A roof that has begun to let go raises an awkward question. Mend what has failed, or take the whole covering off and start again? Both answers can be right, and both can be wrong for the same roof on a different day. A tidy repair on a sound slope is good value. The same repair on a slope whose tiles are crumbling only buys time, and the owner pays for scaffold twice.
We would rather you decided with facts in front of you than with a sales pitch. That means looking at how many tiles are affected and where, what state the battens and underlay are in, how old the covering is and what the house is like underneath. It also means being clear that age alone is not the verdict: a sound old roof is a sound old roof.
The sections below set out the signs that favour each route, the published lifespans and costs for common coverings, the problem of matching what is already there, and the approval tests that change at the Welsh border. Our pitched roofing page covers everything else done to a tiled roof.
Reading the evidence before choosing
The decision rests on a handful of observations, and most of them can be photographed. The pattern matters more than any single fault.
| What the survey finds | Points to | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A few cracked or slipped tiles in one area | Repair | The rest of the slope is carrying on well |
| Worn ridge bedding or a loose verge | Repair | The edges can be redone without lifting the field |
| Tiles flaking or crumbling across a slope | Re-tile | Each repair breaks the next tile along |
| Rusted nails lifting tiles in lines | Re-tile | The fixings are failing across the roof |
| Torn or perished underlay under sound tiles | Re-lay | The tiles can be saved and re-fixed |
The third and fourth rows are the ones that tip a decision. When tiles fail across a whole slope, a repair of three or four of them can crack the next tile along, because that tile is pushed and stood on during the work.
Where the evidence is mixed, the report says that plainly. A roof can be repaired on one pitch and re-tiled on another, and the cost of scaffold is shared between the two jobs if they are done at once. Our guide to nail sickness on a tiled roof explains the fixing failure in the fourth row in detail.
The survey also records things that do not show in a table: whether the loft is dry and clear of staining, whether the ridge line is straight, and whether earlier repairs were made with matching tiles or with whatever was to hand.
Published lifespans, and why age is not the verdict
Published lifespans are ranges, never promises, and the sources disagree.
| Covering | Published range | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Concrete tile | Around 60 years | Marley |
| Concrete tile | 40-50 years | HomeBuilding |
| Clay tile | 60-80 years | HomeBuilding |
| Welsh slate | 100+ years | HomeBuilding |
| Reclaimed Welsh slate | 50-80 years | HomeBuilding |
Marley adds that its figure "is not a guarantee or warranty of its longevity". For clay, Marley says the BRE determined "a minimum life expectancy of 60 years", and that figure belongs to clay tiles only. SPAB writes that a well-slated roof is "likely to be more than 100 years". On a stone-tiled roof, the survey judges the condition of each stone itself.
Read these as the span in which a covering normally reaches the end of its useful life, with the actual date set by the exposure, the care taken at fixing and the maintenance since. A thirty-year-old concrete roof in good order is not due for replacement because of its age, and a younger one with failing nails may be. What decides the question is what we can photograph.
Weather, shade, a nearby tree and the pitch of the slope all alter how fast a covering ages, so two roofs of the same year can be in very different shape. That is why a survey looks past the face of the tiles. We check the underlay, the battens, the fixings and the timber below, because a covering can outlast the layers beneath it, or the other way round.
What third parties publish on cost
We do not publish prices on this page. These are third-party UK ranges, each with its source and date, and none is specific to Hereford.
- Which? (November 2025 survey, ex VAT) gives "£75-£400" for replacing one to six broken or missing standard tiles, and "£80-£300" for a new ridge tile.
- MyJobQuote puts a typical roof repair at around £650 in 2026, a figure that covers a mix of jobs.
- Checkatrade (June 2026, ex VAT, per m² up to 3 m²) gives concrete tile repairs at £90 to £120, clay at £110 to £160 and natural slate at £150 to £220, each per m².
A repair is priced by what it involves, and a per-m² rate is a guide to how the work is priced, not a figure to multiply by your roof area.
