01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Under the tiles

Underlay and ventilation under a tiled roof: HR and air-permeable

Underlay and ventilation decide whether a tiled roof stays dry inside as well as out. This guide explains the two underlay types, the eaves gap and what we check.

Horizon Roofing Hereford 9 min read

Tiles shed most of the rain, but they are not watertight on their own. Wind can push a little water under the laps, and fine snow can blow through the gaps. Under the tiles and battens lies a second layer, the underlay, which catches what gets through and sends it down into the gutter. In older houses the layer was felt, and some of the oldest roofs have no layer at all.

Underlay also affects the air in the loft. Warm, damp air from a house rises into the roof space, and if it meets cold timber and cannot escape it condenses. Which underlay is used decides how much ventilation the roof needs, and a mismatched pair is a known route to a damp loft. The sections below separate the two main types, set out the eaves gap in a cold roof, show how to read the signs and cover the rules.

The whole range of tiled-roof work is on our pitched roofing page.

The layer between the battens and the rafters

Underlay is rolled across the rafters and sits beneath the battens that carry the tiles. The strips overlap from the lowest course upwards, and at the eaves the sheet is dressed into the gutter or over a support tray so that water drops clear of the wall. Nobody sees it once the tiles are on, which is why its condition has to be recorded while the roof is open or from the loft.

Two types matter when you read a quote, and a third turns up on old roofs.

Underlay types and what each asks of the roof
TypeWhat it isWhat it needs
HR underlayHigh resistance. Not vapour-permeableVentilation at the eaves
Air-permeable underlayLets air and vapour passA sealed ceiling and certified product
Old felt or noneAged bitumen felt, or bare battensSurvey, case by case

The word people reach for is "breathable", and it causes confusion. The HR in the name means high resistance: moisture does not pass through that sheet, and it counts as not vapour-permeable, so a roof laid with it cannot count on the underlay to let damp out. The air-permeable sort, sometimes written LR, does let air through, but only under conditions the maker sets out.

On the oldest houses you look up from the loft straight at the tiles or stone, sometimes with lime torching between the battens. That roof has no second skin, so a damp batten lies near the gap that let the water in.

HR underlay and the gap at the eaves

A cold roof is one with the insulation laid along the loft floor, leaving the roof space above it cold and ventilated. With an HR underlay, the air has to come in at the eaves. Marley, the tile maker, gives the rule for a cold roof as "25mm along the length of the eaves for pitches of 15° or less; 10mm along the length of the eaves for pitches of more than 15°".

Two points sit inside that sentence. The gap runs along the length of the eaves, not at a few points, and it gets smaller as the pitch gets steeper. The pitch is measured on the roof, not assumed, and the roof's own design decides which figure applies.

How the ventilation is made:

  • an eaves vent strip or over-fascia vent fixed along the eaves
  • soffit vents in the board under the eaves
  • tile vents or ridge vents, where the design calls for air to leave at the top

The standard behind this is BS 5250, the code on condensation in buildings, which is current but under review. Approved Document C for England cites an older 2002 edition of it, so the exact version in force depends on the document being read. A common fault is loft insulation pushed hard into the eaves so that it blocks the very gap the underlay needs. Our guide to eaves ventilation in a cold roof goes through the fix.

Air-permeable underlay and what it depends on

An air-permeable underlay lets vapour pass through itself, so a roof laid with one can manage with much less ventilation. Marley adds that when the plasterboard below is well sealed, "fortuitous ventilation at the eaves via normal eaves construction (3mm) is all that is required, provided the requirements of UKAS Third Party certification are fully met".

Read the conditions in that sentence before relying on it:

  1. The ceiling below has to be well sealed, so that damp household air does not rise into the loft in volume.
  2. The gap needed is the small gap that normal eaves construction gives, rather than a deliberate vent.
  3. The underlay has to meet the third-party certification the maker names, which means the right product used in the right way.

Any one of those failing takes the roof back towards the same risk as an HR underlay with no vent.

Cheap fixes can hide the cause. A vent added at one point of the roof does little if the eaves gap is blocked along the rest of its length, and a new underlay does nothing for a ceiling that leaks warm air. That is why we do not choose an underlay from the label on the roll alone. We look at the ceiling below, at the extractor fans, at how the loft hatch seals and at the eaves detail, and we then name the product and the ventilation in the written quote. A homeowner who is told simply that a roof is "breathable" has not been told enough to judge it.

If a replacement underlay is being fitted without taking up the tiles, say so in the quote: some systems are installed from above only when the covering is lifted. Our guide to HR or air-permeable underlay compares the choice in more detail.

