A roof window in the front or rear slope of a house faces the road or the back garden. A window in a slope that faces the side of the house is different. It can look straight into a neighbour's garden or a bedroom window, and the planning rules treat it that way. If the glass is clear, the rules are not met.
The condition sits inside the permitted development right for roof alterations, so it only matters where that right applies. The two nations then part company. England asks for obscure glass in every side-slope window, and relaxes only a second requirement about opening. Wales asks for obscure glass and a fixed or high-opening sash only within a set distance of the boundary opposite.
We have set out each rule in turn, with a table to compare them, then covered dormers and extensions, what obscure glass means in practice and how a survey tests the boundary distance. For the wider service, see our Velux and skylight installation page. If you are still choosing between products, read rooflights and roof windows compared first.
Which slopes count as a side elevation
Every house has a principal elevation, its main face, and the rules for roof alterations are written around it. A roof slope that forms a side elevation is a slope that faces towards a neighbouring property or the side boundary of the plot, rather than the road or the back garden. On a simple pitched house with gables at each end, the slopes face front and back, so a side-slope window is unusual. The question comes up on hipped roofs, where a third slope faces the side, and on roofs of side extensions and outriggers, which can present a slope towards the neighbour.
The Order does not give a list of house shapes. Which slope counts is a matter of how the roof lies on your plot, and where a case is borderline the planning team's view decides it. We photograph the roof from the ground, mark each slope against the boundary, and ask the council to confirm any doubtful one before ordering a unit.
On a Welsh house the same slope can pass or fail depending on the plot, which is why the later sections treat the two nations separately. Three points help you check a slope before you call:
- which way the slope faces: road, back garden or side boundary
- whether a neighbour's house or garden lies beyond that boundary
- whether the roof is a hip, an extension or a main pitch
In England, flats have no householder permitted development rights, so a flat sits outside this right and the council decides. A house in a protected area can meet different rules again, as the next sections explain.
England: obscure-glazed, in every case
In England the condition sits in paragraph C.2 of Class C in the 2015 Order. A window in a slope that forms a side elevation of the house has to be obscure-glazed, and non-opening unless every part that opens is higher than 1.7 metres from the room's floor. The wording takes no account of what lies beyond the boundary, so a window facing a blank wall is judged by the same words as one facing a garden. The two requirements are separate. Obscure glass applies to every side-slope window, whatever its height or distance from the boundary. The 1.7 metre height relaxes the non-opening requirement only.
That reading surprises people, because "obscure and fixed unless above 1.7 m" is the common shortcut. It is wrong in England. A window high in the slope still has to be obscure-glazed. The height only decides whether the sash may open.
| Requirement | When it applies in England |
|---|---|
| Obscure-glazed | Every side-slope window |
| Non-opening | Unless the opening part is more than 1.7 m above the floor of the room |
Class C has no article 2(3) exclusion, so the condition is the same in a conservation area, a National Park or a National Landscape in England. A listed house keeps the permitted development right, but needs listed building consent for works that affect it. Where a window cannot meet the condition, the route is a planning application. Our planning guide sets out the wider question.
Wales: the 10.5 metre test
Wales works differently. Paragraph C.2(b) of Class C in the 1995 Order, as amended in Wales, applies the glass condition only where a window element would be within 10.5 metres of a boundary. The measuring rule is exact: if any element of the window, dropped vertically to ground level, would land within 10.5 metres of a boundary of the plot lying opposite that side of the house, the condition bites. If it would, the window must be obscure-glazed, non-opening unless the part that opens is at least 1.7 metres up, and permanently kept that way.
The 1.7 metre height is measured along the lowest edge of the opening part, above the internal floor or stair directly beneath that point. If the window is farther than 10.5 metres from that boundary, paragraph C.2(b) does not apply.
Two further Welsh points matter before the boundary is measured:
- Roof lights are not permitted development on article 1(5) land, which takes in conservation areas, National Parks and National Landscapes, or inside a World Heritage Site, so there the question is planning permission and not glass.
- Paragraph C.2(a) requires the appearance of materials in any exterior work to match the existing house so far as practicable.
The Welsh Government's plain-language page describes the zone as within 10.5 metres of a side boundary. The Order's wording is the boundary opposite the side elevation, and we follow the Order. Inside Bannau Brycheiniog, ask the National Park Authority which planning route applies.
The two rules compared
A house on the border can fall under either rule, and a client who has read an English page about a Welsh house is working from the wrong test. Setting the two out together shows where they differ.
| Question | England (C.2) | Wales (C.2(b)) |
|---|---|---|
| Is there a distance test? | No | Yes, 10.5 m to the boundary opposite |
| Is obscure glass needed? | In every case | Only inside the 10.5 m zone |
| What does 1.7 m change? | Allows an opening part | Allows an opening part |
| Roof lights on protected land? | Not barred | Not permitted development |
In practice the England rule is easy to apply and the Welsh rule needs a measurement. A long garden or a field beside the house can place a Welsh side-slope window outside the zone altogether, while a terrace or a plot squeezed between neighbours puts it well inside. Where we are unsure about the answer, we ask the council before the order goes in, not after the unit has been fitted.
The comparison also shows why a one-line summary on a website is a risk. A page that says obscure glass is always needed is right for England and over-cautious for a Welsh house outside the zone. A page that says the 10.5 metre test applies is right for Wales and wrong for England. Check which nation a page is written for before you rely on it.
Dormers, extensions and what obscure glass means
Side windows also appear on dormers. In England, Class B, the dormer right, requires side windows in an enlargement to be obscure-glazed, and article 2(3) land (conservation areas, National Parks and National Landscapes) removes the right to build a dormer at all. In Wales the dormer right is excluded from article 1(5) land, which covers the same designations, and Class B.1(g) says so. A dormer is a different permission from a roof window, so it needs its own check, and on a listed house it needs consent as well as any planning route.
Obscure glass is glass that lets light through but blocks a clear view. The Order says "obscure-glazed" and does not set a level. If the level matters, for example where a window looks at a close neighbour, choose a pattern that clearly blocks the view, and ask the council if you are unsure. Keep the paperwork from the supplier for the glass.
Points to settle before ordering a side-slope unit:
- the nation, and whether the house stands on protected land
- for Wales, the measured distance to the boundary opposite
- the glass specification and whether the sash may open
- whether the unit is also the escape window for a loft room, covered in our guide to roof windows as escape windows
The fire-escape rules and the planning rules are separate, and both apply to a unit that serves both purposes.
How a survey settles it before anything is ordered
The best moment to find a problem with a side-slope window is before the unit is bought. A survey for one covers the roof and the plot.
On the roof we check the slope that would hold the window, the rafter spacing, the covering and the lining below. On the plot we photograph the boundary beside that slope and, for a Welsh address, measure the distance from the window line down to the boundary opposite. If the figure is close to 10.5 metres, we give you that figure plainly, because a small shift in the position of the window can move it in or out of the zone. The measured distance is written on the survey sheet beside the photograph of the boundary, so there is no argument later about where the window stands against the line.
You receive photographs of the slope and the boundary, a note of which nation's rule applies and why, and a written total price after the survey. The price spells out the position on scaffold and VAT. What drives it:
- the size of the unit and its flashing kit for the covering
- whether obscure glazing is specified as standard or as an option
- whether the opening exists already or rafters need cutting and framing
- the lining and finish inside
If the council's answer is that the window needs a planning application, we tell you before you have paid for a unit, and the decision on whether to apply is yours. On a listed house, consent comes first. England uses the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990, while Wales uses the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023.
