Walk round the loft of a border farmhouse or a Victorian terrace and you will find glass set into the roof in two quite different ways. One is a roof window, a framed unit with an opening sash, fitted into the slope and flush with the tiles or slate around it. The other is a rooflight, a glazed unit on a raised frame over a flat roof or a shallow pitch. People say skylight for both, and that one word hides a real difference.
The difference matters for three reasons. The energy rules list roof windows and rooflights as separate products with separate figures. The planning position for a new roof light on protected land changes at the Welsh border. And the details that keep rain out, such as flashings on a slope or an upstand round a kerb, cannot be swapped between the two.
What follows explains each term, the figure each product must reach, the planning position on either side of the border, and what to weigh before you order. For the wider service, see our Velux and skylight installation page. The figures in detail sit in the guide to roof window energy rules.
Two names for two different jobs
A roof window is made to behave like a window that happens to sit in a roof. It has a frame, a sash that opens, and a flashing kit that laps over the surrounding covering so rainwater runs round the unit and not into it. It belongs on a pitched roof, where it lights a room below and can be reached from inside.
A rooflight is made to bring daylight down through a roof that is flat or nearly flat. It stands on a kerb, a raised timber or composite frame that lifts the glass clear of the roof surface, and the waterproof layer is dressed up the outside of that frame on every side. Some rooflights open and some are fixed. A kerb is the term to learn, because the life of a rooflight depends on how well the roof covering meets it.
| Point | Roof window | Rooflight |
|---|---|---|
| Roof it suits | Pitched slope | Flat or shallow roof |
| How it is sealed | Flashing kit laid into the covering | Membrane turned up a kerb |
| Reached from | A room below, at arm's length | A ladder, or from above the roof |
| Opening | Sash that opens | Fixed or opening |
Some units blur the line. A glazed unit on a kerb over a shallow pitch is closer to a rooflight, and a roof window can be fitted into a low slope with the right kit. When a quote or a drawing uses only one word, we ask which product is meant before anything is ordered, because the word fixes the flashing, the finish inside and the figure the unit must meet.
What the energy rules ask of each
Both sides of the border give each product its own figure. In England, Approved Document L 2021 sets values for new fabric elements fitted to an existing dwelling in its Table 4.2: roof windows follow the window row at 1.4 or WER Band B, whereas rooflights are given a row of their own at 2.2 W/(m²K). In Wales, Welsh Table 4.1 gives the same two figures, with roof windows named in its window row.
One detail trips people up. The Building Regulations 2010 define a thermal element in terms of walls, floors and roofs, and name roof windows and roof-lights as outside it, along with ordinary windows and doors. A unit is therefore judged on its own figure, and the roof round it is a separate matter. England's Table 4.2 gives a new roof 0.15, while Wales's Table 4.1 gives a new roof 0.13.
- England: roof window 1.4 or WER Band B, rooflight 2.2 (AD L 2021, Table 4.2).
- Wales: roof window 1.4 or WER Band B, rooflight 2.2 (Welsh AD L, Table 4.1).
- England: AD L 2026 takes effect on 24 March 2027, and its Table 3.2 repeats these values.
- Wales: a new edition of the Welsh Approved Document L starts on 4 March 2027.
Until those dates, the current editions govern. When you compare two products, read the figure on the data sheet against the one for its own type: a rooflight is measured against 2.2 and a roof window against 1.4 or WER Band B. A rooflight that meets 2.2 is not being held to a lower bar than a roof window that meets 1.4, because the Approved Documents set the two values apart on purpose. Our guide to roof window energy rules works through how to read the label.
Planning on either side of the border
Planning is where the border matters most. In England, Class C of the 2015 Order covers any other alteration to the roof of a dwellinghouse, so adding a roof window or rooflight to a house is normally permitted development. Two limits apply: the unit may not stand more than 0.15 metres proud of the original slope, and its top may not stand higher than the highest part of the original roof. Land under article 2(3), which takes in conservation areas and National Parks, loses the dormer right in Class B, and Class C is untouched.
In Wales, Class C.1(d) of the 1995 Order, as amended there, takes the right away for roof lights on article 1(5) land and in a World Heritage Site. That land includes conservation areas, National Parks and National Landscapes. A new roof light in any of them therefore needs planning permission. The Welsh protrusion limit is stated as 15 centimetres.
- England: a roof window is not barred in a conservation area, although a listed house needs listed building consent as well.
- Wales: no permitted roof light in a conservation area, in Bannau Brycheiniog or in a National Landscape.
- Both sides: a flat has no householder permitted development rights.
Side-slope windows carry extra glazing conditions in both nations, and the guide on side-slope roof windows and obscure glass covers them. For the whole question, including dormers, our planning guide for England and Wales is the place to start.
Building Regulations approval for a new opening
A new opening is structural work. Rafters are cut, the load they carried is passed round the hole through trimming timbers, and the roof around the unit has to be insulated and sealed to the same standard as the rest. That is why the Building Regulations come into the picture even where planning does not. The trimming is a step we photograph, so you can see it before the lining closes it in.
In Wales, the Welsh Government says on its roof light page that "Approval under the Building Regulations will generally be needed for the installation of a new rooflight". We therefore check with the council's building control team, or with a registered building control approver, before the first cut. In England we ask the same body, and the Planning Portal's re-roofing test counts roof windows and roof-lights within the building envelope, which is one more reason a larger scheme deserves an early call.
An application looks at these points:
- the trimmed opening and the timbers that frame it
- the unit's energy figure against Table 4.2 in England or Table 4.1 in Wales
- the size and position of the unit where it serves as the escape window of a loft room, which our guide to roof windows as escape windows explains
Swapping one existing unit for another like-for-like follows a shorter path, which our guide to swapping an old roof window sets out.
Choosing between them for your roof
Start with the roof, not the catalogue. If the slope is a normal pitch and the room below is a loft room, bedroom or landing, a roof window is the natural choice. It opens, it can be cleaned from inside, and its flashing kit is made for tiles, slates or stone slates. On a house in a Welsh conservation area, though, the same room may need a different answer, because a new roof light there needs planning permission before anything is ordered.
If the roof is flat, over a kitchen extension, a converted garage or a hallway, a rooflight on a kerb is the product made for the job. The kerb and its upstand are the details to get right, and the guide to rooflights on flat roofs covers them.
Four questions settle most choices:
- Is the roof pitched or flat?
- Must the unit open, and can you reach it?
- Does the house stand on article 2(3) land in England or article 1(5) land in Wales?
- Is the house listed? If so, consent comes first.
Appearance counts when a unit will be seen from the road. Tiles, slate and stone slates each take their own flashing kit, cut for that covering, so the choice of unit and the choice of kit go together. A framed unit that stands proud of a stone slate roof looks different from one set low in the covering.
What sets the price of each
Published figures give a feel for the market. None is ours and none is specific to Hereford. MyJobQuote says a Velux window replacement costs "around £100 less for a straightforward swap, as the opening is already in place", and puts a small FK04 centre pivot, standard options with manual operation, at around £330, which is a product price and not an installed one. Checkatrade lists rooflight replacement, such as a Velux, from £1,000.
The spread between those figures shows how much depends on the job. These are the factors that move the price of a roof window or rooflight:
- whether the opening exists already, or the rafters must be cut and trimmed
- the size of the unit, and the flashing kit for the covering
- access, including the scaffold, which is included in the written quote
- the lining inside the reveal, the plasterboard and the decoration
- the glazing chosen to meet the energy figure for its type
The written figure follows the survey and names whether VAT is included. We photograph the existing opening and the roof around it, so you can see what we found before you agree anything. If a straight swap is the better buy than a larger scheme, that is the advice you get.
For a first opening the building control fee and any planning application are separate from the fitting, and the council sets them. Ask the council for its current charge before you commit.
