In brief
It can, and the council decides. In England, paragraph C.1(d) of Class C in the 2015 Order excludes altering or replacing a chimney. In Wales, C.1(c)(i) of the 1995 Order does the same. A rebuild therefore falls outside the permitted development that most roof work relies on, though that does not mean every rebuild needs permission. Listed status adds a separate consent, and an Article 4 direction can change things, so send the council photographs and a description first.
How each country's Order treats a chimney
Permitted development is planning permission that an Order grants in advance, so that no application is made. For work to the roof of a house it is Class C, "Any other alteration to the roof of a dwellinghouse". Each country attaches limits to that class, and a chimney appears in both lists of limits.
| Country | Order and paragraph | Effect on a chimney |
|---|---|---|
| England | GPDO 2015, C.1(d)(i) | Installing, altering or replacing a chimney takes the work out of the class |
| Wales | GPDO 1995 as amended for Wales, C.1(c)(i) | The same exclusion applies to a chimney |
So both Orders give one starting point: Class C is the wrong route for rebuilding a stack.
The border matters for what follows. Welsh Class C also bars removing a chimney where the house stands on article 1(5) land, or in a designated World Heritage area. The Welsh Order uses article 1(5) land as its label for conservation areas, National Parks and AONBs, the last now being styled National Landscapes.
Repair, rebuild and the question the council answers
A great deal of chimney work is plainly repair. Repointing joints, rebedding a pot and renewing a flashing leave the stack as it was. A rebuild is different, because courses of brick or stone come down and go up again, and neither Order says in terms where repair ends and replacement begins. That judgement is the council's.
The authority to ask is the one for your address. For a Hereford address that is Herefordshire Council, and across the border it is the Welsh council for the area. Inside Bannau Brycheiniog National Park, the National Park Authority is the planning authority. Within the two National Landscapes of Malvern Hills and Wye Valley, planning decisions rest with the councils themselves, not with the landscape teams.
When you write, tell the council:
- how tall the stack is, where it stands and what it is built from
- what, if anything, will look different once it is rebuilt
- that you can supply pictures taken at roof level and inside the loft
A reply in writing settles the point for good. On a survey we take those pictures ourselves, so that your description matches what is actually standing on the roof, course by course.
Listed houses, conservation areas and Article 4
Some houses face more than the Order. Three situations come up around a chimney:
- A listed house. In England, LBCA 1990 section 7 needs consent for work that alters what makes the building special. In Wales, the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 section 88 requires such works to be authorised, and section 89 provides for listed building consent; both have applied since 4 November 2024.
- A conservation area. In England it is article 2(3) land, which takes dormers out of Class B but says nothing about chimneys. In Wales it is article 1(5) land, which carries the extra bar on removal.
- An Article 4 direction. GOV.UK describes this as a direction that lets a council withdraw named permitted development rights over a defined area. The Welsh Government notes they turn up most often in conservation areas.
A flat in England has no householder rights at all, because article 2 of the 2015 Order defines a dwellinghouse as something other than a building of flats.
Herefordshire Council has no Article 4 list on its site, so for a Herefordshire address the council has to be asked directly.
Stone matching, shared stacks and Building Regulations
Planning is only one strand of a rebuild. The same stack may need several other points settled before work begins.
The first is the stone. The county's stone atlas describes the big outside stacks on timber-framed houses as "commonly of local sandstone", and a rebuild in some other stone would stand out from the lane. SPAB advises that claims of unavailability "should always be checked with the quarries". Our page on stone stacks on black-and-white houses goes through this.
The second is a shared stack. Where it serves next door, the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 reaches both England and Wales. The building owner serves notice, and surveyors come into it only after a dispute, which is deemed to exist after 14 days without a reply.
The third is Building Regulations. Ask your council's building control service, or a registered building control approver, whether the rebuild needs an application. The chimney repairs hub is the place to start for other chimney questions, and rebuilding a chimney above the roof follows the work itself.
