01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Chimney removal

Taking a chimney down in Hereford: removal, capping and the rules

Taking a chimney down can mean capping it, removing the stack above the roof, or taking out the breast in the rooms. Each has its own rules, and the order matters.

Horizon Roofing Hereford 9 min read

People say they want a chimney taken down and mean one of three quite different jobs. Some want the pots capped and the stack left alone. Some want the stack above the roof removed and the slope made good. Some want the chimney breast out of the living room, with the floor space it takes up. The first is a roofing job, the second is a roofing job with a structural side, and the third is mostly a structural job with a roofing end.

This post separates the three, then sets out the rules in the order they come up: planning, Building Regulations, the neighbour's side of a shared wall, and the finish at the roof. It follows the English rules, which apply in Herefordshire and in the English counties around it. For a house across the border, our answer on removing a chimney in Wales sets out what changes.

The chimney work itself belongs to our chimney repairs service.

Three jobs that all get called taking it down

The words matter, because the rules and the work differ. A chimney is made of parts, and a quote should name which parts come away.

  • Capping: the pots come off and the head of the stack is closed over with a cap or a slab. The stack stays standing, and rain is kept out of the flue.
  • Removing the stack above the roof: the brickwork or stone above the slope is taken down, and the roof is made good where it stood.
  • Removing the breast: the masonry that projects into a room, with the flues in it, comes out, and whatever sat on it above is carried in a new way.
  • Taking out the lot: the stack above the roof, the breast and the flue run between them, floor by floor.

A stack is the part you see from the road; the breast is the part you see from the sofa. The chimney in between runs through the loft and the bedrooms, and on a semi or a terrace it can lean on the wall shared with next door. Which parts you want gone sets which of the sections below apply to you.

We start with the stack because it is on the skyline, where we begin every survey, and because what is above the roof tells us a good deal about how the rest was built. A stack that has been repaired before, with a different brick on top of the original, tells us the house has already had one conversation about its chimney.

Planning: where a chimney comes into the question

In England, it is Class C of the General Permitted Development Order 2015 that deals with re-roofing, which covers "Any other alteration to the roof of a dwellinghouse". The class has exclusions, and one of them is aimed at chimneys. Under C.1(d), development is not permitted if it "would consist of or include" the installation, alteration or replacement of a chimney, flue or soil and vent pipe.

Whether lowering a stack amounts to an alteration in that sense is for the planning team to say. Put the question to Herefordshire Council, or to the council for your own address, before work starts, and ask for the answer in writing so that it can sit with the quote.

The checks that apply to every house:

  • Listed house: consent applies to works that change its character, under the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 s7, and a stack can be part of that character.
  • Conservation area: Herefordshire Council says there are 64 of them in the county, so ask the planning team whether the change needs permission.
  • Article 4 direction: a direction can remove permitted development rights over a marked-out area, so find out whether one reaches your street.
  • Flat: the Order's definition of a dwellinghouse leaves out flats, so householder rights do not apply to one.

Nothing here means the survey has to wait. We can photograph the stack and write down its condition while the planning question is with the council, and the photographs help the planners as much as the roofer.

Building Regulations: breasts always need approval

The Planning Portal is blunt about breasts: approval "will always apply" to taking one out, since a breast is "part of the building's structure". The word "always" is the Portal's own. It holds whatever the size of the breast, and whether or not the chimney is in use.

The reason sits in the second half of that sentence. A breast is not a boxed-in pipe; it is a piece of wall, and the floors, the roof timbers and any stack above it may rest on it. Once it comes out, something else has to carry that weight. Building control looks at the support, at the openings left behind in the floors and the ceilings, and at the way the work is finished. The inspections happen while the structure is still open to view, which is why the date of the work is agreed with them and not just with us.

In England, building control is done by the council or by a registered building control approver, and you choose which. Herefordshire Council Building Control can be reached on 01432 261938 and at bce@herefordshire.gov.uk. Questions about a shared wall go to a party wall surveyor, not building control, so the two enquiries are separate.

Taking only the stack above the roof, and leaving the breast, is a lighter job, but it still alters the building. Ask building control whether your job needs an application, keep the reply with the quote, and show it to us at the survey so that the roof work is priced on the right footing.

