A first check of a tiled roof can be done with both feet on the ground. The ground is the best place for it, because from there you see the whole slope in one view, and a fault shows as a break in a pattern: a tile out of its row, a line that is no longer straight, a patch of colour that does not match its neighbours. Climbing up takes you too close to see any of that, and it puts you at risk for no gain.
Choose a dry, bright day, stand well back from each side of the house in turn, and take your time. Binoculars, or the zoom on a phone, bring a ridge or a chimney near enough to photograph. Do the same from any upstairs window that looks across a lower roof, such as an extension or a porch.
The sections below take the signs in the order we use on a survey: the skyline first, then the slopes, then the age of the covering. They name what each sign can mean, what it cannot prove from a distance, and when it is time to ask for a closer look. For the full range of work on tiled and slated roofs, see our pitched roofing page.
Start at the ridge, the verges and the chimney
The ridge is the crest of the roof, finished with capping tiles along its highest point. The verges are the sloping edges at a gable end, and the chimney stack is the brick or stone column that comes up through the slope. These are the places where the covering stops and something else begins, so they are the places where a roof shows trouble first.
From the garden, look for:
- a ridge line that dips, bows or has a gap between two capping tiles
- capping tiles that sit at different heights from their neighbours
- pale crumbs of mortar on the tiles below the ridge or the verge
- a verge where the end tiles look as though they have stepped away from the wall
- a stack with leaning or open joints, or lead flashing that has curled away from the brickwork
Marley's account of BS 5534 explains why ridge and verge fixings get close attention. Its account says the 2015 amendments meant mortar "could no longer be relied upon as the only means of securing the roof covering", and that hip and ridge tiles have to be mechanically fixed whatever mortar is used. A ridge held by mortar alone is therefore worth a closer look. Mortar is not banned, and a sound mortar bed is not a fault in itself. What matters is how the tiles are held.
Our guide to mortar falling from a verge covers the verge signs in more detail.
Tiles that have slipped, cracked or gone
On the slopes, the courses give you the pattern to read. Tiles are laid in straight rows, each row overlapping the one below, so a tile that has moved leaves a visible break. Walk the full length of the house with your eyes on one row at a time.
| From the garden | Possible cause |
|---|---|
| A tile that has dropped below its row | It has slipped, so the fixing may have failed |
| A dark gap where a tile should be | A tile is missing and the underlay is exposed |
| A tile with a line across it | A crack, which lets water through to the layer beneath |
| Pieces of tile in the gutter or on the ground | A tile has broken up on the roof |
| A tile lifted at its lower edge | It is no longer held down, and wind can lift it further |
A single slipped tile is not always an emergency, but it is a gap in the covering, and the underlay beneath is the only barrier left. Underlay is the membrane that sits beneath the battens. It is built to take a little water, not to stand in for the tiles for long.
For cost context, Which? (November 2025 survey, ex VAT) puts one to six replacement tiles at £75 to £400, and a new ridge tile at £80 to £300. Treat those as outside ranges for typical jobs, never our prices.
If you want to know why tiles slip in the first place, our guide to what makes roof tiles slip sets out the causes.
A roof line that sags, ripples or steps
A tiled roof should show a straight ridge and straight eaves, with smooth planes between them. Stand square to the house and compare the ridge against a fixed straight edge in the picture, such as the top of a neighbour's fence, a wall coping or the line of a window head. Then do the same along the eaves.
Signs worth noting:
- a ridge that droops in the middle or at one end
- a slope that looks hollow, like a shallow dish, between the ridge and the eaves
- ripples running up the slope in a regular pattern, as if the rafters beneath were showing through
- a step or kink where an old roof meets a newer extension or a repaired section
A sag may be the timber under the roof, not the covering. Rafters, purlins and trusses carry the whole load, and a dip means something below has moved or is overloaded. That is a structural question, and a closer look from inside the loft is the next step. Our guide to why a roof line sags sets out the causes in order.
A gentle curve in an older roof can be how it was built, and not a fault at all. Hand-made tiles and old timbers may not give a perfectly flat plane. The warning signs are a change over time and a sag that has appeared since you last looked, so photograph the roof from the same spot once a year and compare.
If a covering needs to be replaced with something heavier, the structure matters twice, and we check it before we price. The border rules for that are in the last section.
What the gutter and the ground below can tell you
Debris falls downhill, so the gutter and the ground under the eaves hold evidence from the roof. A short walk round the house with your eyes down can add to what you saw looking up.
- Grit at the downpipe foot is worth a look, because it can come off the tile surface or from old mortar.
- Pale lumps of mortar mean pointing, bedding or flaunching, the mortar cap around chimney pots, is breaking down somewhere above.
- Whole tile fragments point to a cracked or slipped tile that has already gone.
- Moss or stained patches on the lower courses can show where water sits.
On a wall, look for water marks below the eaves, a green stain under a joint in the gutter, or a patch of damp brickwork that dries slowly. These do not prove the roof is at fault, because a blocked or sagging gutter produces the same marks. A gutter needs a fall to drain, and Brett Martin gives "1mm for every 600mm". An overflowing gutter can mimic a roof leak.
Inside, a loft hatch gives a second view. With a torch, and stepping only on joists, look for daylight showing through the covering, damp patches on the underlay or timbers, and dark staining around the chimney. Do not go beyond the hatch if the floor is not boarded.
None of these signs gives a diagnosis. They tell you where to point the camera and which part of the roof to name when you ask for a survey. We then check the same place close up and show you the photograph of what is there.
Age: what the makers say tiles last
A covering that is old does not have to be failing, but age changes how much you should read into small faults. The lifespans below are typical ranges from named makers and writers, never promises, and they do not always agree.
| Covering | What the source says |
|---|---|
| Clay tile | Marley: the BRE set a minimum life expectancy of 60 years (clay only). HomeBuilding: 60-80 years |
| Concrete tile | Marley: "around 60 years". HomeBuilding: 40-50 years |
| Welsh slate | HomeBuilding: 100+ years |
Marley adds that 60 years is the expected life under ordinary use with sound fitting, and "not a guarantee or warranty of its longevity". It lists what can shorten that life: atmospheric conditions such as high pollution, walking on the tiles and incorrect installation. Staying off the roof is therefore a kindness to it.
So a roof within those ranges needs no alarm, but a covering near the far end of them that also shows several of the signs above is a different case. Two or three slipped tiles on a young roof can be a repair. The same faults on a covering nearing the end of its range, with loose ridge mortar and grit in the gutter, can make a re-roof the more honest answer. Which one it is gets settled after we have looked, with the photographs beside you.
If you have only just bought the house, the age of the covering is the first thing to establish, and the survey notes record it with a photograph of the tile.
When to ask for a closer look
Photograph what you see, note the date and the weather, and ask for a survey if any of these apply:
- Tiles are missing, or broken pieces are in the gutter.
- The ridge or a verge shows loose or open mortar, or a gap.
- The roof line has changed shape since you last looked.
- There are marks on a ceiling or inside the loft that match a fault outside.
Someone then goes up and checks the roof at arm's length, and the photographs from your own slopes come back to you. What follows is a single written total, and it says if VAT and scaffold are inside the figure. If the covering is sound across the slope, repair is the better buy, and a re-roof is recommended only when the evidence calls for it.
If the answer is a re-roof, the rules depend on which side of the border you are on:
- In England, the Planning Portal sets two conditions for needing no application as a rule: "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope'" affected, and "Less than 50 per cent of the roof is affected".
- In Wales, the Welsh Government writes of re-roofing: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval."
We check with building control for your side of the border before work of that size starts, either the council or a registered building control approver.
