01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Cracked tiles

Can one cracked tile be swapped out?

A single cracked tile can come out and a new one go in without touching the rest of the course, if a match exists and its neighbours are sound.

In brief

Yes, where that one tile is the only fault. We raise the tiles above it, slide the cracked tile off its batten (the timber strip each tile hangs from), fit a matching tile and settle the neighbours back down. The new tile has to match in size, profile and colour. If several tiles in one patch have cracked, the cause is wider than one tile, and we photograph the slope to show you what is happening.

Taking one tile out and bedding a new one

A roof tile hangs from a batten by small lugs on its back, called nibs. Each tile overlaps the one below and tucks under the one above, so a cracked tile is held in place by its neighbours. To free it, we raise the tiles above with a tile lifter, a flat tool that needs only gentle pressure, and slide the broken tile out. Loose pieces are cleared from the course below so none is left sitting under the new tile.

The replacement goes in by the same route and drops onto the batten so its nibs engage. Marley says installing to BS 5534 isn't required by law, but a tile resting on its own weight can lift in a gust. For that reason the replacement is fixed the way its neighbours are held, by nail, clip or both, and is never left loose.

Once it is in, we check and photograph:

  • whether the crack ran right through the tile or was a hairline
  • the edges of the tiles either side, for chips from the lifting
  • the batten underneath, for splits or rot
  • the underlay below, for tears or gaps

Those photographs go to you, so you can see the new tile sitting in its course and the sound ones around it.

Finding a spare that matches your roof

The replacement has to lie flat in its course, carry rain away as the old one did and look right from the lane. A tile that is nearly right can rock, stand proud or leave a gap, so the match is made on several points.

Four things a spare tile has to match
FeatureReason
Length, width and thicknessKeeps the lap and lets the tile lie flat
ProfilePlain, pantile and interlocking tiles do not swap
Clay or concreteThe two weather differently and do not mix
Colour and ageNew tiles look brighter than weathered ones

Each profile also has its own minimum pitch. Marley lists its clay tiles from 15 degrees for the Lincoln pantile to 40 degrees for the Canterbury, so a tile of another profile can be wrong for the slope it is meant to fill.

Herefordshire's older stone roofs use local sandstone tilestones. SPAB advises asking the quarries themselves before accepting that a stone is out of stock or slow to arrive, so for stone we ring a quarry first. A related page covers how old and new tiles sit together.

When the cracked tile is a warning

One crack can be a knock from a ladder or a falling branch. A line of cracks, or a tile that split with no cause you can see, tells a different story. Frost can split a tile that has soaked up water, and a tile can also break where it has lost its nail and shifted. Our page on nail sickness in a tiled roof explains that second case.

Age matters too. Marley says the BRE set a minimum life expectancy of 60 years, but only for clay tiles. For concrete, Marley says around 60 years while HomeBuilding gives 40 to 50 years for plain and Double Roman tiles. These are typical ranges, not promises.

Third-party prices give a feel for the scale of the job:

  • For a small repair of up to six tiles, Which? gives £75 to £400 in its November 2025 survey, excluding VAT.
  • Checkatrade (June 2026, excluding VAT) prices repairs per m², up to 3 m²: concrete £90 to £120, clay £110 to £160.

Once we have seen your own roof, the price reaches you in writing as a single figure for the whole job.

Is approval needed for a tile swap?

Swapping a tile is a repair, not a re-roof, and the rules go lightly on small repairs. The two countries set the test in different words:

  • For England, the Planning Portal sets two tests for re-roofing, covering under 25 per cent of the building envelope and under 50 per cent of the roof. A few tiles sit far inside both.
  • For Wales, the Welsh Government's roof guidance puts its line at 25 per cent of a pitched or flat roof's area, and a repair or re-cover below that does not normally call for an application.

A listed house is another matter, since a repair that changes how the roof looks may need consent. In England that consent comes under the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990; in Wales the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 governs it. Put the question to the council before touching a listed roof.

The pitched roofing hub covers a whole slope, and our guide to re-tiling or repairing sets out how to choose between the two.

Related questions

Will the new tile stand out from the old ones?

At first it can, because a new tile is brighter than one that has weathered for years. We match the size, profile and colour as closely as we can, and the difference softens as the new tile weathers. A reclaimed tile can blend in better where one can be found to suit your roof.

Can I swap a cracked tile myself?

Stepping on tiles can crack more of them, and a fall from a roof can cause serious injury. Our page on whether it is safe to walk on roof tiles explains the risk. Photograph the crack from the ground and send it to us, and we will do the climbing.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing