In brief
No. Cupa, a slate producer, states that its hook fixings are not for any slope pitched under 25 degrees. A roof under that angle keeps its slates on nails, and a single slipped slate on it is held with a tingle, which is a short strip of metal, or by reworking the patch around it. Because everything turns on the angle, we measure the real pitch of each slope with a level before we pick a fixing.
What a hook does, and the 25 degree limit
A slate hook is a stiff wire clip. It is driven into the batten, the timber lath that runs level across the roof, and it catches the bottom edge of a slate so that the slate cannot slide out of its row. Roofers use hooks where a nail would mean lifting a lot of slates, or on a roof where the original nails are tired.
Cupa's guidance draws a firm line at 25 degrees: nothing shallower gets a hook. We read that as a limit, not a preference, and we do not stretch it because a slope is only a little under.
It helps to picture the angle. Pitch is measured from the horizontal, so a 25 degree slope climbs a little under half a metre for every metre it runs back from the eaves. A roof that looks steep from the lane can still fall short on one slope. A porch roof, a side lean-to or a rear extension can sit shallower than the main roof it joins, and the old measurement of the main roof does not carry over.
Hooks, then, are a tool for steeper slopes, and a competent repair on a shallow one is slower work with nails. The rest of this page covers what we use when the angle is too low for one.
Measuring the pitch before choosing a fixing
We do not estimate a pitch from the ground. On the day of the survey we take a reading from each slope, because one house can carry several pitches, and a repair belongs to one slope only. A figure read off an old drawing is not good enough, since roofs get altered.
- Lay a digital level along a rafter, or along a straight batten sitting on the slates.
- Read the angle in degrees and photograph the screen against the roof.
- Repeat on every slope the repair touches, including any extension.
- Write the readings into the survey notes that go with your quote.
With the number in hand, the angle tells us which route is open and which is closed:
| Slope | Route |
|---|---|
| 25 degrees or steeper | Hook fixings are allowed by Cupa |
| Under 25 degrees | No hooks; nails, a tingle or a reworked patch |
| Under 20 degrees | Below Cupa's stated slate minimum, so ask the supplier |
The reading is yours to keep, and it is worth having if the roof is ever re-covered.
What holds a slate on a shallow roof
With hooks ruled out, three routes remain. Which one fits comes down to the extent of the damage.
- Fresh nails: where a slate and the course above can be lifted, the slate is nailed through its own holes into the batten, the way it was first laid. This is the standard fixing and the one Cupa's limit steers us back to.
- A tingle: a thin ribbon of lead or copper, fixed to the batten by a nail driven through the joint beneath and folded up over the tail of a whole slate that has slipped. Our page on what a tingle is shows one in place.
- A reworked patch: where several slates have lost their nails, the neighbouring courses are lifted, the whole patch is nailed, and the slates go back as they were.
A tingle suits an odd slate, not a slope. If we find a row of them, you see the photographs, because the nails behind the other slates are the same age. The guide to nails or hooks for slates compares the fixings in more depth.
Standards, approval and who decides
Cupa's 25 degree limit is a manufacturer's instruction, so it holds in Hereford and in Abergavenny alike. The standard behind roof fixings is BS 5534. Marley, a tile maker, notes that installing to BS 5534 is not required by law, which is why the manufacturer's data is the line we follow.
The angle does not alter the approvals a bigger job needs, and those run differently in each country:
- In England, the Planning Portal puts the trigger at a covering 15 per cent heavier or more than the old one, and Building Regulations approval follows.
- In Wales, the Welsh Government gives slate replaced by tiles as a likely case for Building Regulations approval.
Putting nails in place of hooks on a few slates is repair work and not a re-roof. A whole slope re-slated is another matter, and the written quote names the rules that apply at your address. If another firm offers hooks on a slope you know to be shallow, ask for the pitch reading in writing and check it against Cupa's limit.
For slopes near the limit, see the lowest pitch for natural slate, which sits under slate roofing.
