Ask what energy standard a new roof window must meet and you will hear two numbers: 1.4 and 2.2. Both are real. They apply to different products, and mixing them up is an easy slip in quotes, and in conversations with building control about roof glazing. A roof window uses the figure on the window row: 1.4, or WER Band B. The figure of 2.2 belongs to rooflights.
The roof around the window has its own figure again, and the border matters here. In England an existing home that gets a new roof is held to 0.15, while in Wales the figure is 0.13. When a roof is renovated rather than built new, each country uses a different test again, and a loft conversion lands in that renovation group.
The sections that follow take each figure in turn, name the table it comes from, and keep the two countries apart. They also cover the dates on which the rules move, because both countries have a new edition of the energy document coming in March 2027. Other window work is covered on our Velux and skylight page.
The three figures side by side
The energy figures live in Approved Document L, volume 1 (dwellings). Each country publishes its own edition, and the numbers for glazing happen to match while the numbers for the roof do not. The U-value measures how fast heat passes through an element, written W/(m²·K), and a lower figure means less heat lost.
| Element | England | Wales |
|---|---|---|
| Roof window | 1.4 or WER Band B (Table 4.2) | 1.4 or minimum WER Band B (Table 4.1) |
| Rooflight | 2.2 (Table 4.2) | 2.2 (Table 4.1) |
| New roof | 0.15 (Table 4.2) | 0.13 (Table 4.1) |
England's Table 4.2 carries a note on its window row: "Including roof windows and curtain walling". Wales words the row "Window or roof window". In both countries, then, a roof window counts as a window for energy purposes, and the window row is its row.
The Window Energy Rating, WER, is a rating scheme for whole windows, and the rules accept Band B as the minimum in place of the 1.4 U-value. Nothing more is claimed here about how Band B compares with the other bands: the document sets Band B as the floor, and a supplier's rating label tells you where a particular window sits. When a quote says only "meets Building Regulations", ask which figure it has been checked against, and on which edition of the document. A properly written quote names the row it relies on.
Why the 2.2 figure gets applied to roof windows
The mix-up has a reason. Both products are panes of glass set in a roof, and a quote that says "rooflight" for either one invites the looser figure. The two rows sit next to each other in the tables, and 2.2 is the larger number, so it is the easier one to meet. Quoting it against a roof window understates what that window must achieve.
The way to settle which row applies is to look at the product, not the word on the quote. A manufactured roof window sold with a data sheet and a rating label belongs on the window row. A fixed glazed unit built into a roof, such as a flat one, is what the trade calls a rooflight. Where the product is ambiguous, building control or a registered building control approver decides, and it is better to ask before the order than after the fit. Our guide to rooflight or roof window sets out how the two differ.
Three checks avoid the problem on a job:
- Ask for the U-value or the WER rating in writing, from the maker's data sheet.
- Check that the figure on the sheet is at or below 1.4, or that the rating is Band B or better.
- Keep the sheet with the building control paperwork, so the figure can be shown later.
The roof insulation figures do not apply to the glass. The definition of thermal element in regulation 2 of the Building Regulations 2010 stops at the walls, floors and roofs; it "does not include windows, doors, roof windows or roof-lights". Glazing is therefore tested on its own rows and never against the roof's U-value.
When the roof is renovated rather than built new
A new window can arrive with work on the roof around it, and renovation has its own tests. Each country sets its own test.
- In England, Table 4.3 of Approved Document L 2021 covers existing elements, including loft conversions: a roof threshold of 0.35, improved to 0.16. Paragraph 4.13 lets you settle for the lowest feasible figure where 0.16 proves out of reach in practice, or the saving takes longer than 15 years to repay, and says that "Generally, a thermal element once upgraded should not have a U-value greater than 0.7W/(m2·K)".
- In Wales, Table 11.1 gives column (a) as 0.16 and column (b) as 0.35, and 0.35 is the worst acceptable figure when 0.16 is not feasible, not a trigger. Paragraph 11.14 applies the upgrade once more than 50% of the element is being renovated, and paragraphs 11.20 and 11.21 set a payback within 15 years as the economic test.
