Anyone who has had a roofing quote lately may have seen the number 5534 in it. The standard is called BS 5534, and it is the British code of practice for roofs finished in slate or tile. It sets out how a covering should be chosen, set out on the battens and held down against the wind. Roofing firms refer to it, manufacturers write their fixing guides around it, and surveyors expect to see it named.
It is also widely misunderstood. Some owners are told that mortar on a ridge breaks the law. Others are told that a standard carries no weight at all and can be ignored. Neither is right, and Marley, a tile maker with a technical team that deals with this daily, sets out where the real line sits.
The sections below take the standard in plain terms: what it is, where it stops being a legal matter, what changed in 2015 and 2018, how it sits beside older stone and clay roofs, and what to ask a roofer in writing. Both sides of the border are covered, and any point that differs is tagged with its side. For the wider work on tiled roofs, see our pitched roofing page.
What the standard is, in plain words
Marley describes BS 5534 as the code of practice for installing slates and tiles to new-build pitched roofs and vertical cladding. It was the first guidance of its kind to give recommendations on the design, performance and installation of such roofs. Re-roofing and repairs come within it too, so it reaches a job on an existing house as much as a new build, and the same fixing questions come up on both.
The edition in force is BS 5534:2014+A2:2018, which means the 2014 standard with its second amendment of 2018.
Marley lists what the contents cover:
- how battens are selected
- the methods of fixing a covering
- wind uplift formulas
- a way of calculating the fixing specification for a roof
A code of practice sets recommendations, which is different from a rulebook with penalties. It describes how work should be done so that a roof holds up, and it gives everyone involved, from the tile maker to the person writing a quote, a shared reference to point at. Marley adds that makers in the roofing industry typically align their installation guides with the standard, and that any deviation needs documented evidence to prove suitability.
The standard is a recommendation about method. It does not tell you which tile to buy, and it does not give a lifespan. For the pitch limits that decide which products can go on a slope, our guide to roof pitch limits for tiles and slates sets out the published figures.
Not the law, but not optional in practice
Marley states the position directly: "Installing to BS 5534 isn't required by law". It then adds that the standard's inclusion in a specification can be upheld in court if necessary, and that its guidance helps a roof meet the Building Regulations.
Those two points sit side by side, and both are useful to an owner:
- Marley is plain that BS 5534 is not a legal requirement, so "it's the law" is the wrong sentence to hear.
- If a quote or a contract says the work will be done to BS 5534, that promise can be enforced, which is why it is worth having it written down.
The Building Regulations point is where the standard has weight. Approved Documents explain how to meet the regulations for structure, fire and weather resistance. Work on a roof that is done to a recognised British Standard is easier to show as compliant. In England, building control for the council or a registered building control approver checks the roof work that comes under the regulations. In Wales, the same job goes to the council's building control or a registered approver, under Welsh rules that are made separately.
A product laid in a way its maker does not describe can be at odds with both the guide and the standard, so the safest route is to ask which documents the quote follows.
We name the standard and the product's own data sheet in the written price, and we say which parts of the roof they apply to.
What changed in 2015: mortar alone is no longer enough
Ridge, hip and verge tiles were traditionally bedded on mortar. Mortar sets hard and holds well while it is sound, but it cracks and weathers, and a loose bed gives the wind a way in. The 2015 amendments dealt with that.
Marley's account says the changes were driven by extreme weather, which was putting more strain on roofs and raising insurance claims, and by a need to align with European standards. Its summary of what the 2015 amendments did is the part owners most need:
| Change | What it means on the roof |
|---|---|
| Mortar | By itself, mortar is no longer something to be "relied upon" for the whole fixing |
| Single-lap, hip and ridge tiles | Fixed mechanically, with or without mortar |
| Perimeter tiles | Fixed twice |
| Wind loads | Higher loads assumed, so more fixings generally |
A mechanical fixing is a clip, nail or screw that holds the tile to the roof structure without depending on the mortar. Mortar remains allowed, and a ridge can still be bedded in it. What the standard asks is that the mortar is not carrying the whole load on its own.
