01432 610152 Get a quote Call 01432 610152

Re-slating and insulation

Insulating when you re-slate: England and Wales

A stripped slate roof is the easiest time to upgrade the insulation, and the Building Regulations take an interest in that moment. This guide sets out what each nation requires.

Horizon Roofing Hereford 9 min read

When a slate roof is re-slated, the slates come off, the battens and underlay come off with them, and for a few days the rafters stand bare. It is the clearest view you will ever get of what lies between the house and the weather, and the simplest time to put more insulation into the roof. Once the new slates are on, reaching the rafters means working from inside the loft, or from the room below.

The law has an interest in that moment too. The Building Regulations classify a roof as one of a building's thermal elements, and the treatment of re-covering one is not the same in England and Wales. England decides by the Planning Portal's thresholds and then by the renovation values in Approved Document L. Wales starts from the Welsh Government's statement that approval will be needed in most cases, and ties re-covering to better insulation.

We set out each side in turn, then where the insulation goes, what to ask about moisture, and how the survey and quote handle it. For the wider service, see our slate roofing page, and for the stripping and relaying itself, the guide to re-slating a roof.

Why a re-slate is the moment to insulate

A slate roof is nailed or hooked to battens, which are fixed over an underlay, which lies over the rafters. To add insulation above the rafters, all three layers have to come off. To add it between the rafters, the underlay has to come off or be lifted. Both are routine on a re-slate and awkward at any other time.

A roof that is only repaired does not give the same opening. Slipping one slate back, or replacing a handful of broken ones, leaves the structure as it was. That is why the rules turn on the extent of the re-covering, and not on the bare fact that something was fixed.

The Welsh Government's guidance links the two jobs: since the roof is one of the building's thermal elements, re-covering it is the point at which its insulation should be improved too. England reaches a similar place through thresholds rather than a stated principle.

Four things are worth settling before slates come off:

  • the extent of the re-slating, as an area and as a share of the whole roof
  • what insulation is in the loft or rafters now, and its condition
  • how tightly the ceiling below is sealed against warm air rising
  • whether the house is listed, where consent comes first

None of these needs a ladder. They need a look in the loft, a photograph of the rafters, and a note of the loft hatch and the light fittings that pierce the ceiling.

England: the approval test and the renovation figures

In England, the Planning Portal's test for no application has two parts: "Less than 25 per cent of the total 'building envelope'" affected, and "Less than 50 per cent of the roof". That envelope takes in the walls, the floor, the roof and every window, door and roof-light. A full re-slate of an ordinary house takes the roof side of that test far past 50 per cent, so approval is in play.

Where Building Regulations apply, Approved Document L 2021 supplies the figures for renovating an existing roof. Table 4.3 gives a threshold of 0.35 and a target of 0.16, in W/(m²K). Paragraph 4.13 allows a fallback. Where 0.16 cannot be reached in practice, or the payback would run past 15 years, the roof is brought to the best figure that does repay within that time, and as a general rule no worse than 0.7.

From 24 March 2027, AD L 2026 takes over in England, with its tables renumbered 3.2 and 3.3. Until then the 2021 edition governs. Table 4.2 covers new roofs only and is a separate question from renovation.

On planning, Class C of the 2015 Order covers re-roofing, so changing the covering is normally permitted development in England. No part of an alteration may stand taller than the original roof's highest point, and insulation built on top of the rafters thickens the roof, so that limit can matter at the ridge. Conservation areas do not bar Class C in England. A listed house adds a consent requirement, under section 7 of the 1990 Act.

Wales: re-covering and the 0.16 target

Wales takes a different route. The Welsh Government's re-roofing page begins from approval: "In most situations, this work will need Building Regulations approval." Its roof page adds that an insulation upgrade would normally follow when more of the roof is replaced. A full re-slate sits far above any such line.

The figures are in the Welsh Approved Document L. Table 11.1 gives a renovated pitched roof 0.16, with 0.35 as the limiting value where 0.16 is out of reach. The whole roof element is upgraded once the renovated area passes 50% of it (paragraph 11.14). If 0.16 cannot be met on grounds of cost, function or technique, paragraphs 11.20 and 11.21 allow the best figure that is feasible, generally no worse than 0.35, with payback of the initial cost within 15 years.

Renovating a slate roof: England and Wales compared
PointEnglandWales
Approval starting pointPlanning Portal envelope and roof testNeeded in most situations
Renovation figure0.35 threshold, 0.16 improved0.16, worst 0.35
New roof figureTable 4.2Table 4.1, 0.13
Next edition24 March 20274 March 2027

In Wales, Class C.2(a) of the planning order asks that the finish stay close to the old covering's appearance, so far as is practicable, which re-slating in slate does. Where the house is in a conservation area or the Bannau Brycheiniog, ask the council or the Park Authority about matters beyond the covering. Our guide to re-slating in Wales and matching the old roof covers that side.

