ranges below come from HomeBuilding and from SPAB, and each keeps its own hedge. The pitch, how the slates are held and how the roof is looked after all move a real roof towards one end of its range or the other.
| Covering | Published range | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Welsh slate | "100+ years" | HomeBuilding |
| Spanish slate | "75-100 years" | HomeBuilding |
| Reclaimed Welsh slate | "50-80 years" | HomeBuilding |
| Fibre cement (Eternit) | "30-40 years" | HomeBuilding |
SPAB adds a line for well-laid natural slate: "the life of a well-slated roof is likely to be more than 100 years". Note the word "likely" and the phrase "well-slated". Fixings, battens and lead details do not last as long as the slate itself, so a roof of long-lived slate can still need work on its fixings and flashings.
How a slate is laid counts for as much as the slate, so the fixings, headlap and battens are specified as carefully as the slate. Read across the table and the picture is clear. A manufactured slate can be a fair choice for a small roof, a garage or an outbuilding where length of life matters less. On a house you plan to keep, the longer range of natural slate is part of its value. Our short answer on how long Welsh slate lasts goes further, and a second one covers fibre cement.
Price: what the cost guides say
The cost guides do not agree, and that is worth knowing before you compare quotes. HomeBuilding (30 September 2025) gives £10,000 to £15,000 for a 65 m² semi roofed in concrete plain tiles, while on a Welsh slate version it writes that the figure "might reach £18,000". MyJobQuote's slate page puts a slate re-roof at around £7,800 on average. Which? (November 2025 survey, ex VAT) gives £7,000-£21,000 for re-covering an average three-bedroom house in full. Ask every quote what its figure includes: scaffold, VAT, the lead and the battens.
On the covering alone, HomeBuilding gives supply-only prices per m² of £185 for Welsh slate and £72 for Spanish. Those are materials, they leave out laying, and they should never be multiplied into a total. They do show how far apart two natural slates can sit before any fibre cement is considered.
What moves the final price of a re-slate:
- the covering chosen and its supply price
- the area and steepness of the roof, and how easily it can be reached
- how sound the battens and underlay are
- whether the lead details are renewed at the same time
- scaffold, which the written quote includes
A single written figure comes once the survey is done. A fair comparison asks for both coverings on the same specification, with the same lead and the same battens, and we price them that way if you want to see them side by side.
Approval and planning, country by country
Changing the covering sets off Building Regulations and planning questions, and the country matters. The weight test above applies in both. The planning point is different in each:
- In England, re-roofing is normally permitted development under Class C of the 2015 Order, and a change of covering carries no materials-matching condition, so slate to fibre cement is normally permitted development on a house that is not listed.
- In Wales, Class C.2(a) of the 1995 Order requires the appearance of the materials to "so far as practicable match" the existing. A fibre cement slate on a natural slate roof has to look like it, and if it does not, the council must be asked.
Our planning guide at roof window planning in England and Wales sets the conditions out in full.
Listed buildings follow separate law. In England, section 7 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 brings in listed building consent where works affect what gives a building its special interest. In Wales, section 88 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 says such works must be authorised, by consent under section 89, and that has applied since 4 November 2024. On a listed house, a new covering raises a consent question in either country, whatever the planning position.
An Article 4 direction can withdraw permitted development rights, so we ask the council whether one applies to the address before a covering is chosen. The approval tests for re-covering are laid out in the re-slating guide linked earlier on this page. A house in Wales that has a slate roof today stays inside the matching condition most easily by keeping to natural slate of a similar colour and size, and the Wales-only guide on matching the old roof goes into that.