In practice that gives a clear check on an older ridge. If the capping tiles are held by mortar only, and the mortar is crumbling, they are not fixed in the way the current standard recommends. If the tiles are also clipped or screwed, a worn mortar bed is a weathering repair, not a safety fault.
That is why we look for a fixing when we look at a ridge, not only the mortar. Our guide to whether a dry ridge uses mortar deals with that sort of system.
The 2018 amendment, BS 8612 and underlay drape
The 2015 changes were followed by rapid growth in dry-fix systems. Marley records that their quality varied and that there was no defined way to compare them, and that site problems arose from confusion over fitting underlays over rafters and the correct drape. The standard was updated again in February 2018.
The 2018 amendment, which gives BS 5534:2014+A2:2018, is described by Marley as aiming to further improve the security, durability and weather-tightness of new and refurbished pitched roofs. It refers to BS 8612:2018, which supports BS 5534 by setting out fixing and ventilation standards for dry-fix systems for ridges, hips and verges.
Other changes Marley lists include:
- a scope that now takes in ordinary re-roofing and repairs
- support for BS 8000-6:2023 on the workmanship of slating and tiling
- classification of underlays by wind uplift resistance
- a revised definition of low water resistance (LR) and air-permeable underlays, and a maximum underlay drape of 15 mm
- new wording on shielding the roof from rain until the covering is fixed, aimed at keeping UV light off underlays
Drape is the amount an underlay sags between rafters, and Marley names confusion over the right drape among the site problems that led to the 2018 amendment.
For a homeowner, the lesson is simple. A dry-fix verge or ridge is not a lesser choice, but it has to be a system with a specification to BS 8612, fixed as its maker describes. When a quote offers a dry verge, ask which system, and for its data sheet.
Our guide to what BS 8612 covers follows that part of the story.
Older roofs, stone tiles and heritage buildings
BS 5534 was written with modern coverings in mind, and Marley says so about older work. It notes that the amended standard clarifies its scope in relation to heritage roofs, saying its recommendations may not be appropriate for them. Fixing methods for traditional roofing materials can conflict with BS 5534, and consultation with local planning authorities and conservation experts is advised so that a suitable approach can be agreed.
That matters across the Hereford area, where traditional stone roofs use local sandstone tilestones, and the county's building stone atlas names the St Maughans sandstones as the main source. SPAB, the old-buildings society, calls Welsh slate and stone roofs "predominantly double-lapped" in its advice note. A stone tile roof is laid in a very different way from a modern interlocking tile roof, so a standard designed around modern products cannot be applied to it clause by clause.
On an older house, three questions come first:
- Is the building listed, or in a conservation area? If so, the council may need to agree the method before work starts. In England, that is the local planning authority under the 1990 Act. In Wales, it is the council under the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023.
- What is the roof covering, and can the original be kept or matched?
- What fixing does the existing structure allow?
Where a roof is protected, we raise the question of fixings with the council and show you what is proposed. Where it is not, the repair is matched to the age and make of the roof, so stone or old clay does not get a modern method imposed without a reason.
Questions to put in writing before the work starts
Because the standard is a recommendation, what matters is what your contract says. These are the points to ask a roofer to confirm on paper:
- Which standard or data sheet does the work follow, and for which parts of the roof?
- How will the ridge, hip and verge tiles be fixed, and is mortar the only fixing?
- What underlay is proposed, and what is its classification?
- Does the quote say whether VAT and scaffold are included?
- Who deals with building control, and which office is it?
On re-roofing and approval, the two sides of the border work differently:
- In England, the Planning Portal says a new covering that adds weight "by 15 per cent or more" needs Building Regulations approval. This is not a planning matter.
- In Wales, the Welsh Government says re-roofing "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval."
For work that comes under either set of rules, building control for the house's own side is asked first, whether that is the council or a registered building control approver.
Our price is one total, written after a survey, and the survey photographs show the ridge, verges and fixings as found on your roof. If a ridge is fixed by mortar alone, you see it in a picture, and you see the proposed fixing beside it. If the tiles are good and only the fixings have let go, re-fixing is the repair. A full replacement comes up only when the covering itself has run its course.