A shared chimney and the party wall

On a semi or a terrace, the breast can stand against the wall dividing two houses, and the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 speaks to it twice. Section 2(2)(g) lets the building owner cut away "any projecting chimney breast, jamb or flue" from a party wall, external wall or boundary wall. Section 3(2)(a) requires the notice to be served at least 2 months before the proposed work.

These are the points people mix up:

  • The building owner sends the notice; neither the roofer nor the neighbour does.
  • The neighbour may agree in writing, and section 3(3)(a) leaves the owner free to proceed on that written agreement.
  • Silence does not count as agreement. GOV.UK puts it as "You cannot assume that no response means they agree to the works."
  • Should the neighbour object, or stay silent for a fortnight, the Act treats that as a dispute, and surveyors are appointed (sections 5 and 10).

The notice has nothing to do with building control. It is a separate duty, and the two run side by side, so each body gets its own question. Our guide to chimneys on a party wall goes through who needs to be told and what the notice contains.

Get the date of the notice into the plan early. The two months start on the day it is served, so the order of work below is built round it, and a start date should never be promised before the notice has gone out.

What happens at the roof afterwards

Once the stack is down, the roof has a gap in it, and the finish decides whether it leaks. Where a stack stood on a slope, the covering has to be rebuilt round the gap: battens, underlay and tiles or slates matched to the rest. The lead flashing that sealed the stack to the slope comes away with it, so the edges of the new section need weathering of their own.

Where the stack straddled a ridge, the ridge line has to be completed. On a gable it may meet a verge. Both are details we check from the skyline, because the junction of stack, ridge and covering is where the repair would show.

When only the pots come off and the stack is capped, the work is smaller, but the cap still has to shed water and the flashings round the stack still need to be sound. If a capped stack still leaks round its base, the lead is the first place to look, and the cap is the second.

Photographs matter here, because the work is hidden once it is finished. We photograph the stack before work, the junction with the roof during the work and the finished slope, and the pictures are yours to keep. They are also what a surveyor or buyer will want to see later, when the house changes hands and somebody asks what became of the chimney.

The order of work when the breast is involved

Because several bodies are involved, the sequence matters more than the speed. This is the order we follow.

  1. Survey: the stack is examined from the roof and the breast from inside the rooms, and both are photographed.
  2. Rules: planning and listing are checked with the council, and building control is asked about the support.
  3. Neighbour: with a shared wall, the party wall notice is served by the building owner, so the neighbour gets at least 2 months before the first day of work.
  4. Scaffold: any scaffold reaching over the road or footway requires a licence under the Highways Act 1980 s169, and we arrange the licence with our scaffolder. Herefordshire Council's fee is £167, good for a maximum period of 1 month, and it wants 10 days' notice at the least.
  5. Work: the stack comes down, the support goes in and the roof is made good.
  6. Sign-off: the building control body inspects, and you receive photographs of the finished roof.

The written total arrives as one figure, fixed after the survey and the checks are done, because the checks can change the job. A quote written before building control has looked at the support may have to be revised, and we would rather say so at the start than after the scaffold is up. If the council asks for a structural calculation or a drawing, that is gathered before the price is fixed.

The cost side is covered in our post on chimney repair cost in Hereford, with the published ranges named and dated.

Questions before a chimney comes down

Do I need Building Regulations approval to remove only the chimney breast?

Yes. The Planning Portal says Building Regulations approval is needed every time a breast comes out, because the breast is structure. Ask the council's building control team or a registered building control approver, and keep their written answer with the quote for the job in case it is needed later.

Can I cap a chimney and leave the stack standing?

Capping is a smaller job than removal, but the cap has to shed water and the lead round the base must be sound. Should the house be listed, or inside a conservation area, ask the council whether the change needs consent before the pots come off.

How far ahead must a neighbour be told about a shared breast?

Under the Party Wall etc. Act 1996, the building owner must serve the notice for cutting into a party wall, and the gap between service and start is at least two months. The neighbour can agree in writing. If there is an objection, or no reply within 14 days, surveyors are appointed.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing