Callout 1 of 3
Welsh slate over red sandstone at Llandogo
The survey starts on the slope, because that is where rain and wind arrive first. Cadw's listing for the Church of St Oudoceus, Grade II* (record 18575, listed on 18 July 1997), describes it as "Built of snecked red sandstone with Bath stone dressings under a Welsh slate roof with stone parapets and crucifix finials". Slate laid well keeps a roof going for decades, and the published figures are ranges rather than promises. HomeBuilding lists new Welsh slate at "100+ years", Spanish slate at "75-100 years" and reclaimed Welsh slate at "50-80 years". SPAB puts a well-slated roof at "likely to be more than 100 years".
A slate hangs by a nail or two through its head, and once a nail has corroded the slate slips. We lift the courses along the lowest edge and look for slates that have slipped, cracked or begun to flake. SPAB observes that Welsh slate and stone roofs "are predominantly double-lapped", which is why we also measure the headlap: how far each slate reaches over the slate two courses below it. Pitch comes into it as well. Cupa, the slate maker, says that BS 5534:2014+A2:2018 "also indicates that the minimum roof pitch for natural slate is 20 degrees in the case of a project situated in an area with moderate exposure and with a slate 500mm long and a 115mm overlap". Cupa also rules out hook fixings below 25 degrees.
Welsh rules govern any re-roofing in Llandogo. The Welsh Government's page on re-roofing states: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval." On its roof page the Welsh Government draws a line at "less than 25 per cent of the area of a pitch or flat roof", below which an application is not normally needed. Swapping slate for tiles is its own example of a change of material where approval is likely, since weight, fire performance and energy use all have to be looked at. Monmouthshire County Council runs its own building control team from County Hall in Usk, and we contact it before a re-cover begins.
Every slipped slate, rusted fixing and open lap goes into the photographs, so you see the fault before any price is set. Our slate roofing page covers re-slating, and roof repairs covers the smaller jobs that do not need a re-cover.
Checked on a Llandogo slate slope
- Slipped, cracked or flaking slates
- The nail or hook at each slate head
- Headlap on the lowest courses
- Pitch against the fixing method
- Bedding along the ridge and hips
A slate that has slipped shows you where its nail gave out.