Where the insulation goes and what it does to moisture

Insulation in a pitched roof goes in one of three places: at ceiling level in the loft, between the rafters, or above them. Each changes how moisture moves, and moisture is the thing to plan for.

With the insulation at the ceiling and a high-resistance underlay above the rafters, Marley gives eaves openings of 25 mm for pitches up to 15 degrees and 10 mm above that. Cupa's BS 5534 example puts the lowest natural-slate pitch at 20 degrees, assuming moderate exposure, a 500 mm slate and a 115 mm overlap, so a slate roof sits in the 10 mm band. Underlay of the high-resistance kind does not let vapour through. An air-permeable underlay over a tight ceiling is treated differently by Marley: ordinary eaves construction (3mm) is all the ventilation needed, provided the certification conditions are met.

Spray foam needs particular care:

  • Of the two foams, open-cell lets more vapour through, in the Energy Saving Trust's account, while closed-cell does not.
  • Foam sprayed directly onto the roof's underside partly seals the timber, and the trust says the rot risk "should be much lower" with open-cell foam.
  • RICS reported lender concern in March 2023, equity release lending being one example. Before any spraying, confirm with your mortgage provider that the lender allows it.

Which route suits depends on the roof, and we explain the options with the moisture path in mind and the ventilation kept clear. Our slate pitch and headlap guide covers how pitch limits the options.

Bats, nests and a roof that is open

An open roof is an open habitat. Stripping slates exposes the gaps under laps, the ridge and the wall plate, where birds and bats can be sheltering. The law protects both, and the rules need respecting before the first slate is lifted, not after.

Section 1 of the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 is breached when someone intentionally takes, damages or destroys an active nest, meaning one in use or being built. Bats are covered more tightly. Under section 9(4), anyone who intentionally or recklessly upsets a bat in its roost, or obstructs its entrance, commits an offence. Regulation 43 of the Habitats Regulations adds an offence of damaging a roost used for breeding or resting, and no intent is needed. On GOV.UK, the bat guidance warns that roof work is one of the activities that can affect bats.

Which body licenses the work differs by nation:

  • England: Natural England, whose guidance says a licence may be available
  • Wales: Natural Resources Wales, which requires an application where work affects a protected species

Should a bat or a nest be found, the work in that area halts, we photograph what is there, and we tell you who to contact. Slating is then planned around that advice. A stripped roof is a reason to have a survey before the first slate comes off, so that roosts and nests are looked for while the roof is still whole, and so that the programme allows for a pause if one is found.

Weight, heritage, cost and the written total

Insulation can come with a change of covering. If the new covering weighs more, the Planning Portal says Building Regulations approval is needed where it increases the weight "by 15 per cent or more", and the English Approved Document A puts a significant change in roof loading at "more than 15%". The Welsh Government's example of a different covering is slate replaced by tiles, so approval is likely for the structure, fire safety and energy performance.

Listed houses need consent for works that affect them, whichever slate is chosen. In England that is section 7 of the 1990 Act, and in Wales section 88 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023. Check with the council before ordering anything.

On cost, published ranges for a whole roof give a sense of scale. Which? (November 2025 survey, ex VAT) gives £7,000 to £21,000 for replacing the whole roof of an average three-bed house. HomeBuilding says a Welsh slate roof for a 65 m² semi "might reach £18,000". MyJobQuote gives an average of around £7,800 for fitting a slate roof. These are third-party ranges for different scopes, and none is a price for your house.

One written total reaches you after the survey. Scaffold and the clearing of waste are in it, and it states the VAT position. Photographs of the rafters are taken before the underlay goes on, so the layers beneath the new slates are on record. A replacement is offered only when a repair would not last.

Re-slating and insulation: questions

Does re-slating a roof in Wales mean improving the insulation?

The Welsh Government links re-covering a roof with improving its insulation. Table 11.1 of the Welsh Approved Document L gives a renovated roof 0.16, with 0.35 as the worst acceptable value where 0.16 is not feasible. Ask the council or a registered approver what applies to your roof.

What U-value applies to a re-slated roof in England?

AD L 2021 Table 4.3 gives a roof a threshold of 0.35 and a target of 0.16 W/(m²K). Paragraph 4.13 eases the target where the work is impractical or the payback runs beyond 15 years. Building control, whether the council or a registered approver, confirms whether the rules reach your particular re-slate.

Can I add spray foam under the slates when I re-slate?

It is possible, with care. The Energy Saving Trust says open-cell foam lets more vapour pass than closed-cell. RICS wants you to confirm with your mortgage provider that the lender allows it, so ask your lender, and building control, before you decide. Where foam is already on the roof, removing it is a separate question.

Get your free roof quote

Tell us about the roof and we will arrange a survey.

10-year workmanship guarantee, in writing