In brief
Nail sickness is the decay of the nails that hold a tiled roof to its battens, the timber strips running across the rafters. The nails rust or wear thin, so the tiles they held start to slip, lift in a gust or drop into the gutter. The tiles themselves can be sound. A few slipped tiles can be refixed with new fixings, but slipping across a whole slope means the old nails are giving out everywhere, and then the slope is stripped and fixed again.
How the fixings fail behind the tiles
A tiled covering sits on battens, and each tile is held to them by nails, by clips, or by both, depending on the tile and the age of the roof. The nails lie under the course above, out of sight, in the damp gap between the tile and the underlay, which is the sheet laid across the rafters beneath the battens. Over decades they corrode and thin until the tile has little left to hold it.
The fault is in the nail, not the tile. A clay or concrete tile can be in good condition while the nail that held it has gone. One slipped tile tells you little until the tiles around it have been tested by hand, and the same goes for a tile that looks perfect from the garden.
BS 5534:2014+A2:2018 sets out how a tiled covering should be fixed, and Marley, the tile maker, points out that installing to BS 5534 "isn't required by law". So the state of the nails on an older roof is judged on that roof itself, with photographs, and not against a legal line.
What a sick roof looks like
Nail sickness may not announce itself with one dramatic failure. It shows as small shifts that build up, and a few of those shifts are visible from the garden or from the loft hatch without anyone climbing onto the roof, so a slow look at each slope through binoculars tells you something before a surveyor arrives.
- Tiles sitting lower than their neighbours, so a course no longer runs straight
- Gaps along a row where a tile has dropped away
- Pieces of tile, or whole tiles, on the path, the porch roof or in the gutter after wind
- Daylight showing through the covering from inside the loft, or rust-coloured streaks on the underlay
- A tile that moves when lifted gently at its tail during a survey
Our survey begins on the skyline with ridge, verge and chimney, then works down each slope, with photographs of every find so you can see which tiles are loose and which are held. We lift a sample of tiles to look at the nail itself, because the nail is the evidence and the tile is not.
Repair, or take the slope off
Where only a few tiles have slipped and the rest hold firm, new fixings and a handful of replacement tiles close the gap. Where tiles have slipped across a slope, the nails holding the others are the same age and in the same state, so patching only moves the problem a few feet along. We lay out what the photographs show, and we tell you when repair is the better buy.
A full re-cover brings the rules into play, and the rulebook changes where England ends and Wales begins:
- In England, the Planning Portal asks two questions of a re-roof: is under 25 per cent of the total building envelope affected, and under 50 per cent of the roof. Pass both and an application does not normally follow.
- In England, the same source says a covering that makes the roof 15 per cent or more heavier needs approval.
- In Wales, gov.wales opens its re-roofing page by saying Building Regulations approval will be needed in most situations, so we ask the council's building control service or a registered building control approver before starting.
A stripped slope gets fresh battens and underlay too. The guide to battens and felt renewal covers what that involves.
Tile lifespans and published repair prices
A tile outlasts its nails in plenty of cases, so treat the lifespans here as ranges for the tile and nothing more. Marley expects roof tiles to last around 60 years, while HomeBuilding gives plain concrete tiles 40 to 50 years. For clay, the BRE set a minimum life expectancy of 60 years, a figure that belongs to clay alone.
Which? surveyed Trusted Traders in November 2025 and puts a job of one to six tiles at £75 to £400, excluding VAT. Read that as a UK-wide range rather than a Herefordshire price.
Separately, Checkatrade's June 2026 repair guide gives concrete tile repairs at £90 to £120 per m² and clay at £110 to £160 per m², for patches up to 3 m² and excluding VAT.
What you receive from us is a written price covering everything once we have surveyed, with scaffold and waste clearance inside it. The pitched roofing page sets out the wider work, and the answer on what makes roof tiles slip looks at the other reasons a tile loosens.
