01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Underlay types

HR or breathable underlay: what is the difference?

HR underlay holds vapour back, and a breathable underlay lets it pass. That single difference decides how much air the roof space must be given.

In brief

HR stands for high resistance. The HR kind is not vapour-permeable, so damp in the loft has to leave by moving air. A breathable, air-permeable underlay lets vapour pass and, over a sealed ceiling, can manage on far less ventilation at the eaves. Marley asks for 25mm or 10mm with HR on a cold roof, and 3mm for the air-permeable type under set conditions. We identify yours before we advise.

What HR means and why it holds vapour back

Under the battens and tiles, a sheet of underlay runs across the rafters. It is a second line of defence, because a tile roof is not watertight and wind can push rain or fine snow under the laps. Anything that gets past the tiles runs down the underlay and out at the eaves into the gutter.

The letters HR mean high resistance, and the resistance in question is to water vapour. Cooking, washing and breathing put moisture into the air of a house, and warm air carries it upwards. An HR underlay stops that vapour at the roof, so the loft has to clear it another way, by air that enters low and leaves high. That is why Marley's guidance for HR underlay on a cold roof asks for a real opening along the eaves.

Whatever the underlay, the aim of a survey is to see what is actually there. Our page on what roof underlay does covers the job it was laid to do, and the pages beside it in this series show how an underlay is renewed.

HR and breathable underlay side by side

The word breathable describes an underlay that lets vapour through. An HR underlay does not. Marley's cold roof guidance sets out what each type asks of the eaves, and the table puts the two in one place.

HR and air-permeable underlay compared
QuestionHR underlayAir-permeable underlay
Passes vapourNoYes
Eaves opening, 15° or less25mm3mm, on conditions
Eaves opening, over 15°10mm3mm, on conditions
What it depends onThe gap staying clearA sealed ceiling and certification

The 3mm in the right-hand column is the air that reaches the loft through ordinary eaves construction. Marley says it is all that is required when the certification conditions are satisfied completely, and that is not something a photograph can show. Marley calls this type LR, for low resistance. The breathable label alone does not mean a roof needs no gap at the eaves, and in either case the gap has to be kept clear, since insulation pushed into it ends the airflow that the underlay depends on. See eaves ventilation for a cold roof for the figures in full.

Finding out which underlay is on your roof

A homeowner may not know which underlay lies beneath the tiles, and a roof that has been re-covered more than once can carry a mix of old and new. The loft is the place to look, on a dry day and from the hatch or a safe board laid across the joists.

When we survey, we check and photograph:

  • any maker's name or printing on the underside of the underlay
  • the underlay at the eaves, for tears, laps and how it meets the gutter
  • marks of damp or dark staining on the timber near the eaves
  • the ceiling below, for gaps round pipes, cables and the hatch

A sealed ceiling is half of the answer for an air-permeable underlay, since warm air leaking up from the house loads the loft with moisture. If we cannot tell which underlay you have, we treat the roof as the more cautious case until we can, and that means leaving the eaves gap clear. Any change to the underlay is priced inside one written total, together with the battens and any tiles that have to be relaid. Photographs from before and after put the roof as found and the roof as left on record.

Changing the underlay: rules in both countries

Underlay is most easily renewed when a slope is stripped and re-laid, because the battens and tiles are already off the roof. It may not be worth lifting sound tiles for the underlay alone. Our page on batten and felt renewal sets out the work and what comes with it.

A re-roof meets different approval tests in the two countries:

  • In England, two Planning Portal tests apply to a re-roof: under 50 per cent of the roof, and under 25 per cent of the building envelope.
  • In Wales, gov.wales expects Building Regulations approval to be needed for re-roofing in most situations, and asks for the insulation to be improved when a roof is re-covered.

Better insulation at ceiling level can press against the eaves gap, so the airflow is checked whenever a loft is insulated. We photograph the battens and underlay as they are uncovered, so you see the state of the roof beneath before it is closed up again. If the covering is also being changed, the weight of the new tile matters, and our pitched roofing hub lists the pages that cover the roof above the loft, from battens to ridges.

Related questions

Is breathable underlay the same as HR underlay?

No. An HR underlay has high resistance to vapour and is not vapour-permeable. A breathable underlay is one that lets vapour pass. Because the two behave differently in the loft, they ask different things of the eaves ventilation, and we identify yours before giving any advice on the roof.

Can I check the underlay myself?

Standing on the hatch ladder with a torch, you may see printing on the underside of the underlay or the maker's name. Photograph it, and photograph any damp patches near the eaves. Please stay off the ceiling and on a board across the joists. Send us the pictures and we will tell you what they show.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing