In brief
Because the stone was local. The county's stone atlas reports sandstone as the common material for the heavy external stacks of timber-framed houses, and separate sandstone beds, the St Maughans above all, supplied its stone roof tiles. A timber house also needs a flue that will not burn, so the stack became the one part built in masonry. A repair to such a stack matches that stone and its mortar.
The rock under the county
Herefordshire's stone atlas, a 2012 study hosted by Herefordshire Council, ties the county's old buildings to the ground they stand on. It names the St Maughans Formation sandstones as the main source of local roofing stone, which only a small group of quarries still work, and it records Downton Castle Sandstone as a rock cut for both walling and roofing.
Those two uses describe how a stone behaves. A freestone cuts cleanly in any direction, which suits the squared blocks of a stack. A tilestone splits into thin sheets, which suits a roof. Which bed a given stack came from is not recorded, so the stone in a stack and the stone on the roof beside it are each identified at the survey.
The atlas adds a note on clay. The Raglan mudstones fed brickmaking, tilemaking and pipeworks in the county, so brick and stone both belong to Herefordshire, and a stack in either is built of local material. That is why each repair starts with identifying what your stack is made of, before anyone mixes mortar or orders a single unit.
Why a timber house wants a masonry stack
The atlas treats the timber-framed house as the county's regional style, with a Black and White Village Trail laid out in the north-west. An oak frame carries the walls and floors of such a house, and an open fire needs a flue that will not burn. So the one part built in masonry is the stack, standing outside or beside the frame.
The same source notes that the frame's lowest beam rests on a low base of sandstone or siltstone, and it gives sandstone as the common material for the large outside stacks. The result is a broad, solid column rising from the side of the house instead of the middle of it, which is a shape you can recognise from the lane.
That shape does not tell you what any one house has on its roof, and no count of stone, brick or tiled stacks is published. Our survey tells you what your own stack is made of. The repair detail for those frames sits in stone stacks on black-and-white houses, where the junction between frame, plinth and stack is covered in full.
What stone means for repair
A stone stack ages differently from a brick one. The stone takes in water in its own way, the joints are wide, and the original mortar was lime. Repairs follow from that.
- Repointing uses a mortar that suits the stone and does not trap moisture against it, as set out in lime or cement mortar on a chimney.
- Loose or missing stones are reset in their own courses, or replaced with stone from the same family.
- Flaunching, pots and flashing are renewed to suit the stack head.
- Where stone has to be bought in, the quarry is asked what it can supply and when.
Each job begins at the top. We photograph the stone, the joints, the pots and the lead from roof level, so the pictures record the mortar and the stone as they stand before a price is set. A brick patch on a stone stack, or a hard grey joint beside soft golden stone, stays visible from the lane for the life of the stack, so we avoid both.
Matching the repair to how the stack was built is the point of the survey, and one written total follows it. If the stack is a listed feature, the council hears about the proposed mortar, stone and method first, and the work waits for its reply.
Listed stacks, conservation areas and the English rules
Old stone stacks belong to old houses, and an old house may be listed. In England, section 7 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 asks for consent when a listed building's character is at stake. Herefordshire has 64 conservation areas, and the council's list shows whether your road is in one. An Article 4 direction can add controls, and Herefordshire Council can tell you whether one covers your address.
In England, Class C of the permitted development order leaves out the installation, alteration or replacement of a chimney (C.1(d)(i)). A repair that keeps the stack as it stands is separate from that, while a complete rebuild could be treated as a replacement, which whether rebuilding a stack needs planning works through.
The Planning Portal also tells owners that approval under the Building Regulations always applies to taking out a chimney breast. Removing a breast is not the same job as repairing a stack, and for a house in Herefordshire the council's building control team is where the question goes. The main chimney repairs service covers the rest of the work.
