Callout 1 of 3
Roof lights and dormers inside a National Landscape
Trellech lies within the Wye Valley National Landscape, the newer name for what was called an AONB. The designation describes the land; it does not decide applications. Planning decisions for a Trellech address belong to Monmouthshire County Council. What the designation does change is the short list of things a householder can do without applying, and roof work is where that shows up first.
In Wales this kind of land is called article 1(5) land, and the Welsh householder rules treat it strictly. There, a new rooflight falls outside permitted development, and a dormer does too. Both need planning permission, whichever slope they face. Our planning guide for roof windows goes through the rules and the reasoning. A like-for-like re-cover raises fewer questions, and the Welsh Government's summary explains why: "the appearance of the materials used must, as far as possible, match the appearance of those used on your existing roof". That wording leaves room for repair and like-for-like work, and it is why a switch of material goes to the council first.
Planning is half the story. The Welsh Government says "Approval under the Building Regulations will generally be needed for the installation of a new rooflight", and it expects the glazing to perform. Under Welsh Approved Document L, a roof window is held to WER Band B or 1.4 W/m²K, while a rooflight is held to 2.2. Once a window is in, we look at the flashing round its frame, the condition of the seal and the lining inside the opening, which is where a failing window shows itself first.
A dormer or roof window can go with a loft conversion, and Welsh Approved Document B applies to that. In paragraph 3.6, Welsh Approved Document B says "The dwellinghouse may either have a protected stairway as described in (a) below, or the top floor can be separated and given its own alternative escape route as described in (b)." Paragraph 3.20 adds that "automatic fire suppression" with a fire-resisting partition and door is another way to protect an open-plan area. Escape windows, in paragraph 3.8, need an openable area, free of obstruction, of at least 0.33m2. These are matters for the designer and for building control, and we bring them up during the survey so that the written price rests on the right plan. See Velux and skylight installation.
A planning question
Who decides a roof light application, given the National Landscape?
Monmouthshire County Council decides it. That designation labels the land and is not itself the planning authority. Building control sits with the same council, or with a registered building control approver, and the two applications are made separately.
In a protected landscape, the planning question comes before the first measurement.















