In brief
Yes, expect to need approval. When the Welsh Government wants to show a change of covering that is likely to need Building Regulations approval, it picks slate to tiles, citing the strength of the roof, its fire performance and its energy use. Planning is a separate test, which asks the new covering to be close to the old one or, failing that, to be cleared with the council first.
Why the Welsh Government names slate to tiles
Welsh Government guidance on re-roofing uses this very swap as its worked example, which makes it an unusually direct answer to the question, and one you can point to when you ask the council. Where the original covering gives way to another material, slate to tiles for instance, approval under the Building Regulations is likely to be needed. Three matters sit behind that:
- structural stability, which comes into play where the new tile will be significantly heavier or lighter than what it replaces, and the structure under it has to be shown to cope
- fire safety of the new covering
- energy efficiency of the roof as a whole
The same guidance opens with a general rule: most re-roofing work will need approval. Slate to tiles therefore sits well inside the rule and is no odd exception to it. The guidance also puts roofs among the thermal elements, so re-covering should bring better insulation with it, and our page on U-values in Wales sets out the figures. A Welsh border house with a slate roof therefore faces three checks at once, not one, and each is answered with building control before the order for tiles is placed.
Weight, and the 15% structural check
Paragraph 4.4 of Approved Document A, the Welsh edition for use in Wales, calls a change in roof loading significant when the loading upon the roof is increased by more than 15%, which is a test of the weight of the whole covering, not of one tile. Natural slate and a tile do not weigh the same, and which is heavier depends on the exact products chosen. We compare the data sheets for both, instead of assuming anything from the name of the material.
Where the load rises past that mark, the rafters are checked, along with the wall plates and the walls that carry their weight. The Welsh Government's phrasing reaches the opposite case too, since a replacement that is much lighter alters how the roof sits and behaves, and that is why both heavier and lighter appear in its words.
Fire performance of the covering and the energy upgrade are the other matters, and both go to building control, which means the council or a registered building control approver. Our page on heavier roof covering approval covers the structural check in more depth, and what it asks to see.
Planning: the look of the new covering
In Wales, Class C of the General Permitted Development Order 1995 allows other alterations to the roof of a dwellinghouse, subject to C.2(a): the appearance of the materials must so far as practicable match those of the existing dwellinghouse. The Welsh Government's plain summary asks for materials that match, as far as possible, the ones already on your roof.
Slate to tiles changes the look, so it does not sit safely inside Class C. Put the question to the council before ordering tiles or, for a house inside Bannau Brycheiniog, to the National Park Authority. On article 1(5) land, which takes in conservation areas, National Parks and National Landscapes, a roof light cannot be added under permitted development either, so a re-roof there can raise more than one planning question.
A listed house also needs listed building consent, through the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023, a system in force since 4 November 2024, and that consent is separate from both Building Regulations and the matching test. Our page on changing a roof covering in Wales and planning covers the planning route from start to finish.
Keeping slate, or changing, on a Welsh border house
Some houses should keep their slate. SPAB's term for Welsh slate and stone roofs is predominantly double-lapped, a construction that doubles up the cover across the slope. HomeBuilding gives Welsh slate over 100 years, Spanish slate 75 to 100 years and reclaimed Welsh slate 50 to 80 years, as typical ranges, never promises. For concrete tiles, Marley says around 60 years and HomeBuilding says 40 to 50 years.
Where slate is said to be hard to get, SPAB advises putting any such claim to the quarries. We ask the quarry before proposing a change of covering, so that a delay does not decide the matter, and we tell you what the quarry replied.
The survey photographs the slope as it stands, and the written price is a single total naming the covering and the approval needed. If a repair would keep the slate, and the slope is otherwise sound, the repair comes first, because replacement is only offered when it is the honest answer. See re-roofing a house in Wales and roof replacement for the wider picture.