The renovation figure for a roof is 0.16 in both countries, set against 0.35, not 0.15. England's 0.15 and Wales's 0.13 are for an existing dwelling given a wholly new roof, while a loft conversion falls under the renovation test. A flat roof given a fresh membrane is renovation in England, and Wales's paragraph 11.16 says the same.
Welsh Table 10.1, for windows and doors, repeats the glazing figures: "Windows, roof windows" at 1.4 or WER Band B, rooflights at 2.2. It also lists threshold values for retained fittings, 3.3 for windows and 3.8 for rooflights. A roof window that stays in place through a roof job is a retained fitting, and that is where the table applies.
Editions and dates: what applies now, and from March 2027
Rules move, and quoting the wrong edition is another way to get the figure wrong. As the documents stand:
- England: Approved Document L 2021 (2023 amendments) says "This approved document takes effect on 15 June 2022 for use in England". That is the edition in force now, with Tables 4.2 and 4.3.
- England, from 24 March 2027: Approved Document L 2026 takes effect "for building work that is not in connection with higher-risk building work". The tables are renumbered 3.2 and 3.3, with the same values: roof 0.15, window 1.4 or WER Band B, rooflight 2.2. The payback rule becomes paragraph 3.14.
- Wales: the 2022 edition incorporating 2024 amendments, which "takes effect on 23 November 2022 for use in Wales". A successor takes effect on 4 March 2027.
Neither new edition applies today. Building control says which edition applies to a particular job.
Oversight differs as well. Building control in both countries is carried out by the council or by a registered building control approver, and registered approvers register with the Building Safety Regulator. In Wales, the Welsh Government reformed the building control process from 1 July 2026. In practice, that means the route to approval for a roof window in Wales is the council's service or a registered approver, and the paperwork they ask for is the same data sheet.
Planning is a separate set of rules from energy, and our England and Wales planning guide sets out how the two differ.
What this means when a window is fitted
Put together, the glazing figure is the one that follows the product and the roof figure is the one that follows the job. A new roof window is checked against 1.4 or WER Band B. A new roof around it is checked against 0.15 in England or 0.13 in Wales. A renovated roof is checked against 0.16 on either side of the border, with the relaxations above where 0.16 cannot be reached.
On a survey we do four things. We identify whether the existing opening holds a roof window or a rooflight, and note its size. We photograph the roof from inside and out, so the extent of any renovation is clear. We find out which side of the border the address is on, because the tables and the paragraph numbers differ. And we ask the building control body for that address which edition and which route apply, the council or a registered building control approver.
You then receive one written total price. The price follows what the survey finds, including the window specification, and the site is left tidy.
A few other pages help with the detail. The data sheet carries the U-value, and the WER label is part of what that guide covers. Neither replaces the data sheet for the model you are buying, and neither changes the figures above. If the sheet shows a number that sits above 1.4 and no Band B rating, say so to the supplier before the order is placed, not after the frame is in the roof.
Who checks the figures in England and Wales
A roof window that must meet an energy figure needs someone to check that it does. In both countries that is building control, and the choice is between the council's building control team and a registered building control approver. Private building control is not new; what began in 2024 is the register. All private businesses that do building control work in England and Wales must register with the Building Safety Regulator (BSR), and England's registration regulations took effect on 6 April 2024.
The oversight differs. In Wales the BSR acts for the Welsh Ministers, and its remit covers registered building inspectors and registered approvers, while "Local authorities are regulated by the Welsh Ministers". The local contacts differ too:
- Herefordshire Council runs its own building control service, on 01432 261938, at bce@herefordshire.gov.uk.
- Monmouthshire County Council has its own building control service, which wrote of an update to its regime from 1 July 2026.
- For Powys, ask the council's building control service or a registered building control approver.
The paperwork is simple when it is gathered early: the data sheet for the model, the rating label if there is one, the size of the opening, and photographs of the roof from inside and out. We pass these to whichever body covers your address, and the figure on the sheet is what they check against the table.
None of this replaces a planning check where the land is protected. Welsh Class C withholds roof lights from conservation areas, National Parks and National Landscapes, as our guide to Welsh conservation areas and parks sets out.
