In brief
Damp is the cause. Water gets into the brick through failed mortar, a cracked top or a leaking flashing, then freezes and expands, and the face flakes away. That flaking is called spalling. Flue gases and condensation inside a stack can add to it from within. The remedy is to stop the water first, then cut out the damaged bricks and replace them, or rebuild if the stack has lost its strength.
How damp breaks a brick
A brick is hard but not sealed. It takes in water through its pores, and the water dries out again in good weather. The stack rises clear of the slope, taking weather on every face with no wall behind it, and it stays wet for longer than the walls below. When the air turns cold, water inside a brick freezes, expands and pushes. Repeat that enough times and the outer skin lets go in flakes or sheets. That is spalling.
Water gets in through faults at the top of the house:
- joints with the mortar washed out, which let rain reach the brick faces
- cracked flaunching and pots, which let rain down into the head of the stack
- lead flashing that has lifted, which lets water run behind the stack at the roof joint
- a cap or cowl missing from an unused flue
Two of these have pages of their own, covering cracked flaunching and when a chimney needs repointing. A stack that has begun to crumble has been taking in water for some time, which is why the survey looks for the original entry point and not only for the damage.
The brick, the mortar and the flue gases
Not every brick ages the same way. Herefordshire's clay has a long history in brickmaking: the county's stone atlas, published with Herefordshire Council as host, records that the Raglan mudstones supplied clay to "the famous Herefordshire brick, tile and pipeworks industries", and lists some 250 brickworks among the county's recorded sites. A soft-fired brick will spall sooner than a hard-fired one standing in the same weather.
The mortar matters just as much. A mortar harder than the brick sends water out through the brick instead of the joint, which is why the choice of mix has a page of its own: lime or cement mortar on a chimney.
Inside the stack, a flue that carried smoke can leave deposits that attract moisture. Condensation from a boiler or stove flue can attack the lining and the joints from within. That is a fault in the flue and its lining, not in the roof, and it is one reason the survey looks at the inside of a stack as well as the outside before any repair is priced.
Spalling is easy to spot once you know it. Look for pitted or scaled brick faces, small curved flakes of clay in the gutter or on the slope below, and a fine sandy powder on the ledges.
Reading the damage on the stack
The depth of the damage decides the repair. From roof level we look at each face, test the brick with a tool, and sort what we find into the four cases below. Where one brick in a course has gone and the rest are sound, the repair stays small.
| What we see | What it means | Repair |
|---|---|---|
| Faint surface flaking | Early spalling | Stop the water, then repoint |
| Bricks with the face gone | Frost damage through the unit | Cut out and replace those bricks |
| Soft, sandy brick | Unit has lost its strength | Replace, or rebuild that part |
| Leaning or opened stack | Structure is moving | Rebuild from a sound course |
Replacement bricks are matched for size, colour and texture, because a stack patched with the wrong brick looks wrong from the lane. We hold a damaged brick against the originals in daylight before we order, and we photograph the match once it is bedded. A stack that is leaning is another subject, and the sound course it is rebuilt from is chosen by looking at the joints and the bricks together, not by guessing.
Rebuilding, consent and the rules
When too many bricks have gone, the stack is taken down to a sound course and rebuilt. A rebuild could be treated as replacing the chimney. In England, Class C leaves out the installation, alteration or replacement of a chimney (C.1(d)(i)), and in Wales the same exclusion is C.1(c)(i). Ask the council about your address, and see whether rebuilding a stack needs planning.
A listed house is protected as well. In England, that is section 7 of the 1990 Act, and in Wales it is section 88 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023. Ask whether an Article 4 direction applies to your road, too.
Where the stack rises from a wall you share, the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 reaches both countries, and the neighbour may need notice before work begins.
After the survey, one written total reaches you with a photograph of each damaged face beside it. Bricks cut out leave with us, and the slopes are swept of dust. Other stack jobs sit under chimney repairs.
