01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Lime or cement

Lime or cement mortar for a chimney?

The mortar should suit the masonry it joins, so an old sandstone stack points towards lime, and a look at the existing joints settles which mix goes in.

In brief

It depends on what the stack is built from and what is already in its joints. Soft old stone or brick is generally repointed in lime-based mortar, because a mortar harder than the masonry can leave the stone or brick to take the wear. A hard modern brick stack laid in cement can take a cement-based mix. We look at the joints first, then match the mortar. On a listed house, consent may be needed before any repointing alters the look of the stack.

Why the mortar matters at the top of a stack

A chimney stack rises clear of the ridge or slope, and every face of it is exposed. Rain, wind and frost reach it from all directions, with no neighbouring roof to shelter it. Its joints are where wear appears first, which is why the mix chosen for them matters so much to the years that follow.

Our approach is that the joint should be the part that gives, not the masonry. Mortar is cheap to renew and the stone or brick is not. If the mortar is harder than the masonry around it, the stack can still lose material, and the damage then shows in the face of the stone or brick, not in the joint.

Masonry and the mortar we would consider for it
What the stack is built fromMortar we would consider
Old sandstoneLime-based, matched to the existing joints
Soft, old brickLime-based, with joints finished to suit
Hard modern brick laid in cementA cement-based mix of similar strength
Mixed or repaired beforeDecided after testing and looking

Our page on repointing a chimney stack shows how a stack is worked.

Reading what is already in the joints

A stack may have been repointed already, and the last repair is not always the right one to copy. Before anything is chosen, we look at the joints from a ladder or scaffold and note what we find:

  • the colour and grain of the mortar, and whether the sand shows
  • whether the joints stand proud of the face or sit back from it
  • brick or stone edges that have crumbled next to hard, grey joints
  • patches of repair that differ in colour from the original work
  • how deep the joints have worn, and whether they can be raked out safely

Crumbling at the edges of the masonry beside sound, hard joints is the clearest warning. It suggests the joint is harder than the unit it holds, and a fresh cement joint would repeat the problem.

We photograph the stack on each face so each face can be compared before and after. A small test area, raked out and repointed, shows how the new mortar will look when it dries, before the whole stack is worked. Fresh mortar looks paler than weathered mortar, and the match improves over the following months.

Stone, listing and the two sets of rules

In the words of the Herefordshire building stone atlas, the external stacks on the county's black-and-white buildings are "commonly of local sandstone". Repointing one of them in the wrong mix changes its look from the lane. SPAB advises that claims of unavailability "should always be checked with the quarries" before a different stone is accepted.

Consent for a listed stack depends on the nation:

  • In England, LBCA 1990 section 7 means listed building consent is needed for work affecting the character of a listed building.
  • In Wales, section 88 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 says works must be authorised, with section 89 providing the consent.

Whether repointing in a given mortar affects the character is for the council to judge, so put the question to it first. In a conservation area, check whether an Article 4 direction applies with your council. The page on stone stacks on black-and-white houses goes through the local stone. Photographs of the joints as they stand now, taken before any work, make that conversation with the council simpler, because they show what is there today.

Mortar on the roof, flashings and what a repoint costs

Mortar also appears further down the roof. Marley says installing to BS 5534 "isn't required by law", and that since the 2015 amendments mortar "could no longer be relied upon as the only means of securing the roof covering". Mortar at ridges and verges is therefore not banned; it just cannot be the only fixing. On a chimney, the equivalent point is that mortar joints keep the masonry in line while the lead keeps the water out.

Lead flashings can be let into the stack's joints. Repointing and flashing can happen together for that reason, since a joint raked out for lead is a joint that needs refilling. MyJobQuote (page dated 22/09/26) says lead flashing correctly installed "can last for over 80 years".

A price for repointing comes after a survey, because the height of the stack, the condition of the joints and the access all change the work. You receive one written total. The chimney repairs hub brings together the other parts of a stack, and the page on when a chimney needs repointing covers the signs.

Related questions

Can cement repointing on an old stack be reversed later?

It can, but removing hard cement joints risks chipping the stone or brick edges beside them. That is a reason to check the existing mortar before the first repoint, so the right mix goes in at the first attempt. A small test area on the stack shows the result before the whole stack is done, and you can see it in a photograph.

Will new joints look different from the old ones?

At first, yes. Fresh mortar is paler than weathered mortar and may stand out against old masonry. We match the sand and colour to the existing joints and finish them to suit, and the match improves as the mortar weathers over the months that follow.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing