In brief
In England, yes: the Class C condition covers every window on a side-slope, and the glass must be obscure. The opening parts must stay shut unless they sit more than 1.7 metres above the floor. In Wales, Class C.2(b) bites only where the window would fall within 10.5 metres of the boundary of the curtilage opposite the side elevation. Inside that distance it must be obscure and non-opening below 1.7 metres.
England: obscure glass in every case
The English condition is Class C.2 of the 2015 order. It is aimed at a window in the slope that forms a side of the house, and it makes two demands of that window.
The first demand is that the window must be obscure-glazed. The second is that it must be non-opening, unless the parts that can be opened are more than 1.7 metres over the floor of that room. The height is taken from that floor, which is why a window set high in a sloping ceiling can qualify for the relaxation while one beside a bed does not.
The two parts do different jobs. Obscure glazing applies to every such window, whatever its height. The 1.7 metre figure relaxes only the second part, so a window whose opening parts are above that height may open, but its glass stays obscured.
A side elevation is a side of the house, not the front or the back, so the slope in question is the one that faces the side of the plot. The condition attaches to the window you add under Class C, not to a window that was already there when the work began.
Wales: a boundary test comes first
Wales still works under the 1995 order. The test in Class C.2(b) is one of distance. Take any part of the new window, drop it straight down to the ground, and ask whether that point lies within 10.5 metres of a boundary of the curtilage opposite the side elevation. If it does, the condition applies. If every part of the window falls further away, it does not.
If it does, the window must be:
- obscure-glazed
- non-opening, apart from any part that can be opened at a height of at least 1.7 metres over the floor or stair beneath it
- permanently kept that way
The Welsh Government's plain summary words the distance as within 10.5 metres of a side boundary. The order itself speaks of the boundary opposite the relevant side elevation, and that is the wording we follow. A window further away than that is outside C.2(b), though every other Class C condition still applies to it, and a position near the boundary opposite is worth measuring with care. On a narrow plot, a few hundred millimetres along the slope can decide which side of the 10.5 metre line a window falls, so the measurement is taken twice.
Side by side, and the other conditions
The two rules compare like this:
| Point | England, C.2 | Wales, C.2(b) |
|---|---|---|
| When it applies | Every side-slope window | Within 10.5 metres of the boundary opposite |
| Obscure glass | Always | Only within that distance |
| Opening parts | Shut unless more than 1.7 m up | Shut unless at least 1.7 m up |
Why does the rule exist? The orders do not say, but the effect is to stop a new window looking into the neighbouring plot from a side slope, and the glass requirement is the means of doing it. That explains why the English rule is blunt, and why the Welsh rule turns on how close the boundary is.
Other conditions apply on top. Both countries limit how far a window projects, and in Wales Class C gives a roof light no cover on article 1(5) land. A listed house needs consent too, in either country. Each condition is quoted in our planning guide for England and Wales, and side-slope roof windows and obscure glass looks at the glass itself.
Checking the position on the survey
When we survey, we work out which slope counts as a side elevation, mark where the window will sit, and measure out to the boundary opposite where that matters. The slope and the boundary are photographed, and the height of the opening parts above the floor is noted.
Where the window has to be obscure, we choose a pane that still lets the daylight in, and we confirm with the maker that the pattern and the level of obscurity suit what the planning condition asks. If the position fails the rules, a window on the back slope may be easier, and you are told so before anything is ordered. Your council can confirm how Class C applies to your house. If the house is listed, consent is the first question.
After the survey the price is given as a written total, covering the window, the flashing, the lining and the obscure pane if one is needed. The wider range of work is listed under Velux and skylights, and the neighbouring limit on depth is explained in how far a roof window can stick out.
