01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Nail sickness

What is nail sickness on a slate roof?

A slate roof can lose slates while the stone is sound, because the nails holding them have corroded or worn through. That fault is called nail sickness.

In brief

Nail sickness means the nails behind a slate roof are giving up. Each slate is hung from a batten, a timber lath crossing the rafters, and when its nails weaken the slate drifts out of line even though the stone is undamaged. A few can be held back with a hook or a tingle, a small metal strip. Slates dropping across a whole slope point to fixings that are all near the end of their life.

How a slate hangs, and where its nail gives out

Every slate is holed near its top edge and fixed to a batten. In a double-lapped roof, which SPAB says Welsh slate and stone roofs predominantly are, each slate covers the nail heads of the course below. The fixing is hidden from the day the roof is finished, so nobody sees a nail weaken.

That is where nail sickness starts. A nail that has rusted through, worn thin against the slate or lost its grip in the batten stops carrying the weight. The slate may be perfectly sound. It drops until the course below stops it, or it lands in the gutter.

A slate can outlast its nails. HomeBuilding gives Welsh slate a lifespan of 100+ years, and SPAB expects a roof that is properly slated to last more than 100 years, as a likelihood rather than a promise. Those are ranges for the slates, not promises, and they say nothing about the fixings behind them.

An old batten can add to the problem. Timber that has gone soft holds a nail badly, so a sick roof is sometimes a fixing problem and a timber problem together.

Signs of nail sickness, from the path and up close

The first sign is a slate that has moved. Because the fault sits under the courses above, we read it from the pattern of what has slipped, not from any single slate.

A survey starts on the skyline with ridge, verges and chimney, and then moves lower, slope by slope. The photographs record:

  • slates sitting lower than the course lines either side of them
  • fallen slates among the gutter debris or lodged on a lower roof
  • slates that move under a gentle hand
  • rust staining below nail holes, where a nail head shows
  • gaps where bare batten or underlay can be seen

One slipped slate on its own can follow a knock from a branch or a ladder. Slates slipping across one slope, or in lines running up the roof, point to nails of the same age failing in turn. The photographs let you tell which of the two you have before a price is written.

Nothing on the ground can confirm the diagnosis. It needs a ladder and a hand on the slates.

Holding the slates, or stripping and re-slating

A whole slate that has slipped goes back into its course, held at its bottom edge by a slate hook or a tingle: a narrow strip of metal, tacked to the batten and bent up around the tail. Cupa, the slate maker, rules out hooks on slopes below 25 degrees, so a shallow slope takes a tingle or a reworked patch. The guide to nails or hooks for slates compares the two.

When the nails are failing widely, holding slates one at a time only postpones the next fall. The lasting answer is to strip the slope, check the battens, and re-fix the sound slates on new nails, topping up with matching slates for any that are cracked. The page on re-slating a roof sets out how that goes.

For a patch, Checkatrade's June 2026 guide gives natural slate repairs at £150 to £220 per m², excluding VAT, on a rate worked up to a maximum of 3 m². For a whole roof, MyJobQuote puts fitting a slate roof at an average of around £7,800. The two are different jobs, so the figures are never added or multiplied together.

England and Wales test a re-slate differently

Fixing a few slates and re-slating a slope are treated differently, and the border changes the test.

  • England: the Planning Portal sets two thresholds for re-roofing without a Building Regulations application, less than 25 per cent of the total building envelope and less than 50 per cent of the roof.
  • England: the Planning Portal treats a second trigger for approval: a new covering whose weight is 15 per cent or more above the old.
  • Wales: for the Welsh Government, re-roofing in most situations needs Building Regulations approval, while its roof page leaves a repair or re-cover under 25 per cent of a pitched or flat roof's area outside a normal application.

A listed house needs consent too, under section 7 of the 1990 Act in England and under sections 88 and 89 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 in Wales.

Before any slate comes off, we confirm which side the house stands on and ask the council's building control team when the work sits near a threshold. Once we have surveyed, a single written price follows, with the photographs beside it. Our slate roofing page covers the wider subject.

Related questions

Can nail sickness be cured without taking the roof off?

Not across a whole slope. Hooks and tingles close individual gaps, and they suit a few slipped slates. The rest of the slope hangs on nails put in at the same time, so a roof that keeps shedding slates needs the slope stripped and re-fixed. A short survey will show which of the two you have.

Does a slipped slate always mean nail sickness?

No. A single slate can be knocked loose by a ladder, a branch or a clumsy foot, and its nails may be sound. The pattern tells the story: slates slipping in lines, or across one slope, point to fixings failing together. We photograph that pattern so you can judge it yourself.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing