In brief
Yes. HomeBuilding gives supply-only prices of £185 per m² for Welsh slate and £72 per m² for Spanish, so Welsh costs a little over two and a half times as much for the slate alone. For a 65 m² semi it puts plain concrete tiles at £10,000 to £15,000 while Welsh slate over the same rafters, it says, might come to £18,000. Other sources give lower averages, so these are published figures and not our price.
The figures HomeBuilding publishes
HomeBuilding's cost guide, last updated on 30 September 2025, is the source for the comparison. It gives three numbers that matter here:
- Welsh slate, supply only: £185 per m².
- Spanish natural slate, supply only: £72 per m².
- For a three-bedroom semi with a 65 m² roof, the guide says plain concrete tiles may cost between £10,000 and £15,000, and that a roof in Welsh slate could climb as far as £18,000.
The first two are prices per square metre of slate, with no labour in them. The third is a whole-roof estimate for one house, including labour, scaffolding and insulation. The guide also warns of dearer labour in London and the south-east, and adds that remote places can carry travel premiums, so a national figure is no guide to a Hereford price.
We do not turn the per-m² prices into a total. The same guide quotes other per-m² figures in its text, so any sum built from one line would be a guess. What the two numbers do show is the ratio, and that is why the answer to the question is yes.
Why the gap narrows on a whole roof
On a complete roof the stone is one item among several. The timber work, underlay, battens, lead details, scaffold and labour cost much the same under either slate, so a big difference in the price of the slate becomes a smaller one in the price of the roof.
HomeBuilding's own whole-roof figures show this. Its Welsh slate estimate of up to £18,000 is above the £10,000 to £15,000 it gives for plain concrete tiles, but it is not several times higher.
Where you see a very low quote for slate work, it is worth asking which slate is in it. A Spanish slate priced as though it were Welsh is a poor swap, and a Welsh slate quoted at the Spanish price is a warning sign.
When you ask us for a price, our quote is written as a single total, and the slate it proposes is named in the first lines. If you want to see the effect of a different slate, ask for both options and compare the two totals. Where the roof is a repair rather than a replacement, the slates are chosen to suit the existing roof, and the question of which is dearer does not arise.
Other published figures, and why they differ
Third-party guides may not agree, which is why we name each source and its date.
| Source | Figure |
|---|---|
| HomeBuilding, 30 September 2025 | Welsh slate roof for a 65 m² semi might reach £18,000 |
| MyJobQuote | Fitting a slate roof, an average of around £7,800 |
| Which?, November 2025 survey, excluding VAT | Replacing an entire roof on an average three-bed house, £7,000 to £21,000 |
Each was built on a different house, a different method and a different mix of materials, so the lowest and highest cannot be laid side by side as if they described one roof, and not one of them prices your own house, which only a survey can do.
For repairs, Checkatrade's June 2026 rates, excluding VAT, are £90 to £120 per m² for concrete tiles, £110 to £160 for clay and £150 to £220 for natural slate, on patches up to 3 m². Those are per-m² rates for small patches and are never multiplied by a roof's area.
Our page on new slate roof costs and the note on slate repair cost per m² go further into each.
Paying for lifespan, and the rules if you switch
A dearer slate buys a longer typical life. HomeBuilding's approximate ranges are 100 or more years for Welsh slate, 75 to 100 for Spanish and 40 to 50 for plain concrete tiles, and our page on how long Welsh slate lasts sets them out. Those are ranges, not promises, and nobody can say what your roof will do.
Changing from slate to another covering raises approval questions, and the answers diverge between the countries:
- England: according to the Planning Portal, a covering 15 per cent heavier or more needs Building Regulations approval, while a re-roof affecting less than 25 per cent of the building envelope and less than 50 per cent of the roof normally calls for none.
- Wales: the Welsh Government's re-roofing page expects Building Regulations approval in most situations, and cites slate swapped for tiles as a case where approval is probable.
Staying with slate keeps the weight about the same, though the survey still checks the roof timbers and the fixings, because old timber can be weaker than it looks. The full range of covering choices sits under slate roofing.