Reading condensation under the roof covering

Condensation and a leak can look alike from the bedroom. The clues are in the timing. A leak follows rain; condensation follows cold, still nights and shows without any rain at all.

  • Droplets or a dark bloom on the underside of the underlay, on a cold morning.
  • Damp or furry mould on the rafters and battens, spread across the slope instead of at a single point.
  • Rusty nail tips showing through the underlay or the boards.
  • Wet insulation around the eaves where air cannot move.
  • A musty smell in the loft after a run of cold nights.

Several household habits feed the damp, and none of them shows on the roof itself. Drying washing indoors, a bathroom with no extractor to the outside, or a loft hatch that does not shut tight all let moist air rise. Dealing with the moisture at its source in the house is part of the answer, whatever is done to the roof.

On a survey we use a torch in the loft, and where possible we lift a few tiles to see the underside of the underlay in the area that is marked. Photographs of the loft and of the eaves are what you see afterwards. Marks that sit under a hip or valley point to that joint as the likely entry, and they are followed up on the roof.

The repair might be as small as clearing a blocked gap, or as large as relaying the felt and battens. Which it is depends on what the photographs show, and you see them before any price is agreed. If the underlay is sound and only the airflow is wrong, the sensible answer is to correct the airflow and leave the covering alone.

Insulation, spray foam and the roof void

Adding insulation changes how a roof behaves. More insulation at the ceiling makes the loft colder, which helps ventilation matter even more, and insulation pushed into the eaves can close the gap.

Foam sprayed onto the roof's underside is a separate case. The Energy Saving Trust splits spray foam into closed-cell and open-cell. It says of closed-cell: "Its main drawback is that it's not vapour permeable". Open-cell is "the more vapour permeable". On the risk of rot, it says that spraying foam to the underside "will partially seal the timber… But this risk should be much lower with an open-cell foam".

Lenders have taken an interest as well. RICS wrote in March 2023 that concern had reached specific sectors of lending, equity release among them, and its consumer guide asks you to check with your mortgage provider before any foam goes on a roof.

Where insulation is being improved with the roof work, the figures are set out in the Approved Documents. These are the roof figures for existing homes.

  • In England, AD L 2021 Table 4.2 gives 0.15 for a roof newly built into an existing home, and Table 4.3 gives a 0.35 threshold and 0.16 improved figure for a renovated one.
  • In Wales, Table 4.1 gives 0.13 for the same case, and Table 11.1 gives 0.16, not worse than 0.35.
  • The next editions take effect on 24 March 2027 in England and 4 March 2027 in Wales.

Approvals when the underlay is renewed

Replacing the underlay can mean stripping the tiles and battens, so it is re-covering for the purposes of the rules.

  • In England, the Planning Portal puts the normal exemption at "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope'" together with "Less than 50 per cent of the roof".
  • In Wales, the Welsh Government says of re-roofing that "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval", and that "the work to re-cover a roof should also include for improving the thermal insulation properties of the roof".
  • In England, a heavier replacement covering is tested at "15 per cent or more" by the Planning Portal and "more than 15%" by Approved Document A.

Building control on either side of the border, whether the council or a registered building control approver, can tell you whether the work needs an application. We check before the work starts and tell you what we find.

On order of work, the safest sequence is to survey the loft first, photograph the marks, then decide whether new underlay, new battens or just the ventilation need attention. Our guide to battens and felt renewal sets out what that stripping involves.

You get one total in writing for the agreed work, and the figure shows what it covers, scaffold included or not. Standing scaffold on the footway or road falls under section 169 of the Highways Act 1980, and we arrange the licence with our scaffolder.

Underlay and ventilation: three questions

Is HR underlay the same as breathable underlay?

No. The two are different. An HR sheet blocks vapour, so the roof needs a ventilated gap along the eaves instead. Air-permeable underlays are a different product with different conditions, and the written quote should say which one is being fitted and why it suits your loft.

Why is my loft damp when the roof does not leak?

Moist air from the house may be rising and condensing on cold timber, especially if the eaves gap is blocked by insulation. Photographs of the underside of the underlay and of the eaves show which it is, before anyone suggests replacing the covering, and they give you something to compare after any change.

Do I need a new underlay when I only replace broken tiles?

Not as a rule. Replacing a few broken tiles leaves the underlay in place. We look at the underlay through the gap, photograph its condition and tell you if it has torn or perished, so any extra work is something you agree with us in writing before it begins.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing