The aim of a slate repair is to put right what has failed and leave undisturbed what has not. A slate roof is built in overlapping layers, each slate covered at its head by the slates two courses above. That overlap is the headlap, and it is why one slate can be lifted out and replaced without taking the roof apart.
Whether that is the right job depends on one question: is the fault in the slate, or in whatever holds it? A cracked slate is a small repair. A slope whose nails have rusted through is a different matter, and patching it only moves the problem along. We look at the whole slope before deciding which it is, and the photographs we take put that evidence in front of you.
The sections below follow the survey: reading the slope, mending single slates, the skyline details, the case for a repair, the signs that patching has run out, and what England and Wales each require. For the wider subject, see our slate roofing page.
Reading the slope before touching it
We start with the whole slope rather than the one slate that dripped. From the ground, a slate roof shows lines: courses that sag, slates that sit proud, patches of a different colour where earlier repairs were made. From the loft, daylight at a joint and dark tide marks on the battens show where water has been getting in. Then we go up and photograph each fault with its position noted against the nearest chimney or gable.
The pattern of faults tells us more than any single one. A slate or two out of line is a small matter, while the same fault spread across one area points at the fixings under it.
| What we see | What it points to |
|---|---|
| One slate out of line | A failed nail, or a crack at the nail hole |
| Slates slipping in one area | Fixings failing across that area |
| Flaking, layered edges | The slate itself breaking down |
| A gap at the ridge or valley | Bedding or lead, with the slates sound |
SPAB's phrase for these roofs is "predominantly double-lapped": each slate is held by its own fixing and shielded by the slates above it. When a slate slips, a hole opens in that layering, and the underlay below is all that stands between the hole and the loft. Reading the pattern first stops us treating a symptom as the cause, and it tells us how far to look beyond the visible fault before any slate is touched.
Mending slipped, cracked and missing slates
A single slate is replaced from within the slope. The nails of the broken slate are cut with a slate ripper, a long flat tool slid up under the slate and hooked on the nail shanks. The remains come out, and a matching slate is slid into the gap.
The new slate cannot be nailed through its head, because the course above is in the way. It is held by a tingle instead: a narrow clip, cut from lead or copper, whose foot is nailed to the batten while its free end is bent up across the slate's tail. A lone tingle in an otherwise sound slope is an accepted, long-established repair, and it leaves the surrounding courses undisturbed.
The slate chosen for the gap decides how the repair looks and performs:
- length and width matched to the courses either side, so the overlap stays even
- a similar thickness, so the course does not tilt
- a colour and weathering that sit close to the old slates, which is where reclaimed slate comes in
- a sound batten under the gap, checked before the slate goes in
A cracked slate that is still held by its nail can sometimes be left. A crack across the nail hole means the slate is no longer fixed and will slip, so it comes out. On a roof that already carries a row of tingles, we look at the nails across the slope rather than adding one more clip to the row, because a row of clips can mean the original nails have given up.
Skyline repairs: ridge, valleys and lead
A leak under a slate roof does not always mean a slate is at fault. Ridge bedding, a lifted verge or a worn valley lining can let water in with every slate around them sound. We go to those joints first, in the same order we use on every roof: ridge, verge, chimney, valleys, then the open slopes.
At the ridge, Marley says that since the 2015 amendments to BS 5534 mortar "could no longer be relied upon as the only means of securing the roof covering", so a rebuilt ridge carries a mechanical fixing as well. BS 8612 covers dry-fix systems. On a slate roof the ridge fittings are picked to suit the slate and the slope.
Where a slate roof has lead valleys and flashings, the repair is a question of how much sound lead is left. MyJobQuote says correctly installed lead flashing "can last for over 80 years", which is a hedge about a good installation, not a promise about an old one. A split in a valley gutter or a lifted soaker is patched, replaced or re-dressed depending on what the lead is like. Royston Lead's table gives codes 4 to 8 for pitched valley gutters, and says of Code 3: "Recommended for lead soakers only".
The detail is covered in our guide to lead details on a slate roof, which takes soakers, valleys and abutments in turn. We photograph a repair at any of these joints before and after, which lets you compare the finished joint with the one we found.
Weighing a repair against a re-slate
A repair is the sensible buy where the damage is confined to one spot and the slope around it holds firm. The long lives published for slate support that: HomeBuilding's table gives Welsh slate "100+ years" and Spanish natural slate 75 to 100 years, and SPAB says a well-slated roof is "likely to be more than 100 years". Those are typical ranges, never promises, but they explain why a slate roof is worth mending in a way that some other coverings are not.
Checkatrade's June 2026 rates for natural slate repairs run from £150 to £220 per m², ex VAT, on repair areas up to 3 m².
Other third-party numbers give scale, and none of them is our quote:
- MyJobQuote averages a 2026 roof repair at around £650
- MyJobQuote puts fitting a slate roof at around £7,800 on average
- HomeBuilding's example is a 65 m² semi, where Welsh slate "might reach £18,000"
A rate per m² for a small repair cannot price a whole slope, and it is never multiplied into a total. Your figure is one written price, given after the survey and set beside the cost of stripping and re-covering. Where the repair is the sensible buy, that is the job we recommend, and the photographs show why.
A repair also leaves the date of the eventual re-slate undecided. If the survey shows the nails are sound, the roof carries on, and the next look comes at the next visit. If the survey instead shows a slope near the end of its working life, you hear that at the same time, with the photographs, so the repair is never presented as more than it is.
When patching stops being the answer
Some faults are symptoms. Slates that slip, are refixed, and slip again within a season are showing that the nails under them have given up. A roof in that state has nail sickness, where fixings have rusted through or worked loose while the slates themselves are fine. Our guide to nail sickness on a slate roof explains how it differs from random damage.
These findings point towards re-slating the slope:
- nails failing in many courses, not in one patch
- battens that are soft, rotted or split along the line of the nails
- slates delaminating across the slope, so that replacing them one by one chases the problem
- underlay that has perished, found when slates are lifted for a repair
Re-slating does not mean new slates. The sound ones come off, are sorted and go back on new nails, battens and underlay, with any shortfall made up from matching or reclaimed stock. Our re-slating guide describes it step by step.
We show you the failed nails and rotted battens on your own roof before recommending it. A stripped slope is a larger job, and it should rest on evidence you have seen, not on a general feeling that the roof is old.
When a slope is re-slated, the slates that come off sound are counted and graded, so you know how many are being reused and how many replacements the job needs. That count goes on the quote, which means the work is described in slates and not in guesses.
Approval, access and safety on a repair
Replacing slates one for one is lighter work than re-covering a slope, and the approval rules mark that difference separately in each country:
- In England, the Planning Portal's two tests are "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope'" and "Less than 50 per cent of the roof"; inside both, it does not expect a Building Regulations application as a rule.
- In Wales, the Welsh Government begins from the opposite end for re-roofing: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval."
Listing adds a consent step to repairs that touch the building's character, however small they are. The statute is section 7 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 in England, and sections 88 and 89 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 in Wales. Talk to the council before the first slate moves.
On site, a slate roof is slippery and slates can crack underfoot, so we spread our weight on roof ladders and boards rather than walking the slope. If you must look yourself, do it from the ground or the loft, with binoculars, a torch and a camera. Scaffold, where the job needs it, is priced into the written quote.
Weather decides the order of work. Slate is not laid or repaired on a wet, slippery slope if the day can be changed, and a temporary cover is a sensible stop-gap over an open hole while the right slate is found. Your own part is to keep people and belongings clear of the room under the damage until the repair is done.