For a whole roof the published figures spread widely. Which? prices a full replacement for an average-sized three-bedroom house at "£7,000-£21,000", ex VAT. HomeBuilding says a three-bedroom semi with a 65m2 roof in plain concrete tiles may cost between £10,000 and £15,000, and that a Welsh slate roof for the same house "might reach £18,000". MyJobQuote puts the average cost of a new roof at around £5,250. The three disagree, because each looks at different jobs, and none of them is a quote for your roof.
What moves the price on the roof itself is the covering, the area, the pitch and access, the state of the battens and underlay, and whether scaffold is needed. A quote from us is one written total, issued after the visit, and it spells out what the total covers.
Matching what is already there
When part of a roof is repaired, the new tiles sit beside the old, and the join is visible for years. Clay and concrete weather differently, and an old clay tile has a colour no new tile will copy for some time. Our guide to mixing old and new roof tiles sets out what the mix looks like and how to make it read well.
There is a further point where the roof is old enough to be part of the character of the place. In the Herefordshire stone atlas, the clay from the Raglan mudstones is credited with feeding "the famous Herefordshire brick, tile and pipeworks industries", so clay plain tiles have a local pedigree. Stone roofs have one too: the same atlas lists first among its sources for roofing stone the St Maughans sandstones, with active permissions in the Golden Valley area.
On stone roofs SPAB warns that many are "changed to different stones or even to slates or fake stone slates", and advises that "Claims of unavailability or long delivery times should always be checked with the quarries". If a quote for a stone roof says matching stone cannot be had, ask how that was checked.
When the roof is re-tiled, three choices are open:
- Lay the same type of tile, new or reclaimed, so the roof keeps its look.
- Choose a different tile of similar weight and profile, where the old pattern is no longer made.
- Change to another covering, which brings the weight and approval questions in the last section.
For a house in a conservation area or a listed house, the choice is the council's as much as yours, and a call to them comes before an order.
How we present the choice
The photographs we take of your roof are the basis of the advice. Where a repair is the right answer, that is the advice you get. Where a repair would be money spent on tiles that are about to fail, we show you which tiles and explain why.
When both routes are possible, we put them side by side in the same terms, so you can compare them without translating. A fair written comparison covers these points:
- what the repair would fix and what it would leave
- what re-tiling would renew, down to underlay and battens
- how long each is expected to last, using the published ranges
- whether VAT, scaffold and the removal of waste are counted in the total
- what happens if the work uncovers something new
The last point matters on any roof. Lifting tiles can show rotten battens or a damaged rafter foot that no one could see from outside. We stop, photograph, explain and agree the extra work with you before it goes ahead, and it is added to the written total so there are no surprises.
If you ask other firms to quote, give each the same brief. A fair comparison needs the same scope, the same covering and the same list of what is included, or the lowest figure may simply be the smallest job. Our guide to warning signs on a tiled roof is a useful checklist to share.
Rules for re-tiling in England and Wales
Re-tiling is re-covering, and the approval tests change at the border.
- In England, the Planning Portal sets the line for no application normally being needed at "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope'" together with "Less than 50 per cent of the roof".
- In Wales, the Welsh Government says of re-roofing: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval."
- In England, the Planning Portal asks for approval when a different covering raises the roof's weight "by 15 per cent or more", while Approved Document A says "more than 15%".
- In Wales, the Welsh Government adds that re-covering "should also include for improving the thermal insulation properties of the roof".
On energy, England's Approved Document L (2021) Table 4.3 sets a roof threshold of 0.35 and an improved figure of 0.16, and Welsh Table 11.1 gives 0.16, not worse than 0.35 where 0.16 is not feasible. England's next edition takes effect on 24 March 2027 and Wales's on 4 March 2027.
On planning, England's Class C of the 2015 Order covers alterations to a roof, so re-covering a house falls normally within permitted development. In Wales, the 1995 Order's Class C.2(a) wants the look of the materials to "so far as practicable match" the existing house. A listed house also needs consent, under the 1990 Act in England and the 2023 Act in Wales.
A contract signed in your own home after our visit carries a 14-day right to cancel, and work can start inside that window only if you request it in writing. Building control is the council or a registered building control approver, and we check with them before work starts.
